13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Garfield

“Vengo spesso a prendere la pizza a pranzo, uso i buoni Coverflex ma non trovo Pizza Mania nell’app, pensate di attivarli?“

““Absolutely one of the best pizzerias around. The pizza is always fresh, crispy, and full of flavor with high-quality ingredients in every bite. The staff is friendly, the service is fast, and the atmosphere feels welcoming every time. From the sauce to the dough, everything tastes authentic and made with care. Easily a 10/10 experience — highly recommended for anyone who loves real pizza.”
La bella the best“

“In New Jersey, it’s really difficult to find appealing vegan options. This shop blows every other option in NJ out of the water!
The pizzas are delicious, my S/O and I have tried the buffalo, BBQ, pepperoni pizzas and the garlic knots and they are all so delicious!
Most of all, ever since going vegan, I just came to terms with the fact that I would never be able to have a good calzone ever again. The VEGAN CALZONES HERE ARE SO DELICIOUS and they are HUGE!!! You have to try them! And I am sure that the non-vegan options are just as delicious as it’s not so easy to have a good vegan menu but they have it down pat! I should have written this review a long time ago and for that I apologize!
The owners here are so sweet too. They are great people! Please try something from here you won’t regret it!

Vegetarian options: VEGAN OPTIONS ARE AMAZING“

“Pizza isn't my style. I prefer well done and less cheese. This slice was covered from tip to crust in cheese but was floppy. Taste was good. Garlic knots were just ok. The sauce was good and the knots were light and airy but taste was ehh. Service was good. $9.50 for one slice, 5 garlic knots and a Snapple“

“Mussels with a garlic red pepper sauce that is addictive!“

“This is the best Pizza in Garfield hands down. I’ve been all over the tri-state area trying different pizzas, CT style, NY style, Neopolitan, grandma, whatever the style is, I’ve had many. This place doesn’t miss, excellent ingredients, nice premium cup pepperoni, and just a great pie overall. Miles ahead of the previous establishment to anyone who ACTUALLY knows pizza.

The owner is a nice guy, pains me to see all of these 1 star reviews calling him rude simply because he doesn't allow 100 kids to sit there after school as the prior one did. I’ve been here 4 times in the last 2 weeks and have been treated swiftly and with respect the entire time.

His plain pies are great, the specialities are great, mozzarella sticks don't miss either — I have no idea why everyone in town doesn’t come here.“

“wow what can I say growing up 🇮🇹 the resteraunt best 🇮🇹 home made real dishes I know nick long time my father Emilio worked with him at his bakery called Venice bakery they treat us like family every time me my family are present the best in business“

“Excellent pizza/food. Their cold sub Parmigiano is amazing“

“Good food and plenty of it“

“Very nice family friendly restaurant enjoyed their thin crust pizza 🍕 nice welcoming staff will come back to partake on the rest of their menu options George rudawsky“

“They have absolutely earned much more than 5 stars as far as I’m concerned, they have never once disappointed me with my orders, deliveries, special requests & most of all the food is always delicious!! & they’re always pleasant, welcoming, amazing young men…I just love this place!!! Thanks guys so very much for all that u do & for being the great people u r!!! I wish I can give you more than 5 stars…“

“I called this morning at 6am to inquire how long it would take them to make 3 dozen empanadas, for a work event, they said ten mi utes! They saved my day. The empanadas were a hit at work! They were delicious! I bought chicken, beef and cheese! They’re affordable too! Gracias! 🙏🏽 I’ll be buying from here again.“

“Delicious pizza from the good old days! Large menu, casual atmosphere, family owned restaurant. Staff is kind & accommodating. A definite “must try” kinda place … You won’t be disappointed!!! Food is delicious!!“