50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Allendale

“Toscana Pizza nestled between a bunch of high-quality restaurants surely can stand with the best of them. This establishment is run by the most welcoming, humble business owner (Billy) I have ever met. However, his food does all the talking as its always fresh and tasty. The pizza crust is perfectly crisp every time. The ratio of cheese to sauce is spot on. The toppings are high quality. The flavors complement each other in such that you can taste all the ingredients. The marinara sauce used for the other dishes has a nice balance and does not overwhelm the dish it is served with. The Sicilian slice is probably one of the best I have ever had. The grilled chicken pesto sandwich, and the grilled chicken broccoli rabe cooked to order is amazing. Also, one of my favorites is the eggplant as I can eat that every day, not too thick, not too thin. The bread is always crispy and fresh. After your meal, there is always a Thank You coming from the staff as you walk out with a smile on your face.“

“Great Pizza! Had the vodka slice and it was amazing. Love a good thin crust pizza. Service was awesome and the place was very comfortable. Looking forward to trying more things on the menu Just moved down the road and been meaning to try it out. I am very glad I did. I will be ordering my pizza from here now.“

“After a quest to find the quintessential pizza experience in town, I stumbled upon Pizza Knight, and let me tell you, it was a culinary adventure worth every savory bite.From the moment I stepped through the door, I was met with warmth and hospitality that set the tone for an exceptional dining experience. The staff at Pizza Knight exude friendliness and genuine care for their patrons, making me feel not just like a customer, but like a welcomed guest.Now, let’s talk about the main event – the pizza. I indulged in both the Detroit Vodka Cecilian and the Vodka Pie, and each slice was a revelation of flavor. The Detroit Vodka Cecilian boasted a perfect blend of tangy tomato sauce, creamy vodka sauce, and crispy crust, while the Vodka Pie elevated the classic pizza with its unique vodka-infused twist, leaving my taste buds dancing with delight.Beyond the mouthwatering pizzas, Pizza Knight’s attention to detail and commitment to quality shine through in every aspect of their offerings. From the fresh ingredients to the expertly crafted crusts, it’s evident that they take pride in their craft.In conclusion, Pizza Knight isn’t just a place to grab a slice – it’s a destination for pizza aficionados seeking an unforgettable dining experience. With impeccable hospitality and pizzas that redefine perfection, Pizza Knight has undoubtedly earned its place as a must-visit establishment in town.“

“Family run business with owners who try to please their customers. The pizza & salads are outstanding & there is nothing that compares to what they are serving in rockland county.Vegetarian options: Outstanding salads & plenty of vegetable choices to add to your pizza.Dietary restrictions: They will try to please you & accommodate any dietary restrictions.Parking: Plenty of available spaceKid-friendliness: Family style restaurant“

“Visiting Grumpys for the Pizza Hunters App and was not disappointed. Parking can be tricky. There are only 4 parking spots behind the Pizzeria..I wound up parking across the street and patronizing the Deli as well in the process. I didn't even get all the way inside the door and was greeted immediately with a Hello, Welcome and How are You. Service was excellent and the price point was excellent. A lot of great Pizza for your money. It took me a little to find the words for this Pizza. The Crispy crust is definitely the highlight. Followed by the Sauce and Cheese. Really, the pizza has its own unique style and delivery. It all works. At one point, I thought maybe a little more sauce, since i am a big fan, but once it hits your taste Buds, you realize that it all works perfectly together and that's what makes it unique as a Grumpys Pizza. I give it 5 Pie Ya's.. pie ya, pie ya. Pie ya. Pie ya. Pie ya. I will definitely be back again. Great Job Grumpys..I have to Pizza aside, your Customer Service is top notch as well.“

“Excellent place that has been around for a while. They know good food, and have a great atmosphere. Personally, I think they have the best pizza in town. They have consistently good service that never disappoints, and everything on their menu is delicious and well worth the trip here.Parking: The parking could be better, but they do have a valet on site that takes care of all of that.“

“the pizza was so stringy, and warm, it was definitely hand made and never frozen, the music playing really brings up the mood and was easy to order, a single slice is only 3 bucks (minus tax) and it is very wheelchair friendly, the chairs are not screwed to the floor so you can move chairs for the wheelchair.“

“The food is always amazing, unique and generous portion size.Recently did a sheva brachos in house, and the owner and staff outdid themselves. They were attentive, accommodating and responsive. Also added some fish entrees for those who requested. They even set up Spotify Jewish music for us! The guests were comfortable and happy, and the restaurant did everything we contracted and more. Leftovers were packed nicely and efficiently for distribution. We would definitely do this again!Wheelchair accessibility: street level access“

