Lenny & John's Subs

$ • Sandwich Shops

Menu Order Online

About Lenny & John's Subs

Lenny & John's Subs offers tasty, huge sandwiches made fresh to order, though a bit pricey. It is considered the best spot for sandwiches on the Island, perfect for picking up breakfast or lunch. The menu features popular choices like the Italian sub and the polywog sandwich, or customers can customize their orders. The shop has a cozy atmosphere with several tables for indoor and outdoor seating, making it easy to enjoy a meal or take food to go. While there can be a wait due to call-in orders, many customers find that calling ahead can lead to quicker service, often having their meals ready in about 15 minutes. The sandwiches are known for being stuffed with meat and made with great bread, ensuring no one leaves hungry. The owner and staff are friendly, providing great counter service. The shop even serves hot coffee, making it a perfect stop for a quick pick-me-up during a beach day. Located within walking distance to the beach, it’s a great place to grab a satisfying meal and enjoy a beachy vibe.