23 Best Seafood Restaurants near Bayville

“I photographed a wedding here back when it was known as Martell's Waters Edge and the location was incredibly epic! At every turn I had incredibly scenic locations to provide my couple with epic photos (see attached).In addition the staff was super friendly and helpful as well as the food was really amazing! Everyone was enjoying it!I highly recommend this location if you have a wedding or event!“

“AMAZINGGGGG!!! After hearing nothing but excellent things about this restaurant I finally made it and it lived up to all the hype!! Everything was amazing from the time we sat down, staff was very friendly and welcoming and our waitress was so personable and very attentive. All the food was top notch, the crab toast appetizer special on the fabulous sourdough bread was unbelievable, I have never had crab that fresh! Also, I highly recommend the potato app ? I will definitely be back!! Chef came out to ask how everything was, great guy! I would highly recommend this restaurant to everyone!!!!“

“Both my wife and I had General Tso’s Chicken which was fantastic!Wonton soup was great.Service was great and you have to bring your own alcohol.Highly recommend!We returned last night and again everything was fantastic!They had a special , Garlic Parmigiana Chicken Dumplings! Unbelievably great! Like mixing Italian with Chinese!Our waiter, Dave M. was also very friendly and knowledgeable!One of my favorite places to go!!“

“My husband and I had one of the best meals out in a long time. From the moment you walk through the door you know you're in store for something special. The ambiance is outstanding and the service is amazing. The menu is top notch. The steaks are the best quality and cooked to perfection. Talk about a hidden gem!“

“This is our go to restaurant because we always know we will have a great meal. The food is amazing. Staff is on point and so professional. Kate, our server was one of the sweetest people we have met. Made our meal even more special. Thank you for an awesome meal and we will be back!!“

“I randomly had a delivery order from here, and I hit the jackpot. This food was absolutely amazing. I AM IN HEAVEN. I was not prepared for food this delicious, my taste buds were attacked. Chile relleno, al pastor tacos, elotes, rice and beans. I was in cozumel 5 days ago and this was like I had never left. If anyone needs me, I'll be in a food coma.“

“Last night was my first time coming here and I’ll definitely be back. We were a party of 9 for girls night and ended up in a beautiful secluded room. We didn’t feel rushed at all and the service and food were both excellent! I highly recommend if you have a larger party like we did. Can’t wait to come back with my husband!“

“From Michigan, found this out of the way place and decided to try it because of all the excellent reviews. Reviews were spot on, even a gal from Virginia found them online, we both had excellent meals. Don’t miss this family run gem if your in the area. Thanks for a great dinner. Had the Full Monte with an 8oz Lobster side. Owner came out to see if dinner was what we expected. Bravo“

“Thankfully we got a table as walk ins, but the place was pretty busy. It’s a very beach vibe and the menu reflects all of the summer favorites. We got the Korean wings and avocado fries for starters. The wings were good, but I would pass on the avocado fries. I decided to take a chance and go for the tuna bowl. To my surprise, the tuna was delicious. The rice was cooked perfectly and it filled me up. My boyfriend got the double burger and he could barely finish it. His only commentary was that the waffle fries were trash.“

“Our pizza adventures continue and we found ourselves at the Anchor Inn a few nights ago. The place was full of families and friends enjoying a varied menu. We came for pizza but ended up ordering an appetizer and salad. Everything was very good! Service was fast and attentive. There’s an accessible entrance. Street parking was easy, but there’s also a parking lot. The place is probably a madhouse in the summer, but we had no trouble getting a table.“

“Mad Fish company has been a great addition to the island. What started as take-out only has evolved into a full sit down restaurant. The food is delicious, the serving sizes are great and the welcoming nature of Maddie and Gayle are unmatched. This is BYOB with both indoor or outdoor seating. I recommend the combo platter, it’s fresh and plentiful.“

“Food presentation and taste was wonderful. I was happy to see that they still serve a salad and side dish with the main entree as many restaurants don’t anymore. The restaurant itself was very cute, I do wish it was a bit larger of a space only due to noise. There was a very large party and the people talking/laughing in combination with the acoustics of the room just made it sound extremely loud inside, my husband and I could barely concentrate to talk. It would have been nicer to have the party in a private area, if the restaurant was larger. The staff were all very friendly and kind. Overall we were impressed and will def be back!“

