24 Best Bakeries near Clayton

“Ty you to Yhannes for Outstanding service and the most DELICIOUS cheesecake you will find anywhere..Served thier products as part of our wedding reception and they were true highlights of the meal..Ty again“

“Delicious cupcakes and top tier customer service!“

“I normally recommend this place. Normally all the desserts I get so not disappoint. This past visit, I ordered the galaxy brownie cookie and the cookies and cream cheesecake that I’ve been looking forward too for a year. The cheesecake has good flavor but over baked so it’s gummy and chewy and not silky and smooth.“

“Can't say enough about Zimmermans! Both my boys (one who is special needs) absolutely love being able to play, have fun and do all holiday related activities! We have done their Christmas hayrides many years in a row, class trips, my kids birthday parties & attended many friends parties there! The owners are so kind, and truly take pride in their family owned business & making sure everyone has an unforgettable experience! Lucky to have such a wonderful place right in town!!!“

“Platinum House of Sweets created the wedding cake of our dreams! Not only was it stunning to look at, but it was absolutely delicious. From the very first bite, we were hooked—it was everything we wanted and more. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about the flavors, and neither could we. In fact, we were genuinely craving it long after it was finished! The team at Platinum House of Sweets truly outdid themselves, perfectly balancing beauty and taste to create a cake that was as memorable as the day itself. If you’re looking for a bakery that will exceed your expectations and leave you wishing for just one more slice, Platinum House of Sweets is the way to go. We couldn’t have been happier with their work!“

“I always get my cakes for special occasions at this bakery. We just threw a 50th surprise party. I emailed details on my desired theme and as usual Kristen knocked it out of the park. The cake was stunning to say the least and tasted even better than it looked! Great value for such incredible expertise. Thank you Aversa’s!“

“This past year I had to private events at Lamp Post, one brunch, one dinner. I can't begin to say how wonderful both was. The staff goes well above and beyond with everything and the food was great. You can't beat the price.“

“Best dessert, platter of custom cupcakes, and brownies. Ashley took care of everything as if it was for her own family. I certainly will be back for everything else I need. Thank you Ashley and Cacia!“

“I have ordered a lemon supreme cake, a limoncello cake , cookies and a half vanilla half chocolate cake . All were so very good . I highly recommend this bakery . I can’t wait to try more things .“

“Popped in for the first time ever after searching for a local bakery to grab something for a last minute Galentines treat and was not disappointed. Pickle dip, a best of 2025 box, and some crackballs. Everything was heavenly and SO fresh. Will think of this place first for every event from now on!“

“They're cookies are SO GOOD! I go there everytime I'm in Pitman“

“I just had my baby shower at Mademoiselle Macaron and it was perfect! The sandwiches, dessert, and tea were all so good. They also were happy to accommodate my nut allergy. It’s the perfect place for 25-35 people and is such a unique and adorable spot for any celebration! Highly recommend!“

“Best hoagie I've had in a long time ,will always order there“

“An amazing experience from start to finish! The communication was excellent, and the execution of this beautiful birthday cake exceeded my expectations. I couldn't be more pleased with the entire process. The Banana Foster flavor was absolutely delicious—so good that not a single piece was left over. A huge thank you for helping make the celebration so special!“

“Came by the other day and the pastries are amazing! Their bread are also soft and flavorful, if you manage to get them warm even better!! The workers are also very nice and provide a good experience so if you never tried authentic Mexican pastries this is the spot!! Will be coming here more often❤️❤️“

“Forgot to take a good picture to post but these ladies made the greatest promotional cookies for me. Had a special project in mind for a promotion. Gave them a picture and they got a custom cutter made and made the cookies almost identical to the picture! They looked hand painted. Like literally couldn’t have been better. They were durable enough for me to transport and individually wrapped.

If you go into their store front you’ll see they take the extra steps other people don’t. What they did for us was above and beyond any reasonable expectation. I’d HIGHLY recommend them for any sweet creation! I know I won’t be going anywhere else from now on“

“My husband planned a surprise 40th birthday party for me this weekend, and after our original baker had to cancel due to an unfortunate recurrence of her cancer, he suddenly found himself without a cake and very little time. In a moment of desperation, he turned to you—and we are so grateful that he did. The cake was light, delicious, and absolutely beautiful. He ordered a chocolate cake with crushed Reese’s cups and whipped icing, and it exceeded every expectation. Thank you so much for not only saving the party, but for making my cake truly special. You’ve gained loyal customers in us, and based on the number of compliments we received, you’ll have plenty of new customers coming your way as well!“

“Excellent breads, rolls, pastries, and cakes. I highly recommend for these items. Their tiramisu is phenomenal.

We recently ordered several strombolis. While the pepperoni with cheese was awesome. The others weren't very flavorful at all. The roast pork with broccoli rabbe did not have any seasoning, or so little that it wasn't detectable.

The other was bland as well. So bland, I cannot recall which one. Also, we were supposed to get a side of marinara but it was missing from the order. I picked up the early, around 7:30-8 am. My fault for not checking before I drove 3.5 hours home.“

“I have used saps for several occasions . Food is amazing and I am never disappointed in anything I get from hot dishes, fruit, salads to the amazing cookies!“

“The staff was great and helped me out. I arrived long after my appointment into the night. It could not be helped. Building 6 is trailer staging. Building 7/8 drive and door 15 is the one you're looking for check in. Definitely no overnight parking. Ignore the visitor must check in signs as you pull in. Those are not for you. Just find door 15 at the building 7 drive. I parked in building 6 staging and walked there.“

“If you're traveling through New Jersey and have a sweet tooth, you absolutely must stop at this Amish-run bakery. They make some of the best hand-made donuts I've ever had.

I'm a frequent traveler, and I'm always on the hunt for the perfect Boston Cream donut. After trying countless versions across the country (from New York to Vegas), I can confidently say this bakery sets the gold standard.

Their donuts are noticeably larger and heavier than most, and the quality is exceptional. The dough is incredibly fresh and light, and the fillings are divine. I've tried several of their flavors, and each one was outstanding.
At just $2 per donut, it's an incredible value. You can truly taste the love and dedication that the owners and their team put into every single creation.

Whenever I'm in New Jersey, I always make a special detour to visit this bakery. It's that good.“

“wonderful job on my daughters Taylor Swift themed cake and cupcakes today! so beautiful and delicious.“

“The cupcakes and donuts are amazing!“

“I went to Cinnabon and the vibes and business was great. I am also an employee at the Gloucester Outlets and every time I go into Cinnabon I ask the employees names. Faith and Nick were great workers and had a great vibe. They made the presence there amazing. The hospitality was great! 10/10 recommend! The business is great! My daughter Ella and Mia are obsessed“