“Very friendly and attentive staff! This was a great experience. Bread came out with a plate of delicious mozzarella and tomato in olive oil (complimentary). I had shrimp parm that was very tasty. Loved the sauce. I ordered it with the roasted potatoes, and although I thought they were a bit lacking in flavor (need some spice or something), I was so happy that I had a choice of pasta, salad, or potato. My husband had the chicken sorrentino and really liked that too. He ordered it with a salad and that also was good. We ordered two desserts. Cannoli was good, but I've had better. My husband really enjoyed the banana pudding. Then they gave us zeppoles on the house, which we had to take home as we were already stuffed with good food. Highly recommend this place!“

“OMG! This place is amazing. I heard about it from a few people but I live in Spring Valley and never thought about going when the “what’s for dinner” question was asked. Happened to be driving by and stopped for lunch. Now I’m kicking myself for not going sooner. I’m locking my fingers and looking for more. We had the Disco balls and the Mexican jumping balls. Even the employees were super nice and friendly. Cannot wait till we go again which will be very soon.“

“In my opinion, Perusia has the best thin crust pizza in town, we also loved the mussels, ravioli, bolognese, & tortellini. We were there for our Daughters birthday party today, and she and her friends loved the pizza, spaghetti & meatballs, & the pasta pomodoro and had a great time. The staff were incredibly helpful and nice, they held our birthday cake overnight for us and allowed us to decorate the table an hour before hand while the kids were at the escape room in the next shopping center. The restaurant is comfortable and clean. Thank you so much.“

“Amazing staff, delicious food, the perfect spot for your event! John was such a pleasure to work with. He took care of every need and made sure that my event went perfectly. My family and I were beyond happy with everything and enjoyed having the private space for us and our guests. Can’t recommend enough and will def be coming back! Thanks again iachetti’s kitchen for everything!“

“What a WONDERFUL treat!!! When I was a little girl growing up in New York, there was an Argentine Pizzeria that had THE-BEST pizza and empanadas. Unfortunately, the owners retired and moved away. I have searched and search for that perfect crunch of the Argentine pizza and taste….and I FOUND IT at Biby’s!Biby’s offers different types of pizza but if you want to experience AMAZING-NESS, their Argentine Pizza Deluxe is the way to go. Minus the eggs, that is EXACTLY the way I had it growing up. We ate with the sliced hard boiled eggs on top and it was sooooo….GOOD!As soon I saw the round pan and the gentleman building the pizza, my heart was so GLAD…. I said to my myself, “Yes, that’s how I remember the pizza being prepared” The Argentine pizza is a little thicker but so tasty!All of this and I didn’t tell you about the empanadas…. ALSO DEE-LISH, and the Chimichurri sauce is incredible! And a variety of empanadas.The service was incredible, they were really kind and gracious.I traveled a good hour to Biby’s Empanadas & Pizza….the travel was WELL WORTH IT!At home with my family, everything was a HIT!“

“UPDATE AT THE END;I ordered online ahead of time to have my order ready on time, when I arrived in the store, the worker at the counter was choosing his priorities of personal life over the customers.He left me waiting there while my food was getting soggy more and more by the minute..He was busy catching up with some friends..When I spoke up and asked if my order is ready, the friend backed off to let me through to the counter, but this lovely worker took the opportunity to now call another friend over Video call to show him who just came in to the store.......To the business owner, if you want to have a good name, please make sure to talk to the worker that worked at the counter on March 30th at 11:45 - 11:55 pm.----UPDATE.A few minutes after posting the review, I got a reply from the owner that he will look into this.The next morning I got a call from him that he looked at the CCTV footage and wants to hear more details from me.I gave him the full story and he said that he will talk to the worker.I got a call from him not too long after the initial call, and he clarified what the story was and that the company is taking full responsibility on this.Now, after this I can proudly say, the customers service is 10 out of 5, awesome and amazing to deal with responsible people, a mistake is a mistake.“

“We love this place the chicken parm pizza is amazing since the new owners took over it's better then before there friendly sandwiches are better they take credit cards and there delivery is more efficient there even open on Sundays there pizza amazing and sandwiches are plentiful great family “

