Customers` Favorites
“First time here this past Tuesday. The food was phenomenal. I took a friend from Brooklyn and she was very impressed also! We got the local oysters, New England clam chowder, Flounder picatta and the roasted chicken dish. All excellent!!“
Customers` Favorites
“Food is superb! Service is excellent! Very clean & nice atmosphere. I’ve never had a bad meal there!“
Customers` Favorites
“WOW! Truly what a great time at the Marlin!! The food was fantastic and the staff was even better!!!! The bar back, Evan, was such a nice person and worked super hard. The kitchen expo Mike was extremely helpful and answered our questions with the ut-most confidence. What a great establishment!!!! We will be back!!“
Customers` Favorites
“Our go to place when we go to the island.“
“My dad, Erich Rauer, recently passed away. I just wanted to share that this was one of his favorite places, he had a lot of good times with all his friends here, especially with his good friend Doug. Unfortunately in the past few years his illness prevented him from being able to hang out with everyone here as much as he would have liked to. But that didn’t stop him from sharing some stories of fun times here. On occasion my sister Kim or I had the pleasure of joining him for a few drinks. He was very proud of his German heritage, was a great fisherman back in the day, loved soccer and watching the FIFA World Cup, and a NY Giants fan for as long as I can remember.
But anyway, I just wanted to share the memory. I included a few pictures dad had sent me, of some good times he had over the past few years here.
- Shari Rauer“
Customers` Favorites
“Love this place, but was very disappointed in the happy hour oysters on 7/9/25….. very small….. other than that, everything else was great“
Customers` Favorites
“We have a great time when Chef prepares food as we the participants get to ask questions about products, recipes, etc! He makes the presentation fun and we always learn something new! Cinco de Mayo dishes were spectacular! Love this place!“
Customers` Favorites
“Had a wonderful retirement party there on 06/07. Everything was perfect. From the table settings to the personalized menu. The servers were excellent and the food was outstanding and got rave reviews from our guests and family. Calloways has always been a favorite of mine and now has many more. Thank you to the owner and all your amazing staff. And I think you have a few more converts to your Paul Bunyan Bloody Mary’s. They were yummy.“
Customers` Favorites
“Stopped by here for lunch on a Saturday. Had a really nice time at the bar with friendly local patrons and bar staff. I had the pulled pork chili and my wife had a chicken cheese steak. We both had a beer with lunch. Food was excellent. I can't wait to try the chicken wings which smelled awesome“
Customers` Favorites
“Great food! Great pricing.! Staff is phenomenal! Always so pleasant ,attentive, and accommodating!! Love to Pardi Hardi w/Nardi's!“
“Fair sized restaurant/bar. Three sided bar with really nice bar seats. A parallel dining room. Local oysters were really good. Has a big draft beer list. Brunch menu on Saturday and Sunday’s offers $10 mimosa or bloody Mary’s for the first one then they’re $2 after the first one. Brunch is from 11am to 230pm.“
Customers` Favorites
“You have to try the ranch fries they come with potato wedges but no get them with regular fries. To much potato with the wedges and takes the other flavors away with just potato. Food is amazing especially the scallops wrapped in bacon, and the seafood bisque. Been coming here for years and will continue with many more years.“
Customers` Favorites
“Great dinner with my husband. Lovely server!!“
Customers` Favorites
“Had a great stay for our first time here. Professional and extremely nice staff. Beautifully decorated for Christmas! Kids loved the pool.“
Customers` Favorites
“{{restaurant.reviews}}“
Loading...
“the hudson house is the happiest place on earth. after all my years coming here, i have never had anything less than a great experience. all of the bartenders are amazing, so personable, kind and friendly. robby fab and casey are the best!!!!!!!! if you don’t come here you’ve never experienced LBI!“