50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bennington

“Great quality, friendly and dedicated owners and staff. They never disappoint!!“

“I had an issue with my order at the Bennington, NE Papa John’s, but Angel, the manager, went above and beyond to make it right. She was professional, kind, and immediately arranged a refund and replacement.

As someone who manages IT for over 120 Arby’s locations, I really appreciate seeing that level of customer care and accountability. Angel turned a bad experience into a great one — she deserves recognition! 🍕👏“

“Called this Godfather's Express and told them I grew up in Omaha. Let them know that the Phoenix Franchises, where I have lived since 1987, should be shut down, as they do NOT make a REAL Godfather's Pizza like I remember. Asked them to build me a large Supreme, that would make Willie Thiessen PROUD! THEY DELIVERED! GREAT PIZZA.....perfect like the old days!!“

“Sooooo goood!!! Always delicious 😋“

“We enjoyed the pizza and chop salad. Our daughter just had a liver transplant and they discounted our bill 50%. Very kind people.“

“MaMa’s has become far and above our favorite place to get pizza from in the Omaha. From the perfect crunchy crust, the awesome balanced sauce, fresh toppings to the fresh mozzarella cheese slices on top it is the most consistent, fantastic pizza! I started eating lunch at the original location and moved to Bennington and have eaten at the Pacific Street location for the last 8+.“

“Highly recommended! Nice staff, excellent pizza, reasonable price. Loved the crust!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️!“

“Best pizza in town. Won’t go anywhere else.“

“We love Oscar's! Great food and great staff. We especially love the Thai Bourbon char buff wings and their amazing lasagna, but everything else we've tried is equally good. We've never had a bad experience or a bad meal. One of our favorite places. Highly recommend!“

“Great food and attentive staff!“

“The garlic parmesan wings were delicious!“

“Rodger did an amazing job! He knew the menu and gave us great advice. I’m a picky guy when it comes to steak but I can tell you the 16 oz ribeye doesn’t disappoint. Cooked perfectly and seasoned to perfection! Will definitely recommend it to everyone. I’ll ask for Rodger every time we eat at the Salted Edge! Thank you for an amazing anniversary dinner.“

“The best pizza joint! Delicious food and the owners are always so friendly when we come in. We’ve celebrated multiple occasions in their party room and love takeout, too. 10/10“

“Outstanding service, attention, and food“

“I ordered online and went to pick up my order earlier than the time I was told to come. They were very nice and made my order after the other people that were inside, but before the other online orders that were ahead of mine. That was really nice of them.“

“The best pizza joint! Delicious food and the owners are always so friendly when we come in. We’ve celebrated multiple occasions in their party room and love takeout, too. 10/10“

“All menu options are amazing from soups to pizza, meatballs & I could make a meal out of the appetizers too. Always delicious & very generous portions. Yum-yum!“

“We had such a delightful time here! Great service-friendly and fast! Food was carefully prepared and presented very well. We got the carne sourdough pizza and squid ink pasta with shrimp, seasonal lemon shortbread dessert with coconut gelato, my husband got the affogato. Everything was great and we were very satisfied afterwards. We liked the easy parking and convenient location compared to the downtown location.“

“On 8/29, we decided to try the Pizza Pie Guys. I ordered over the phone and went to pick it up. The woman who handed me our order was super nice & very friendly. Got home and we took our first bite together. My mom had the Mac & Beer Cheese Pizza, my husband had the Italian Danwich and I had the Pancetta White Pizza. No joke, we all moaned at our first bites. Best first impression EVER. Don't hesitate to give this place a try. Just one order and we're hooked!!! Thank you.“

“I was host for a meeting for my women's group and set up to have meeting at PizzaWest Maple St. The day of the meeting, I had a family issue arise. I stopped at PizzaWest before rushing off to help family - just to make sure everything was still set for the meeting and ordered a couple pizzas for the ladies since I was not sure I would be back. PizzaWest was awesome! The ladies said they were well taken care of once they arrived. Thank you!!!“

“We’ve been ordering from this location weekly for a while now. The same guys always make our order and are so friendly. We really appreciate the deals from the app and the quick pickup!

We get 2 medium pizzas for 6.99 each which feeds our family of 5 for less than $15. It’s not very cheap to eat out with 5 people even at fast food so we appreciate this yummy affordable option!“

“I like this spot...I want to LOVE this place but serve your customers NOT your friends.We are all your friends or we would not come here. The pizza dough bites are good. 😁“

“My 7 year old always wants to walk and eat there“

“We love grabbing fresh tasting Papa Murphys pizza for a Friday night movie night… Staff is pleasant and helpful. Sometimes our kids get to go in and order the pizza on their own and feel so proud and staff is always patient and pleasant to them!“

“Stopped by for the lunch buffet, food was decent, but staff were not too excited to be there. Cherry Pepsi was inop, I mentioned it and was told she would take care of it, but never did. Chit chatting with coworkers seemed to be the focus. Salad bar is pretty dinky.“

“This is a family favorite. The pizza is always good. It is almost always ready when they said it would be (or we wait less than 5 minutes). The site is easy to customize our favorites and add deals. The only thing that would be better is if they had taco pizza.“

