50 Best Italian Restaurants near Columbus

“Great Pizza! Especially Their Chicken Ranch!“

“Food was amazing !! Must check out“

“We had 31 people for our Christmas party this afternoon, everything was above and beyond! The food was delicious and abundant! Thank you so much for being so attentive, friendly and welcoming. We will be back next year!“

“The food has always been good here, but our waitress last night was above and beyond. It was packed but she never let more than a few minutes pass to check on us. In our rush to leave, we forgot to grab our leftovers and she ran to the parking lot to catch us! Mackenzie is a huge asset to your business and her service is truly appreciated, thank you!“

“great family owned business with good food and interesting weekend specials“

“If you are looking for a family based excellent restaurant this is your place. Iccara has been in business for as long as I can remember. Their food is outstanding, the atmosphere on point. Most importantly the family are awesome! If you've never been you are missing out on a true gem! Now I'm hungry lol!!“

“We got their menu in our mailbox last week. Tried them tonight and we enjoyed their food very much. Nice thin crispy crust, nicely seasoned sauce, nice amount of cheese and toppings. A definite "recommend" !“

“excellent menu. food is soooo good! atmosphere awesome, staff excellent. our favorite local spot for almost 30 years!!!“

“From mouthwatering cocktails to exquisite dishes in a stunning local restaurant where you can be soothed by the band and catered to by staff...nothing compares.“

“Have had dinner there several times with friends and everyone has always been most complimentary of meals served. I have personally enjoyed the shrimp and scallops as well as stuffed flounder. Also ordered for take out catering trays of chicken and penne vodka for a family event which were wonderful. Great place with a strong menu and terrific meals. Also ordered several catered dinners for my family including chicken Marcella and penne vodka.“

“We had our Thanksgiving dinner and everything was great. I look forward to additional gatherings in the future.“

“First time dining at diamonds. Everything was absolutely delicious. The fried calamari had some spicy hot peppers in it with a marinara sauce. It was so good my husband had his favorite chicken Parmesan with Bolognese sauce super scrumptious, and I had the beef Wellington with pasta. it was absolutely outstanding. We will definitely be back . Thank you so much for a wonderful experience.“

“You will always see this place full of happy returning patrons and we are two of them. Food quality is fresh, tasty and reasonably priced. You have to try their Brick Oven pizzas. If you crave an American cheese hoagie, that is prepared on the best tasting roll in New Jersey, delicious cheese, and crisp lettuce and onions, try one of theirs. The very best that we have ever judged.“

“Don't let this place fool you. It may not look like much from the outside. The pizza is excellent. Have even had a number of family events there over the years and it was great every time. Was there tonight and will certainly be back. They put their $ into the quality of the food rather than the ambiance. Place is clean and the owner and staff are friendly. Rates 10 Stars if possible. Reminds me of Pizza places I would frequent with my friends back in the early 70s“

“Food was cooked to perfection and staff are great! Perfect Thursday Night Jazz 🎵🎶 Guest with music and vocal talent are welcome to join in ❤️“

“We ordered a tray of Chicken Parmigiana with vodka sauce for Christmas Eve dinner. It was absolutely amazing. We finished off with cannolis which were huge and so delicious! Romeo is the best, whatever you want, he will do!“

“We had a fantastic late lunch on Easter Sunday at Toscano. We started with cocktails at their bar in front and then proceeded to enjoy a most delicious meal at our table. Bone-in ribeye and the 10oz filet were the main course with Caesar salad and French onion mashed potatoes on the side. Service was very attentive from Brianna and overall experience was great, definitely recommend.“

“Great pizza and fast delivery! Shout out to Brodie.“

“Had our reunion dinner there last night. The food was outstanding and our waitress was tremendous. She did a fantastic job.“

“Good food and great people“

“great dinner with friends tonight. waitress actually remembered us from a few months ago. thank you for the great food and service. salmon was delicious!“

“The food is great; the owners are friendly, all around good people! I’d recommend this place for take out or private parties!! My husband loves the pizza 🍕 💕“

“Pepperoni pizza was delicious. First time stopping in, the slices weren’t selling me but I ordered a plain & a pepperoni and my first bite I was sold I didn’t even have to add garlic!! Will be back“

“Had a party for 30+ people. Everything was first class! Food was out of this world, service great, atmosphere nice. Manager was great to work with. All my guest raved about the food. I Just discovered this place in December and it is by far my favorite place!!“

