“Food was great! Michelle was out waitress and couldn't be nicer. She was attentive and always smiled. What a Doll. Would definitely come back again. Atmosphere is old school neighborhood pizzeria. OK for me, but could use a little TLC to brighten up the place, just a bit.“
“Have not been here in years. Service was amazing. Our server Tim was the best. The owner was so friendly and attentive. Food was fresh, hot and tasty. Atmosphere was family friendly and great for all ages. Very reasonably priced. Bonus- upstairs if you want to host a party. We will definitely be going back. We highly recommend the Firehouse“
“Wow!! I am blown away. Probably the nicest people I’ve ever encountered. I’m vegan and my son isn’t I always struggle to find pizza places we can both go. This place is amazing. The vegan food is home made ! The pizza my son loved. Super reasonable prices. The family is so down the earth!!! They put on a show for my son to watch while we eat I highly recommend! Best pizza place around !“
“Excellent authentic Italian food in Garfield, NJ. Make sure you make reservations in advance if going on a Friday, Saturday or Sunday, you will not get in without one. Though they are a little understaffed, the staff is very professional and accommodating. We had appetizers, pizza, main courses and dessert all were excellent. It is a BYOB, the could use a host or hostess during evenings to help with the seating of guest, etc. Definitely will be going back.“
“Came to drop off FiOS equipment at the Verizon store during the day so I stopped in for two slices for lunch. I got a chicken bacon ranch slice and a plain slice. Service was quick, clean inside, couple of tables. I decided to take them to go because I was in a hurry. I was able to eat them in the car and there was zero oil drip so I was pretty happy about that. Could be a tad saucier but overall decent and good slices. Only about $7 for both.“
“It's definitely been At least 30 years since I been here , the original owner passed away but definitely left it in good hands, the new owner is real nice and definitely making quality pizza. Just like I remember it back when. Things that I like , they have beer, the inside is nice n dated, no need for high end renovations like everywhere else. Gives it a nice old school cozy feel. Good pizza , good atmosphere , nice people , 10/10“
“Their food is amazing. They have a great Tuesday special and unlike other places there’s specials on Tuesday are just as good as their pies as any other day. The only thing I would say, is that the person that normally answers the phone should be taught how to speak to people, extremely rude but other than that everything is “
“If you are ready for a great time for a great price, great Italian food, and the best service! This is the place for you! My husband and I had a great experience! The entire staff was very nice! The food is absolutely fantastic and their prices are unbeatable! Very affordable for what they give you and the food is very fresh! Great service and no wait time! We highly recommend this place!“
“The best empanadas in the area. Always fresh! They have a variety of empanadas besides the classic beef, cheese, or chicken. Just had the crab and shrimp empanadas, juicy and super delicious! Highly recommend this place! It's no wonder my parish has been getting them from here hahaParking: Parking is somewhat difficult here as you can see in Garfield there's these camera posts installed so if you stick around too long it takes a picture of your license plates and get a ticket mailed“
“The pizza is amazing! The vodka sauce pizza is out of this world! It’s a must order pizza! I ordered out, but there was plenty of space to sit and eat. Their menu has pasta choices, giro and sandwiches but that all. No wings or fries. Either way, this place had amazing pizza!“
“Best wraps and salads you can get from a pizza restaurant. I have been addicted every since I tried their wraps me and my coworkers order from here almost everyday. The grilled chicken is very tasty and grilled to perfection. Any sandwich wrap or salad they make with it tastes amazing. Also prices are very reasonable.“
“My partner and I love ordering from here. We live in the neighborhood and it’s so convenient to have a place like this we can walk to for something delicious at a great price. I don’t think you could go wrong ordering anything off their menu; their pizza is the perfect Jersey pizza, their burritos are huge and taste SO fresh, and their cheeseburgers are like In N Out but WAY better quality. They also have desserts and the chocolate cake I tried was great. Love Aileen’s “