11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fair Lawn

“best pizza, served with a warm smile“

“I came all the way from Brooklyn to New Jersey just to try this pizza at Benjy’s kosher pizza after hearing it has a real Israeli-style taste — and it was absolutely worth the trip.

The pizza was excellent, with an authentic flavor that really brings you back to what you’d find in Israel. The dough, sauce, and cheese all blend perfectly together, and everything tasted fresh and high quality. The service was also outstanding — friendly, fast, and professional, with a great atmosphere that made the experience even better.

Overall, it was a great experience both in terms of food and service. Definitely a place worth coming back to, and highly recommended for anyone missing that real Israeli pizza taste.“

“Hi, just wanted to say. How great this place is. I ordered on Satuday. They forgot to add my 2 chicken empanadas to my pick up oder. I called and left a message but they were closed. I called on Monday spoke to Stepanie and she was very apologetic. She suggested i pick them up. Which I did. Long story short. They replaced it with 4 empanadas. Great customer service. Empanadas are delicious. Recommend highly..Many blessings for their business.. Will order again...“

“muy buena la pizza 🍕 y la atención muy amables todos gracias“

“This Place is amazing!!!! Movie Theater Quality looking pizza. It felt like I was in a Teenage Mutant Ninja turtle Movie. Don't get me started how the food taste. Last time I went was 2023. Can't wait to bring the wife to this Place. Ness knows what they're doing.“

“i love this place and have been coming here a lot the past year. the service is very good and at this point he remembers that i just get one slice buffalo chicken and its only 3 bucks. its insane how much you get for only 3 bucks and its probably my favorite pizza place in fair lawn.“

“Hello, typically I do not leave food reviews but I just wanted to say you guys seriously have some awesome pizza. Not only does this beautiful place have awesome pizza but the nicest server took my call this weekend. I believe her name was Angelina, let me tell you guys that is the exact kind of staff member you want taking your order. It honestly brightened my whole day she was very patient in explaining the items you guys had to offer and cracked a few jokes. This place has awesome pizza and food but what’s gonna make me come back is the kind of people you guys have staffed this place with thank you for the wonderful time!“

“Lately terrible . Portions of food are l so cut down .. I ordered meatball hero and if there was 2 meatballs on it I’d be shocked .. was all bread . I know economy is hurting but so Are we !!!! I’d rather pay higher prices but don’t scrimp on the portions…. Chicken dinners are half the usual meat . I been going there for years regular weekly with family or ordering out. I am through now …. We are all hurting ..also now they charge fir extra dressing on salad !! Just I’ve past 18 months or so . Very disappointed but even if food is decent for our area , I can’t buy a meatball hero and have to go buy a whopper right after I’m done because I’m still hungry!!!! Beware all in Fair Lawn , search elsewhere.“

“Amazing pizza and great food all around. I dont live close by but believe me the trip is worth it and love the variety of food to eat here. I truly recommend dining in or ordering delivery (they deliver to most northern nj towns n cities all day & all night)“

“I haven’t been here in a while but just picked up a 1/2 buffalo and 1/2 plain pie. Wow!!! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. The sauce is so tasty and the buffalo chicken was perfect with the right amount of 🔥
Definitely will be my go to place.“

“Actually the food is very good. The old owner was very bad in dealing but now with the new owner the dealing is great and the service is good. Also the delivery service of the restaurant is the best if you want to get the food as quickly as possible I do not recommend delivery companies. The honest driver in the restaurant is the best thing and if you do not like anything you will talk to him and he will bring you your order again as soon as possible. Thank you for your kindness“