38 Best Italian Restaurants near Windham

“Two fantastic visits - 1/31 and 2/25 - for my wife's birthday and then mine. Patrick provided awesome service, and our food was AWESOME! I had seen bacon-wrapped scallops on the appetizer menu and knew I was getting that! Main courses were also fantastic, and Patrick conversed with us about the paranormal events experienced there, since we are ghost hunting fans. AWESOME EXPERIENCE!! Can't wait to go again.“

“I put Capri at the top of the list of Windham area establishments! The pizza sauce is easily the best flavored sauce around! I’m also a sub connoisseur, and their Italian subs, as well as their steak n cheese is amazing! I had a ham n cheese calzone with pepperoni the other night that was my favorite calzone ever! I can go on and on!“

“the atmosphere is cozy and warm. Delicious martini choices. Huge portions for a reasonable price. Would recommend this place to everyone.“

“Outstanding customer service! Had an issue with an emailed gift card and Lori fixed our problem! Efficient, kind and professional. Highly recommend.“

“Have always enjoyed the food, eating in or take out. During covid when open we enjoyed many a meal and always felt our business was appreciated. Tonight my wife called to place an order ( of roughly 200.00 to 250.00) for our family. Understandably it took a while for the phone to be answered and when it was and my wife said " hello I would like to place a take out order" received " we are not taking take out orders this eve" and was abruptly hung up on. We have been loyal supporters of this establishment pretty since it opened. Never spending another penny here. Our money was great when things were lean, sadly unappreciated. Thanks.“

“We’ve been coming here for years. The service is always an A+ The food is always an A+ We drive all the way here from MA for dinner 🩷“

“Such a friendly staff, we had an amazing meal!“

“The food and drinks were amazing! And our server Dylan put up with our craziness!! Will definitely be back!“

“Drove 50 minutes to meet friends we haven’t seen in a while, only to be told upon being seated we had only 90 minutes. All through meal an underlying sense of being rushed. No offer of dessert or dessert menu, just told someone was waiting for our table. Minutes later waiter started clearing glasses, silverware off table in front of us. Food was very good, too bad experience was“

“Excellent lunch today with the family. Large lunch portions, excellent food, fantastic service.“

“We just left here had an awesome waitress I ordered the chicken broccoli ziti lui style, my husband got the chicken prosciutto calzone and our kids got baked Mac n cheese and chicken fingers! Everything was delicious! Place is very nice inside and very cozy atmosphere. Highly recommend!“

“Friendly staff! Excellent food !“

“Overall a 4/5, everything was awesome! My service was great all thanks to Marie B, also the atmosphere was very cozy and the restaurant was very vast. But one thing took a point off my review that couldn’t make it a full five stars, and that was the pasta and breadsticks. Don’t get me wrong I loved it but the pasta was a bit over cooked and the breadsticks were different for every one, like one is over cooked by a tad and one is very soggy. I hope you can do better olive garden, but overall I still loved it!

Kid-friendliness: My server, Marie was very sweet! To my kids. I can never find a restaurant that is this friendly!“

“My fiancé and I stopped in yesterday for pizza and I had to write a review. People can be quick to complain and don’t always say the good. First, the restaurant was very busy while we were there and it was clear they were understaffed. I saw three people working the floor. One out front doing take out, one running the bar and one waiter working the floor. To top it off, there was a birthday party with about a dozen guests. Our waiter was outstanding. Taking orders, making drinks, bussing the tables, he handled the stress unbelievably well and was pleasant and funny. Our food was delicious and came out piping hot. None of them missed a step. We will definitely be back. Kudos to the team and management well done!“

“While at my mom’s Tuesday night cooking dinner, I noticed she had a container of Rig A Tony’s sauce in her freezer. I used it for our spaghetti, and it was absolutely deliciousssss! Last night, I couldn’t stop thinking about their chicken pot pie after seeing it on here, so I asked my hubby to swing by on his way home from work to see if they had any left. Luckily, they did! Three, to be exact! While checking out, he spotted the banana bread and couldn’t resist grabbing that too. Let’s just say, we went to bed completely stuffed. The chicken pot pie was out of this world, huge! Packed with tender chicken and veggies, and the crust was perfectly golden and flaky. Pure comfort food at its finest. I didn’t think I’d have room for banana bread, but I couldn’t resist sneaking a bite before bed. It was unbelievably moist, fresh, and hands down the best banana bread I’ve ever had. I grew up a wannabe Italian, and there’s just something special about an Italians cooking! Rig A Tony’s completely won me over, and I can’t wait to go back for more! 🤌Mamma mia, che buono!“

“This is one of the very few restaurants that will make you immediately feel at home! You can tell right from the start how much everyone and everything is appreciated and cared for which I believe is the benefit of a family owner restaurant especially when the family is as welcoming and caring as this one. From the martinis coming from the bar (with friendly service from Krista), especially my favorites the homemade creamy limoncello martini, their REAL espresso martinis, and their lemon drop to name a few, to the made to order dishes that you can customize to meet your preferred tastes or needs- everything is just done right! The appetizers are literally to die for- the eggplant a la romana will melt in your mouth, the world famous seafood mushroom are definitely world famous and the clams casino are 👌! For dishes I would recommend their double pork chop alla Nicola with truffle fries, their chicken or veal francese, their Marsala, saltimbocca, chicken langistino on their specials, and their amazing eggplant parm. Make sure you get their homemade pasta which they have 3 to choose from! If you truly know when a restaurant is overall special, then you won't have a hard time choosing the Colosseum for your next dine out experience. Despite when they get busy, I don't think they disappoint. Well worth the wait!!“

“Tried Mave’s for the first time today, two thumbs up! Pizza & eggplant parm sub were both delicious. 👍“

“Amazing Alfredo! Thank you Chris!“

“excellent service and food“

“I just had a neighbor give me some lasagna that his son brought him. Best lasagna I've ever had, I've never been there but, just tying one bite I'm hooked. The sauce is so good I could drink it. Pasquale's is a MUST TRY! 5 🌟 Star“

“Amazingly crafted sauce recipe. I normally get heartburn off of red sauce but this one is good.