“WE SAW THE PROGRAM WITH GORDON RAMSEY, NIGHTMARE KITCHENS USA, AND WE WERE STRIKED BY THE SERIOUSNESS AND GREAT WILL OF ANTONIO, WHO FOR BEING SO YOUNG IS ALREADY A WINNER.WE WANTED TO ASK IF YOU DO HOME DELIVERIES IN EUROPE, WE WOULD LIKE A PIZZA MADE BY ANTONIO.GREETINGS FROM ITALIAN SWITZERLAND.“

“My family and I each enjoyed fantastic service and food at Pazza today. We were offered seats in or outdoors and chose to sit inside. I have celiac and absolutely loved their gluten-free penne shrimp fra diavolo! So spicy and delicious. We all left feeling happy and very full!“

“So glad there is a Singa's near us - pizza is always great. They are generous with toppings and even offer a "half cooked" option so you can finish cooking at home for a fresh pizza experience later. Owner/Staff are always pleasant too.“

“I’ve written more than one review here, probably with multiple emails, or maybe the same one. Who knows. Going on a tour de Bergen County with reviews since I no longer live in the area, and have come to find how incredibly spoiled us Bergen County folks are for the food we have access to. This place is one of them. I’ve never had pizza this good inside or outside of Bergen County. Miss this place a lot, even the lovely owners, and I stop in every trip back to get a slice that I eat straight away—because it’s the only way. Gonna have to plan another trip. Perfecto pizza. Probably can only get better in literal Italy.“

“It is one the best pies around and you have to go and enjoy the quality of the pie.. sauce crust cheese... always consistent! all so evenly prepared... dinners are solid as well.. order a pie as soon as u get there.. then review the menu for dinner!“

“HOLY SMOKES! It's been a long time since I was left satisfied and smiling! This Chicken Carciofi is a master class, must-have item in your take out rotation. The focaccia crunch blended with the heavenly fresh mozzzy ooooooooh MAMA!!! When I eat this sandwich, I travel to another dimension, and I'm comfortable in that place, it feels like home. Add on the special, yet delicate ARANCINOs and I am LOST, barely aware of my surroundings, struggling to gather myself. God Bless America and God Bless Adam and those soldiers at Francesca's!“

“Great food and excellent service. Wide range of quality food and drink. Rocco and his family has been treating and serving every customer as though they were his own family for over 40 years. Highly recommend this Restaurant. ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️“

“Was my first time there recommend my one of the friends I met up there with! The food was fantastic, the atmosphere was great! When we arrived we all thought we needed to have a reservation to get a table, but that was not the case. Pleasantly surprised and able to get a table within 5 minutes. It looks like an upscale pizzeria, but it's so much more! Amazing food! Our served did a great job keeping up with for hungry men asking questions about the menu. He was knowledgeable and well mannered and easy going. Can't wait to go back! Pricing was good a well! Looking to take a hot date there soon too! Highly recommend!Parking: There are some spots just in front of the restaurant, but it's on a main street, so look for parking around the block on the streets perpendicular.“

“Had a wonderful experience at al di la! We arrived a little before 12 pm and was empty so we got to enjoy the quiet but it got filled up while we were sitting. The atmosphere is calm. There isn't a very bug menu but the food is really good. We had their famous salad pizza and didn't disappoint! We also ordered a hot coca which was perfect for this cold rainy day and a delicious salmon pizzaoili. The Eggplant rollantini was good as well. Will definitely be coming back here!“

“Cool new spot in town! I was reluctant to try this place out but I decided to give it a try after seeing a nice crowd in there. It turns out there is a new owner, he just kept the name of the place the same. A mistake in my opinion but at least he did one good thing. He hired a great bartender named I know from Barrel and Brew. This guy can make a great drink and he is so personable. He interacts well with guests and designed a great menu of drinks. I enjoyed a couple of delicious margaritas while I was there. They also had a DJ named Bronson playing some great music. I look forward to seeing how this place does because I've always said this spot would make a great bar because of the nice patio outside. It would make a great hangout for the summer. I can't really comment on the food because I only tried an order of wings but they were good. The ambience though gave me reason to believe this place could make it at this spot.“

“Very clean, fast, & friendly employees were very welcoming and accommodating to what I was looking for if it was not put out amazing food if your passing thru on the highway definitely give this place a stop and get some gas while your at it lol“

“I have passed this place thousands of times, but never ate here. I stopped in tonight and was pleasantly surprised. We ordered pizza, 2 heroes and some cannoli's to go. The pizza was excellent and in my opinion, better than the pizza at other nearby restaurants! The heroes also got great reviews!! Although I'm not a huge fan of cannoli's, they were very good and hit the spot :) I have no idea why it took me so long to try this place out, but I will def. be back! The staff was also super friendly.“