“This is your real deal seafood market. And it was well priced too. We got two lobster tails, a set of crab legs, two steaks, and a lemon and it was only $70 and in amazing quality. Upon entering the shop the employees are working fast and moving through customers. Very happy with my experience here!“

“This is an absolute wow restaurant. There is nothing on the menu that's generic and everything has a personal touch to it. I got to meet the owners and they were the most down to earth friendly people. The clams were an excellent appetizer, followed by one of the best medium-rare prime ribs I've ever had. They absolutely nailed it. The rest of my party enjoyed the seafood they ordered. The dry scallops had by others were raved about and the service was top notch. This is a high end seafood restaurant with all the charm of a seaside inn. I absolutely can't wait to go back.“

“Have been coming here for 20+ years since I was a kid. I swear it keeps getting better. Years ago sometimes you'd have a bad day, a rough server, food that was good but not great. That's never the case the last several years everything about this place has gotten better. I get something different every time and today's was my favorite cocktail and favorite meal.“

“Came in for an early dinner with my son. We arrived at 4pm. By the time we left there was a wait, and it's obvious why. The food was so good. The wings were delicious, and cooked perfectly. I had the scallops and my son had the cheese steak. Two very different meals and both absolutely incredible. Our waiter was so awesome and attentive as well. Would 100% come back.“

“This place sells by far, the freshest seafood I've purchased in Ocean County. Today I bought and cooked shrimp, monkfish and scallops. The shrimp tasted like shrimp(not iodine) the monkish fish was the freshest I've ever eaten even in restaurants, this monkfish truly tasted like poor man's lobster but not at lobster prices. and the diver scallops were meaty, didn't release any water when cooked. Seafood Treasures is the only place I'll buy fresh seafood at reasonable prices. This place is truly a treasure!“

“Oh, the seafood history is very tangible here and park seafood on the boardwalk in Seaside Park Nicholas, the son of Bobby and the grandson of Nick clam House, has boardwalk history in his back pocket.Everything is super fresh everything is upgraded. All the flavors are super bright steam clams are super fresh. They do a nice job on the house lemonade if you want Ford work history Nicolas and park seafood and clam House is the place for classic boardwalk.“

“Our server, Fern, at the Toms River location was absolutely spectacular! From the moment she greeted us with a smile and hello, we felt instantaneously welcome to the restaurant!! Her customer service skills and upselling skills were beyond exceptional! We came in with the idea of just getting a little something to eat, and she helped us broaden our horizons and tried the new salt and vinegar shrimp!( out of this world) she refilled our beverages in a timely manner, checked on us frequently, did not rush us with the endless shrimp options and spaced out the timing of the next dish perfectly! Kudos to the team in Toms River and a big thank you to our server Fern for making our experience pleasant! Will definitely be back because of food and service!!!“

“Enjoyed an excellent meal last night with friends. Food was great, casual friendly atmosphere, service was excellent. Had the mussels, salads were great, seafood curry, blackened fish special, and short ribs to name a few. Then finished with daily bread pudding special and a tsunami for dessert! Will definitely return!“

“I must say Naples is the best pizzeria in town Not only is the pizza the perfect balance of cheese and sauce , the sauce is not sweet yet savory unlike many other pizza sauces. Also they address me by my name every time I walk in. They never forget me!! Very friendly and warm atmosphere!! I highly suggest. They also have a very warm and welcoming dining area in the back as well. The price is not as cheap for a pie , but then again what is these days. You get what you pay for. Which is a very good meal!! The entrees are big and delicious as you get many options on sides as well. Enjoy !!Dietary restrictions: They are extremely accommodating to any dietary restrictions or preferences just let them know ahead of time!Parking: Parking is located in the wawa parking lot along with Danny's Bayshore bagels.Kid-friendliness: AbsolutelyWheelchair accessibility: Yes!“

“The food was amazing I highly recommend the tagliatelle mushroom pasta. My only complaint is that my partner was charged $12 when he asked about substituting asparagus for broccoli and we weren’t told that it would be an additional charge (they didn’t even eat the broccoli) and when we asked about it we were brushed off. Other than that it was a great experience“

“First visit to the Spanish potato, food was excellent, the service was great we had John! Highly recommend for a great meal and good time!! Sangria was wonderful!!Parking: Plenty of parkingWheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp right in front to get in“