“Very good food! Yum Will come back.“

“Super experience this weekend. We sat at the bar- great service.Delicious recommendation from the bartender and great ambiance. We had an excellent experience from the moment we were greeted until we left.. The menu was tempting to try everything but I settled for the short rib buritto breakfast, artichoke and bacon soup. next time I will try the stuffed popadews.“

“Big Fred’s is the best pizza in town!!“

“Thank you for serving the Kelo Jackrabbits on their way back from Frisco! We appreciate your service to us for going above and beyond on a cold winter day. Delicious meal!“

“This is the place best place for pizza it is always hot and by the time you get home if you take out it is still hot I love this pizza place no matter what you request it is done the veggies are fresh your pizza's done your veggies are not half done they cook to the fullest whatever you request this is the best pizza place“

“We have been customers of Maplewood Lanes over 40 years. We love this place. Very clean, friendly employees, great food. You can accumulate points for free food. Would not want to go any where else.“

“Nice environment with great Pizza and Taps!“

“This was the 1st location I visited a couple weeks ago for the 1st time. I was referred to this spot from a client, bec I mentioned to them I was from Brooklyn. I was craving for a good slice or 2, and sadly when I got there I saw that slices are only sold betw 11A and 2P??? I ended up ordering a salad and garlic knots. Salad was ok. Garlic Knots delicious. Very disappointed you don’t offer slices any time of operating hours. It doesn’t matter that this is not in NYC, cause this isn’t how NYC does it. Be authentic and offer slices any time. Not sure how the pizza tastes at this location. I’ll consider going back. And it was much cleaner than the other location, and even had the authentic pizza parlor smell when I walked in. The other spot didn’t. Do better!“

“My wife, son, and myself were in Omaha for the weekend. By sheer happenstance, we received a tip from a gal in our home town 5 hours away. So glad we stopped. Hands down one of the best pizzas we've ever had. Courteous staff, prep/cook time was fast, and great prices. 10 out of 10 would recommend.“

“Our food was hot and freshly cooked. The pizza was perfect. Definitely get the wings charred and double dipped.
Just a heads up the BBQ sauce is a bit spicy. I like heat, but you may want to ask if they have a mild version for the kiddos. 😊“

“03/22/2023 "Mike" and team, very much, "A" game going on today for lunch. Best this location has been in a while. Friendly, fast, focused top notch customer service and food today. TOP MARKS Mike!“

“Very tasty and the crust was perfect“

“Had an issue with DoorDash and the store. DoorDash picked up what the store provided. The store forgot to make our wings and DoorDash refunded us. Jake the manager called me personally, apologized, made the wings and personally delivered them to my house. That's hospitality!! Great work Jake.....I'd hire you tomorrow.“

“The BBQ chicken pizza was delicious! Service was fast and friendly. And the gelato for dessert was yummy!“

“Love to come here during lunch break, conviniantly close to work. They always have hot delicious food ready to go; so it doesnt take up all my lunch time to pick up food. I take advantage of there lunch specials. $8.99+. Wonderful customer service.“

“Great pizza! We’ve had delivered many times and always a great experience. Tonight we may go eat at their location.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Brittany is an exceptional employee of Casey’s. We messed up our pizza order but she made things right with exceptional care and service. Thanks to her outstanding service this will be our go to place for all needs (gas, snacks, pizza). Thank you Brittany. Casey’s is lucky to have your talent.“

“We ordered 7 pizzas and 4 orders of garlic knots to be delivered for a birthday party at 6...doorbell rings at noon....pizza is here...oh no! I called and spoke with the manager...he apologized, said keep the food and we will redeliver at 6 for your party!! No argument, no hemming and hawing, just took care of the problem and saved the day!! This happened 1-2-2026..Day manager...I wish I knew your name...you are awesome!! Thankyou again!!“

“Walked in 3 minutes to close after a 15 hour drive home bc i was starving and everyone I talked to was super nice about getting a last minute order (I wouldnt be). Never the type to come into a store less than 20 mins before close but seriously these guys were great and so“

“Wonderful prime rib special on Thursday night. Very delicious; melt in your mouth. The desserts are also amazing.“

“We recently visited Pickleman's for a quick lunch and decided on a few different things to try instead of their (delicious!!) sandwiches! I have to say the Avo-Cobb salad was so tasty and full of flavor! The kids decided on the pepperoni pizza and garlic bread which they devoured and loved. The staff was very patient while we decided our choices, offering suggestions that were helpful. The restaurant was very clean with a warm, inviting atmosphere. It was a great overall family experience!“

“My friend and I visited the Pizza Ranch pizza buffet this morning at 11am. It wasn’t very busy but had fresh food out including pizza, fried chicken, and a salad bar. The lettuce for the salad had seen better days but overall the food was good. The FunZone Arcade was small and in a separate area from the buffet. It was reasonably priced and had a nice selection of prizes. The two downsides was the water in the ice game smells awful and needs to be changed. The second downside causing me to rate 4/5 stars was approximately 30% of their games were broken or offline. We would have stayed longer and spent more money if they were up and running as some were my favorites. (Down the clown and let’s bounce).“