“Seemed like a crazy Friday night when I walked in but they were very helpful when I was trying to order last minute pies. Just got finished with dinner with the family and the pizza was amazinggggg! We got a grandma square pie and a regular cheese round pizza, the crust is so good. Thank you for being so kind and accommodating! I go here once in a while but I just felt the need to write a review finally tonight because it’s always been a great experience and seeing how hard they were working tonight really made me appreciate everything!“

“I can't complain. The pizza was amazing, I was immediately greeted and asked what I wanted to eat in a busy lunch rush. I sat down and the atmosphere was very pleasant. Love this place now, can't wait to eat here again :)Parking: Handicap parking is available as well.“

“One of the most delicious pizzas I've ever eaten. This restaurant does not accept reservations. They don't have many tables either. It is small but has a warm atmosphere. If you're lucky, you can taste those delicious flavors without waiting too long.Vegetarian options: Options are available in this restaurant for those who prefer vegetarian“

“We ordered a Grandma Margarita last night to take out The pie was prepared and ready within 25 minutes It was our first time trying their pizza Overall very tasty and delicious My wife loved the pie and we would recommend you give them a try You won't be disappointed Second meal tonight we ate in and it's a BYOB We had the absolute best eggplant ever over spaghetti a the topper is that they serve you hot zeppelins with melted chocolate as a treat Simply Amazing“

“I love this pizzeria! I come here once a week literally. The best pizzeria I’ve been to hands down. Everything on their menu is delicious my favorite is the penne vodka pasta with grilled shrimp. I had Nicole as a waitress she was phenomenal! Also, theyre very affordable“

“Where do I begin? We had our daughter's party scheduled from 3:00pm-5:00pm and from the moment we came in, the staff greeted us. We met our hostess Lisa almost immediately as she came right out to introduce herself and walk us over to our table. We got there about half an hour early and everything was already nicely set up. Throughout our time there, Lisa did a spectacular job by being so friendly and attentive. The manager, Denishah was also amazing. She also came over to introduce herself and let us know that if we needed anything to please come see her. She also helped provide support during the party and was just so incredibly friendly, kind and professional. We all had a great time and my daughter wants to come back to this Chuck E. Cheese for her birthday next year and I think that is a great idea. Thank you so much to Lisa, Denishah and all the staff working on 9/9/23. We had a wonderful time!“

“My go to pizzeria. This pizzeria has a true family-friendly feel. The staff are all very friendly and welcoming, and love that small town feel seeing other families dining in when we went. Of course, the most important thing is the pizza, and it was delicious! The crust was perfectly cooked, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Daughter loves the pizza. We often come here for mama daughter dates.“

“Solid place. Out of risk, that when i post this it may be more difficult to get a table..... but food is awesone... and service is well the best.... but tbjs needs to be recognized. 5 stars ! BYOW too and no corkage fee too. Sweeeeeeet!“

“We waited a bit to be seated on a Saturday night (walk-in) but enjoyed our visit. The server was friendly, and helpful when asked about the pizza toppings she recommended. We got the eggplant rollatini appetizer which was excellent and then two pizzas. Vodka sauce with pineapples and anchovies (4/5) and her recommendation which was the fra diavolo with garlic, onion and sausage (5/5). There were leftovers, so I would say the portions were pretty good - don't underestimate thin crust pizza!Vegetarian options: Apps, pizza, pasta all have veg options“

“We have ordered a couple of times and it is always delivered on time and with plates, cutlery, napkins and pepper flakes - you don't have to request for theseDietary restrictions: Jason does a great job and makes sure the food is delivered on time“

“We stopped by for the first time tonight and were thrilled with our experience. Alex and his team are making some of the best thin crust pizza in the area.We came in with a group of six, and they happily accommodated us. They were friendly, welcoming, and the food was delicious. The crust was thin thin thin, and the cheese and sauce were the perfect mix of salty and sweet. I wish I had taken photos of the rest of our food, but we ate it too quickly (that’s how good it is!) We had two plain small thin crust pies, a half pepperoni/half sausage, and a small thin crust with half “the works” and half veggie. We also got a salad and two Italian subs and an arugula salad. Everything we ate was fantastic!We also got to meet the owner Alex, who has put his heart and soul into this place. He is a stand-up guy who really cares about his customers. If you get the chance, stop in and try their pizza - you won’t be disappointed!“

