15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Brown Mills

“Ordered delivery and the order arrived before the quoted time nice and hot! It's delicious too! The delivery driver was so nice! She dealt with my barking dogs and almost dropped soda like a champ lol thank you guys!! Will order again :)“

“After reading many recommendations, we were finally able to get to Riccardo's. We got a bar pie & a Salvo pie which were both excellent. The owner Vito came by & chatted with us for a bit to make sure we were having a good experience. Our waitress Devon was excellent as well. Nice place with nice atmosphere. Was worth the hour trip there to try it.“

“ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Couldn't figure out what kept drawing me back to this hidden gem until I realized they use the BEST Jersey Tomatoes in their perfect sauce (gravy). The dough is baked to a golden brown, semi crunchy goodness that pairs with the cheese like a match made in heaven. The service is ALWAYS great and never a wait. Looks super-clean every time I go and easy parking as well. The best tomato/pizza pie is there and the only place I'll go even though it's 20 miles out of the way. And the prices are VERY REASONABLE compared to everywhere else.Parking: Easy, close parking.“

“This pizza was awesome! Glad McGuire AFB and the surrounding area has an excellent pizza to go to. The prices are reasonable and the quality is there. The inside of this place is simply your classic pizza joint setup with some cool photos and memorabilia to look at. Dining in will give you a glimpse (for the new gen) or a flashback (for us old folk) of the simple life from the 80s and 90s. Highly recommend!P.s. I always forget to take the picture before I dive in, that's why it's half eaten lol.“

“Best pizza and wings in the area. The people who run the place are extremely nice. They remember me and my family whenever we go in there and always take really good care of us. We have made the pizza a Sunday lunch tradition for the kids and they look forward to it every week. I tried their wings and it ruined all other wings for me. Get the mild wings and tell me they are not the best wings in SJ. I used to go to another renowned SJ establishment for their wings and I paid an arm and a leg. These wings are better, closer to the house. and are easier on my wallet!Kid-friendliness: The place is mostly kid proof. My kids are animals.“

“White pizza was good. I like the thin crust and the garlic coverage was perfect. My son had the chicken and spinach panini. He really liked the sautéed spinach, the seasoned chicken, and the pita was grilled perfectly. Only downside, it was really cold inside the restaurant. We will be back again.“

“This place on the outside reminds me of what a hidden gem looks like. Went inside and was greeted by an extremely nice man who was extremely helpful and had a ton of stories. This place in the mood for Mexican is the go too spot around here. Tacos were amazing and everything was fresh.“

“We went to the Italian Villa last night for Dinner.. we just happened to be driving by and picked it out. The food was great! The service was awesome. The staff took extra time to have conversations with my 4 year old daughter and treated her with upmost respect and kindness. I highly recommend eating here!“

“Always very kind and great customer service when you call. They greet you when you come in and if you’re a regular they remember your name. Authentic Italian food made by the family that owns it. They have very good salad, my favorite it’s made with quality lettuce, roasted peppers, olives, and veggies. Their garlic knots are perfectly cooked and fresh, their sauce is nice and thick and fresh. They put their fries in a paper bag to keep them crispy. You’re getting good quality food and very friendly service if you come here.“

“Always take out (I always call ahead for pick up). Ready in 20 minutes, $20 cash. Honestly, it's the best pizza I've ever eaten, and it reminds me of pizza in Italy. I'm not kidding. Get a pie and see what all of the fuss is about.“

“This place is amazing and has the best pizza and pasta I’ve ever had. They have different toppings for pizza, and I love the one with the penne on top of the pizza cheese and sauce. It has that zesty bite to it with a bit of spice I can only put it as. The baked ziti is so good! It was sweet, saucy, and cheese filled goodness. Prices are good as well! Service is so nice and understanding. Definitely a place to go too!“

“Quiet and cozy atmosphere even with their usual full house. I've ordered from here countless times over the years and I have never been disappointed. Browns Mills can be hit or miss with pizza so I drive a little out of my way and it's well worthe it. They have a lot of specialty pizza's to choose from and they are all fantastic. We've had a few of their specials that aren't always on the menu like chicken cordon Bleu and it was delicious! That Sauce was definitely made fresh from scratch and was made traditionally which most restaurants can't execute. Impressive. Very Clean and the prices are fair. Anything you order from here, you will love for sure!“

“I've never had an unpleasant experience of any kind when we order from Papi's Pizza! I love that it's family owned and operated. The girls behind the counter are friendly and do an excellent job! The delivery driver's always arrive before the estimated time that I have been given over the phone when I place my order.- ☆☆☆☆☆ Extremely Satisfied“

“Best place around true family owned and operated, any food is amazing from pizza, to sandwiches, to wings. Custom anything, these guys are different know what they are doing. 35-45 min drive worth it every single time, truthfully care about the quality of the food & customers. Great experiences, amazing spot.“

“Honestly love this location. They are always fast and my order is always correct. The staff are friendly and helpful. My only wish is they delivered to me seeing as I'm in town but there radius is a bit small for that. Other then that definitely one of the best locations I have been to.“