18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Surf City

“One of the best pizzas 🍕 we ever had! Fresh toppings and a “crunch” to the crust. Would definitely recommend!“

“Coming from Nebraska and both my husband I being Boys Town Graduates, this taste like home. The service here is always great, pizza always comes out perfect, and really the only bad thing to say is we wish they were in Sneads Ferry where we live as we just don’t drive out to Surf City enough.“

“Fantastic place to eat ! I loved one of their cocktails so much I asked for the recipe and they gave it to me as well! Great ownership and delicious food !“

“We had never tried Max's Pizza until today. We arrived about 1145am, we were greeted immediately, seated at a booth as we requested, and we met Jessica our amazing waitress. Kind, courteous, and quick ! We ordered our drinks, and garlic cheese bread as a starter. It was 10/10 hot, fresh and delicious ! Our pies were cheese, and a pepperoni, we asked for light sauce, and a crispier crust. It was done perfectly 👌. Our pies were delicious, excellent sauce ! Jessica made sure we had everything we needed, during our visit, she was awesome. The bill was about $50, which I consider a bargain for good food and a family of four. I read the reviews for the restaurant before we came, and while everyone is entitled to their opinion, some of them are just malicious. A pizza place, at the beach, is going to be super busy, expect some wait time. An overwhelmed restaurant at peak time, might make a mistake, be patient and kind. This pizza parlor is a hit, and we highly recommend you give it a try !“

“Excellent NY-style Pizza! My extended family and I ordered 2 large "classic" style pizzas to-go recently (1 cheese, 1 pepperoni). It was the best NY-style pizza that I have had in NC. The foldable crust was crisp with great chew. The sauce was flavorful and NOT sweet. There was a good amount of cheese. We were born and raised in Manhattan (NYC) and really enjoyed the pizzas from Michaelangelo's - highly recommend! Also, the workers were very nice and friendly.“

“Best Pizza in North Carolina hands down 🍷🍕❤️🍺🇮🇹“

“Ordered the best pizza i’ve ever had. A unique option, but got chicken, spinach, banana peppers and alfredo instead of red sauce. So good! Also the eggplant parm was excellent. Fast delivery!“

“Only place we order pizza from. If you're one of the many transplants from the north (like me) this pizza is comparable. I know that's a bold statement, but the guy who owns the place is from Brooklyn, he knows what he's doing.“

“Best pizza outside of Long Island! Staff prompt and friendly. The fried calamari melts in your mouth.“

“We’ve had food delivered several times. Food is always hot and fresh. Delivery is quick.“

“Our delivery driver, Tina, brought us really good pizzas and cheesy bread in the middle of this last nasty storm, but they were still hot, and not rained on, even though she was soaked through. AWESOME work ethic, and we were very grateful. Tipped her an extra $10.
Thank you so much, Tina and Papa Johns!“

“Denoias is always my go to comfort food order. I get a personal sized pizza and it’s always consistently good! I usually get delivery and they’re always quick and it’s always still warm when it arrives. They also are priced well!“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“We ordered the Stromboli to go and it was delicious. Highly recommend for take out!“

“After driving past many times we decided to stop the day before Thanksgiving. We ordered the Thanksgiving meal and enjoyed it. The young man that waited on us was an excellent server and everything was clean. We will definitely return again!“

“Resilient staff, fast food, and makes the whole family happy. Awesome to have from time to time.“

“i have called for delivery of pizza and more ,, first of all ..the people who answered the phones are RUDE!!! ,MORONS..it took15 minutes to place a order with them on the phone because the loser idiots had no idea wht they are doing ..it was just duh ,duh,huh,wht,uuumm,hole please, and wht would u like ...just PLAIN IDOTS!!!..I HAVE CALLED 10 TIMES SINCE THE BEGINNING OF THE YEAR TOO ORDER PIZZA AND other things and each time is the same of wht i said in the beginning!!! ..THIS WILL BE THE LAST TIME I WILL EVER ORDER FROM THIS LOCATION!!!!!!“

“This place goes above and beyond when it comes to customer service. We were staying at the beach last week out of town and had dinner here on our last day. My 13 year old son lost his wallet, come to find out it was left here. They went out of their way to contact me and MAIL me my sons wallet with all of his money in it. Thanks!!!!“