5 Best Italian Restaurants near Plymouth

“I almost always have the Atlantic Salmon, and have been for years! Tonight’s Salmon has to be the best I have had in years. Kudos to the chef 💕.“

“We took a large group (about 22 kids and 25 adults) in for a hockey tournament team dinner over the weekend. Everyone was so helpful. I spoke directly with the owner leading up to the event and he was diligent about keeping in touch with be before, during, and after to ensure a smooth evening. The food is incredible and the atmosphere and staff just added to the experience. I love that the Grotto is super family friendly giving both kids and adults a great experience. The entire team absolutely loved hanging out here. The parents were particularly impressed with the homemade pasta options, variety of adult beverages, and the ability for the kids to have some fun in the Dungeon. The live music was also great! We are already looking forward to the next time we can bring the crew in! Thank you to all of you for making us feel welcome and allowing the kids to be kids. We will definitely recommend the Grotto any chance we get.“

“This small, family-owned Italian restaurant is an absolute gem. From the moment you walk in, you’re welcomed like family—the atmosphere is cozy, inviting, and full of heart. You can truly taste the difference in food that’s made from scratch with love and care.
We’re visiting from Miami, FL, and can honestly say this is the best pizza and chicken Parmesan we’ve ever had—hands down. The flavors are authentic, fresh, and unforgettable. Every bite reminded us why supporting family-owned businesses matters.
If you’re looking for phenomenal Italian food in a warm, welcoming setting, this place is a must-visit. We’ll definitely be back! 🍕🇮🇹“

“We continue to go often. The food and staff are great. This is not a fancy date night place, but it checks off the boxes when it comes to good home style food. They should bottle and sell their marinara, we love it. We are very fond of their pizza. Extra cheese and mushroom is the current favorite.“

“Good food not very relaxing environment at all music would help 😉 always very busy but effectively free parking can pickup dine in or depending on the condition of your roads,delivery (definitely expensive and hard to access, Def not an easy place for driving so take care of delivery if you can find it)“