8 Best Pizza Restaurants near East Rutherford

“Phenomenal first time experience. I ordered the $7 deal- comes with half a pie, one topping, one drizzle and drink. I got mine with chicken and ranch and it was amazing. Make sure to order the spicy tomato sauce for a kick. Almost went back in and ordered another one!!“

“Lemme tell you... from the outside (and inside, for that matter) you might not think much of this place but they are punching way above their weight-class.

They're knocking out one of the best pizzas from all the surrounding towns.

Nothing flashy or fancy... just a traditional pie perfectly executed with a handful of quality ingredients.

And their take on the humble garlic knot? Pure elevated magic.

(With each bite you'll wonder why all the other places still bother making those greasy-heavy ones we've all just grown accustomed to.)

Good pricing.
Cool crew behind the counter.
A bit of street parking is available (but the area isn't friendly with narrow roads, annoying one-ways, you name it).

Definitely worth checking out.“

“Delicious pizza. Mussels and calamari both great as well. Service was great, prices reasonable. Liquor store right next door - convenient for a BYOB.“

“Excelente atención ala persona 👍“

“Amazing pizza and excellent friendly service. The restaurant is clean, welcoming, and convenient. Highly recommend if you are in the area.“

“An awesome family run business with excellent staff!!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻“

“Super convenient, friendly staff, good management. Food is good... it's Papa John's, all the complaints are unwarranted. It used to be the BEST late night option, unfortunately complaints from the neighbors forced the 12am closing time.“

“Every year visit. Always amazing“