“My favorite pizza place of all time. I used to frequent this spot many years ago, I stop by every chance I get when I'm in the area. I stopped by today and 11years later and is still the same. The owner is really nice. The food is great, glad to see not much has changed.“

“Amazing pizza, but I'm a steak guy... This place makes one of the most deliciously flavorful steaks I have had in a long while. I critique many multiple star rated restaurants on how they cook a basic steak, and sadly they fall short of the mark. This was medium rare, carnivore judged, perfection! My new favorite steak place!“

“WOW! Gio's hosted my daughter's bridal shower today. IT was phenomenal. The food, atmosphere, service, etc. Special shout out to Gio, Gina, Danni and everyone else who made our party pure perfection. I wish I had another celebratory occasion coming up to use them again. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.“

“Tonight was my first time there and I was told the food was really good. We had wings and some slices and Ari and Mary didn't disappoint. They brought us some knots while we waited and those were fantastic also. I'm new to the area and will definitely be “

“They are mamash pizza artisans. I'm a bt who misses traif pizza until now. Yummy's has a vast selection of artisan pizza for an array of tastes. The guys from the chef to the cashier are super nice and down to earth. You'll leave happy. Maybe order a few different slices and see what you like the most. You'll thank me later.“

“Was here first week of opening. Not good, however tonight was different. A small pasta dish was over $20, but a salad was $14. If I recall. Y not offer a small tossed with entrees? Other entrees good. Service slow and very few diners. Had to ask for water refills, needs to improve.“

“I've been coming here for almost 30 years, so I am biased in thinking that this is the best slice of pizza in an area known for pizza places. The people who aren't biased are the friends and acquaintances that I have fed this pizza to, and who, despite their determination to defend their hometown pizza place, readily admit three bites in that this pizza is something special. Thin, crispy slices with a good tasting sauce, and perfectly melted cheese is the style here, and it's never failed to hit the mark. This place deserves 5 stars more than maybe any other business I frequent on a regular basis.“

“There a few Pizza places in town. This is the best one, most likely bec of the fresh ingredients and the brick oven. Everything taste better with brick oven IMO. We got half buffalo and half CBR, amazing. Service is fast and super friendly.“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Slice and Spice, and I must say, it exceeded all my expectations. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warmth and hospitality. The ambiance was cozy and inviting, perfect for a casual meal with friends or a romantic dinner.Now, let's talk about the food. Oh my goodness, where do I even begin? Every dish was an explosion of flavor, expertly crafted and beautifully presented. From the crispiness of their signature pizzas to the aromatic spices in their savory dishes, each bite was a delight to the senses.The menu offers a wide variety of options to cater to every palate, including vegetarian and gluten-free choices. Whether you're craving traditional Italian classics or innovative fusion creations, Slice and Spice has something for everyone.And let's not forget about the impeccable service. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional. They were attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about providing top-notch service.Overall, I can't recommend Slice and Spice highly enough. Whether you're a local looking for your new favorite restaurant or a visitor in search of an unforgettable dining experience, do yourself a favor and pay them a visit. You won't be disappointed!Vegetarian options: SaladsParking: Great big parking lotKid-friendliness: They have high chairs and the staff is really nice to the childrenWheelchair accessibility: It is ground floor, and it is very ez to get in and out with a wheelchair“

“My wife and I stop by the bakery to pick up St Joseph cakes on our way to Anthony Francos to get dinner. We noticed the menus at the door and picked one up. We were planning on ordering Eggplant Rollatini. We decided to give Grandmas a chance. People were very friendly and food was fresh and delicious. Would definitely recommend this place. We will be returning in the future.“

“A Chicken Veggie Slice For Me ($4.50)... Specialty SLices Might Seem Small But Hearty... A FIRST Ive Ever Came Across Was Thier Beef Chicken Stock Herb Compilation As I Was Told It Is,, Which Seems to Consist of Garlic,, Onion,, Salt,, Parsley and Red Pepper FLakes and I Think Dried Pieces Of Chicken N Beef... Someone Tell Me What This Is Called If Uuu Run Across This Review... Very Tasty It Is and I Dont Eat Beef Anymore But I Made an Exception to Try... Pretty Decent Place...“

“Amazing pizzeria with top restaurant quality food. The people who work there are nice. They get the order always right. Probably my favorite spot since I moved up to this area 3 years ago. You’ll be surprised at how good this little pizza place actually is. Order the food not just the pizza. They are both top notch.“