“Food is delicious and we had the best service ever there!!“

“Celebrated my wife's birthday last weekend. Food was delicious, service was excellent...we will be back!!“

“Food is Absolutely Amazing. Pizza is delicious, staff is very attentive and you feel at Home! I waitressed there in my 20's as a second job and everything about it has stayed authentic 45 years later! We had the Ceaser salad, clams casino, chicken marcella & pizza. Everyone really enjoyed all of it. Topped off with salted carmel expresso martinis to die for! 👌 Truly a Lower Bucks County Treasure!🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“Best Pizza in The Area!! 🙌“

“Sunday bike ride then pizza for lunch“

“We ordered 2 family trays for delivery. food is amazing and the trays have soooo much in them. Will be ordering again!“

“I normally order from DeLorenzo’s “The Burg” location because it’s very close to me, but since they are closed on Mondays, I decided to try this DeLorenzo’s instead—and I’m so happy I did!!
Before placing my order, I called to ask whether they offered a chicken parm pizza. The person I spoke with explained that they don’t make that; however, he went above and beyond by offering to make it for me anyway. That level of customer service immediately stood out.
When we picked up the pizza, it exceeded all expectations. It was absolutely delicious—perfectly made, filled with chicken, flavorful, and truly a 10/10. You could tell care and pride went into making it.
Between the exceptional customer service and the incredible food, this experience was fantastic. I’m very thankful for the extra effort and kindness shown, and I will absolutely be returning. Highly recommend this location to anyone looking for great pizza and even better service.“

“Wonderful, Wonderful & Wonderful!“

“Best customer service pick up or take out! Orders are always correct if not they will make them right. Greet food and price“

“I wanted to try something different so I decided to place a DoorDash order from here since I live too far for store delivery. I was pleasantly surprised. The food was absolutely delicious & fresh. I ordered the chicken noodle soup and Greek salad w/chicken & tuna. It was to die for!! I’m so happy I gave this place a try, it will be my new go to!“

“Huge shoutout to Angelo’s tonight. Only wish I would’ve remembered my server’s name, to give her extra recognition here. We went out for an important dinner tonight. We were celebrating something small, but meaningful. When we called they had no reservations available for the evening, but then called us back and squeezed us in at 4:30. The power went out in the entire city after we were served our first course. We were served our entrees in the dark, with the same elegance, as of nothing had occurred. Even with the unfortunate circumstances, we were treated like royalty by the entire staff, and had an exceptional dining experience. I will be dreaming of the escarole, until I have it again. Thank you Angelo’s! Great job! 👏🏽“

“Great dishes Your son is incretable“

“Ethan was an incredible server! Very attentive & took great care of us, will definitely be returning!“

“Best homemade Italian food We had the grandmom pizza, the eggplant parmigiana,the chicken parmigiana, the cheese steak and the homemade fresh mozzarella, was the best we never had!! Try Bella's you will be very impressed,“

“What Amazing food and staff!“

“Excellent service, delicious food. Highly recommend!“

“Great spot. Have a drink at the speakeasy prior. Then enjoy excellent salads, apps, pizza as the main course. Well done!“

“The ST did not disappoint. We noticed a small change to the menu where the macadamia crusted grouper was replaced with a whitefish. The good news is it is just as good as ever. The chicken parm was also a winner. Great ratio of chicken, sauce and cheese! We will be back.“

“i love their food. it never disappoints. everything is so good. pizza, sandwiches, chicken fingers, etc. everything ive tried so far is really good. sometimes the wait for delivery is an hour, but my food is still hot when it gets here! i really love this place!“

“A local classic! Rocco's has been serving amazing pizza for decades. A staple of Florence Township!“

“Absolutely amazing food absolutely amazing customer service BEST MEXICAN FOOD IN TOWN!!!! I’ve been in Jersey for about 3 months from Texas and it’s been so hard to find some good Mexican food!!! They are definitely my favorite ever, and the prices are unbeatable! Their other food is just as good too I loved the pizza so much!“

“Their Chicago deep dish is to DIE for!“

“Ordered dinner tonight and 15 minutes later, they brought it out curbside & loaded into my car. Zero contact. The food was fresh, hot and delicious! Thank you!“

“Best 🍕 Pizza in So. Trenton !!!“

“We’ve been regulars for years and we are never disappointed! Amazing weekly special!!! Along with a large daily menu. Such a comfortable, friendly atmosphere. The staff and the Owners go above and beyond.“