32 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cookstown

“Love the pizza here. It reminds me of home. Brooklyn, NY. Would recommend 10 out of 10. Try the buffalo chicken with breaded chicken, that’s my favorite.“

“20 November 2024. Ordered nuggets breadsticks 2 pizzas. It was without a shadow of a doubt by far the most appealing order I've ever received from any domino's ever. The crew working tonight knew what they were doing. 🔥

No photos to add because we ate it all too fast 😬“

“Food was excellent! I’m a foodie, and have had seafood Alfredo at many places. This was by far De Best!!“

“Enzo , his wife, Anna and their sister-in-law are the nicest people you would want to meet along with some really delicious pizzas. The pizza, as my cousin from South Carolina would say "is blazin' cuz" with a crispy thin crust, a delicious homemade sauce along with generous toppings. With each bite, you can taste every ingredient in and on the pizza. Nothing gets left on the plate with the crust being just as good. Also, try their meatball sandwiches which will surely fill you up and have you coming back week after week. Nothing says "New Jersey" like "Bella Napoli"! Try getting a taste of that in other states. HA!“

“Best homemade Italian food We had the grandmom pizza, the eggplant parmigiana,the chicken parmigiana, the cheese steak and the homemade fresh mozzarella, was the best we never had!! Try Bella's you will be very impressed,“

“This was my first time trying mediterranean food and I loved every single thing I ordered. Plus, the service was easily one of the best I’ve ever had at any restaurant. Simply loved it.“

“We placed a large catering order with Jobstown Pizza and the food (chicken parm, chicken marsala, penne vodka, stuffed shells, salad, rolls, chicken fingers and fries) was outstanding. Everything from the customer service to the food and the delivery was outstanding.“

“The salads are BIG and there are severals options to choose from. My favorite it the House salad and Yordanas salad. The bruschetta is always fresh and delicious. Chicken Saltimbuco is my dh favorite. Also a great place to buy catered meals!“

“The staff were very friendly, HOWEVER, the food, the food was AMAZING!! (I made a special request to have ranch dressing added to my steak stromboli before it was baked... It was out of this world). When I tipped the cook, he gave me credit for the recipe, however NOT everyone with a recipe can cook it to perfection... He DID!! I strongly recommend you try this small town Pizzeria...“

“That’s the pizza once you can get it out of the box.“

“Excellent pizza, rice balls and garlic knots!!“

“I’ve eaten at Amari’s twice and plan to go back at least monthly because the food is scrumptious and very reasonably priced. The service is excellent as well; welcoming, friendly, professional and efficient. I highly recommend the caprese salad (I ask for tomatoes to be removed and prosciutto to be added), chicken soup and the pasta dishes.“

“They have awesome customer service skills and will customize orders to make it however you ask. Their food is consistently good and they are always kind! They also support the local schools and fundraisers! Thank you very much Red Star Staff!“

“Kitchy classic 1980's pizza place that is like stepping back into time. That's not a bad thing. Anthony is a character you can't help but enjoy ordering an old school no frills bur delicious pie. Tomato pie is great. Bring cash.“

“Just had an amazing chicken Parm sub with vodka sauce.“

“I live in Bordentown and this place is really a gem. Just excellent food, everything I’ve ever ordered was great. It has that true classic real pizza flavor. It is a standard pizza place in terms of style, but just fantastic quality food, and the employees are very nice.“

“That’s the pizza once you can get it out of the box.“

“Honestly love this location. They are always fast and my order is always correct. The staff are friendly and helpful. My only wish is they delivered to me seeing as I'm in town but there radius is a bit small for that. Other then that definitely one of the best locations I have been to.“

“Wonderful Italian food and beautiful atmosphere had take out plenty of times, and always good no matter what day of the week and we had a wonderful waiter Steven last night.“

“Great pizzeria. The food is good, the owner is accommodating and the people who work there are great. Great place to grab a slice for lunch or to sit down and have dinner.“

“This place is amazing! Excellent service, everybody was extremely kind. The food was delicious. We tried their cheese pizza, a Buffalo chicken cheesesteak, and an Italian grinder. Everything was delicious, hot, and fresh! I cannot recommend them enough!“

“Our family orders from here often. My order was incorrect and I had to pick at everyone else's food because we called back and we are currently on hold for 20 minutes and counting.... "we know you're hungry and will be with you as soon as possible." We had 3 inconveniences with them and it always happens to be my order. I hung up, I'm gonna try to call back one more time. If they don't answer, I'm done. I don't care how much I like their pizza and Stromboli. It's one thing making a mistake, that ok, but the fact it's not made right is the problem. Farewell“

“This place is legit. The food here is excellent. The staff friendly and if you don’t try it at least once you’re missing out.“

“Friendly staff, large portions! Excellent food! I enjoyed the food and will b back!!“

“We had a Birthday party here oct 5, 2024 in a private room and we were very pleased with everything from the food to the service. Our servers were fabulous!!!! would definitely recommend to everyone.“

“Just went to dinner with 7 of my gal friends! Had the best waitress was able to give us separate checks which included gratuities. The food was fantastic. We were able to sit and talk and was not noisy! We will be back“

“Consistently Delicious Pizza and Outstanding Service**

I've been a regular customer at Papa John's in Bordentown, NJ, and I cannot praise this location enough. The food is consistently delicious, and the service is top-notch.

The owner of this establishment is a true professional who genuinely cares about his customers. Every visit is met with a warm welcome, and you can always count on the staff to be friendly and efficient. It's clear that the owner has instilled a sense of pride and dedication in his team, as their commitment to providing an excellent dining experience shines through every time.

The pizza here is always fresh, with a perfect balance of toppings and that signature Papa John's taste. Whether I'm ordering for a quick lunch or a family dinner, I know I'll be getting high-quality, mouthwatering pizza every time.

If you're in the Bordentown area and looking for a reliable spot for great pizza and friendly service, look no further than Papa John's. Highly recommended!“

“Had our reunion dinner there last night. The food was outstanding and our waitress was tremendous. She did a fantastic job.“

“this place has a amazing tomato pie“

“Visited here for lunch with my children as we were passing through NJ on our way home from a holiday visit with family. Saw the great reviews and decided to try it out. We got Italian subs and pizza. The subs were absolutely delicious. Crisp, toasted bread, fresh meat and veggies, yummy sauce. We all loved them. And the pizzas were great too! We will make this a regular stop whenever passing through NJ again.“

“Been going here since the beginning. Pizza quality has gone downhill and now the staff is rude. Never again.“

“This place was interesting. I went there for food, and realized it's in a top golf. The food was not as expensive as I expected, and it was also better than I expected. The atmosphere was really weird tho. It felt like I was in a new car dealership with LED lights and a smell of rubber.

With that said, I still give it an 8/10. The staff were very friendly, the food was great, it was pretty cheap, I had a good time. Just be ready to be surrounded by top golf dad's ?“