This is THE BEST crust you will get within at least 25 miles. I’d honestly say that this is the best pizza you will get between Boston and all of New Hampshire.

Friendly people and they work hard to keep these pizzas and other food coming out top notch.

If you are looking for a 9/10 rating pizza, you call them and pay them. Tip them too… we need these pizzas to keep spinning!“

“Im disappointed that the trios come with fettuccine and only one option for pasta with red sauce. They Must have changed the policy since I was here last. So disappointed. Not a fan of mixing red sauce and fettuccine sauce. The pizza was good.“

“The staff here is super friendly and I always enjoy coming to get my Sunday morning breakfast.The food is always exceptional in a great atmosphere.There new French bread.Breakfast bowls are ridiculously awesome.. I highly suggest coming here🥰“

“It's a very beautiful place to visit even alone or with the family and friends. There are a lot of stores, restaurants and kiosks. A lot of things to have fun.“

“Delicious, our Friday night treat!“

“Only had a debit card and they had a 5 dollar minimum. I explained I’m behind at work and need some food and he let me get a single slice and a Gatorade under the $5 limit. Then gave me a slice on the house. The generosity of the people here is amazing. You don’t see that often. Plus the pizza is great!“

“Very humble, the food is great, the staff is great and Jay and Kristine the owners are great and always involved.“

“Not only are their gluten free cakes beautiful , they are delicious. For people with Celiac Disease having a beautiful cake to celebrate with is a difficult task. We are so grateful to Luciano’s. I highly recommend them.“

“We always order from here! Today we got the. Wings extra crispy they were excellent we also ordered a large Paisanos Deluxe no peppers extra crispy. OMG. The best pizza North of Boston! Amazing staff and Pizza. A must try“

“Hardly five stars. Deleted my complaint . Nice owner. Charged me 3 times for 2 pizzas. Guess she needs 64 bucks more than me. I find that to be poor business and the woman could not even be bothered to contact me. Will never go back nor will I recommend the place. Too bad cause the pizza was not bad and Jess is quite lovely. Owner should take customer service lessons from her. My previous complaint was deleted!!“

“Real good food ...best I had In a long time first time experience was primo😎🤙🔥“

“Doesn’t look like much from the outside but it is super nice inside! Great atmosphere, clean and a great crowd for the patriots game. Food was good and reasonably priced. Tots were great, the bacon egg and cheese on croissant was delicious. Great service! No one enjoyed the home fries for our party but the burgers were good.“

“The chicken finger dinner I got was decent, however the fries tasted slightly burnt, the chicken was good, I ordered it with honey mustard and got complimentary sweet and sour as well which was nice, the service was good and the atmosphere was good, the place has dim lighting which adds a good atmosphere I think.“

“I visited this location few years back. Usually I go more 9ften to the location in Lowell. I helped my fiend to organize her baby shower here. Since day 1, Anthony (owner) was very helpful and accomodating. On event day our main server Barbara provided a top notch service.
Event was a 3pm but they let us go at 11:30 to decorate, and Barbara was already ther and help me to set up tablecloths and everything she could.
At the moment of the event food was on time and deliscious, the buffet set up was very nice and Barbara kept cleaning making sure everything was presentable. Everybody love the food, the service and the place.

Parking: There is plenty of parking.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp to get into the restaurant“

“My fiancé and I stopped in yesterday for pizza and I had to write a review. People can be quick to complain and don’t always say the good. First, the restaurant was very busy while we were there and it was clear they were understaffed. I saw three people working the floor. One out front doing take out, one running the bar and one waiter working the floor. To top it off, there was a birthday party with about a dozen guests. Our waiter was outstanding. Taking orders, making drinks, bussing the tables, he handled the stress unbelievably well and was pleasant and funny. Our food was delicious and came out piping hot. None of them missed a step. We will definitely be back. Kudos to the team and management well done!“

“I’ve visit to sbarro 01/27/2025 and let me tell you Frank the general manager gave me the best costumer service that I ever experienced in the fast food industry this young man is very professional and polite in what he does he offered me numerous of combos that were available and gave me the best opinion for me and my kids and of course the whole time he was smiling I’m definitely coming back here again and ima forward the word to my family and friends god bless this young man you guys have a good team player in your side my name is Lisa Bennetts by the way I am a new manager in the new nash Casino and I even offered him a job and he respectfully declined my offer and told me that he is loyal to the sbarro brand…“

“I've seen some low ratings - no idea why.. this is arguably the best Pizza in the area. Without question the best slice place that I can think of as well. Last 5 times I ate pizza I just went in and ordered a few slices. If I ordered a large I'd eat the whole damn thing, so slices work great for me. Every time I eat there, I tell someone on the staff - you're the best Pizza around.“