50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carlstadt

“My husband and I was craving some good authentic pizza and let me just say this place DID NOT disappoint. The owner and everyone that worked there was super nice which made me love it even more. I wanted my husband who’s from Baltimore to try zeppole, he’s never heard of it and for me, growing up in Bk and Staten Island it was one of my childhood favs. They didn’t have any made when I asked about it which was fine but while I was in conversation with their delivery driver the owner came out with some. He actually went out of his way to make me some zeppole, and it was delicious and extremely nostalgic for me. He has no idea how that made my day and brought back so many memories to me. Their food is delicious, atmosphere warm and friendly. I recommend this place and we will be back.“

“I am thrilled that I discovered this Amazing Pizzeria restaurant. The best Italian Food around! Their burgers are Absolutely delicious! Their pizza is the very best! All of their bread is homemade!! I can't say enough about this place!!! I would give them 10 stars if I could!!!“

“Another incredible Friday night wrap!! Never had a bad wrap here! Frequently order here because the food never disappoints. Tonight’s Pompeii wrap was so good I could have eaten another one lol“

“Amazing spot! The man who served me was beyond cool, polite and just a 10/10 kind of guy. Best service!

I ordered some sausage, egg and cheese’s on everything bagels and they were perfect, exactly what I needed to start my morning.

I forgot to ask for the name of the man that served us, but I know he has great tastes in music.“

“Great Italian food and a decent menu, not much choice but not too much. It's located next to Post Office 34 and is very trendy. The view and service are great, but it's noisy as there isn't much to absorb the sound. We ordered focaccia, roasted peppers and pasta. Everything is great and super fresh.“

“Great and delicious pizza, excellent friendly customer service and cool space.“

“The pizza is excellent, there is a modest amount of space to eat in, and they have a bar so customers can enjoy an adult beverage with their meal. Friendly service and a reasonable wait makes this good value for one’s money. We will be back!“

“Although I went in shortly after 2 on a weekday, there was still quite a bit of a line but I didn't have to wait very long before ordering at the counter. The burrata pizza was delicious and rich in both the feeling and texture. Adding the spicy oil to the pizza made it taste even better. Overall, it's worth waiting in line for some great pizza but I recommend going during quieter hours when the lines aren't as long. It's a must visit while visiting NYC or even if you live nearby.“

“Excellent“

“Their pizza is delicious and they were super friendly! Love that’s it’s nice and close to Penn Station, a great first stop after we arrived in the city!“

“the best! staff was so lovely and welcoming!!“

“Very good atmosphere and very tasty pizzas. A real treat!“

“This is the best pizza I have ever had, nice crisp, light crust with just the right amount of toppings, no grease at all. I live in CT and thought no pizza was better than our New Haven ones, boy was I wrong!!! Looking forward to returning……soon!“

“Pizza was delicious (and larger than expected, which made the price point more bearable. Limited options, but love that they let you do half and half of pizza type. Alexis, server, was really great. Some of the other servers could learn from her.“

“Very Friendly service. Staff were great and assisted with menu choices. Most of all the Pizza was Delicious 😋“

“Had the pleasure of eating here today with my family. What a wonder experience! Staff was extremely friendly and helpful, beautiful opera being played lightly in the background, and the food was amazing with large portions. Would absolutely recommend! We will definitely be coming back on our next trip to NY!“

“3z3d3d33d3ddezze3ez x🙂‍↔️🤪🤪🤔😗😶‍🌫️😉🙏🙏😘🙂‍↔️😘🙂‍↔️😶‍🌫️😃😘🙂‍↔️🤪🙏. d x3 32e3de 3“

“7.8/10
- very floppy, too floppy imo
- pepperoni is fire. Thin, crispy, price is on point
- tri slice was good but couldn't taste the pesto imo, other sauce overpowered the pizza. Wouldn't justify buying again but it's chill.

Edit:
- it was 2am and the slice we got was pretty crispy, barely any flop. Its good! Got Chicken Vodka & Tri slice, and it was like a good, 7.7 slice. Not doughy, crisp, good flavor -ish.“

“Setting Zagat scores, foodie reviews, and multi- year celebrity endorsements aside for this 51-year old pizza destination, it is hard to imagine a better New York-style slice. The crisp crust, the flavorful sauce and toppings heated up with a toss of additional mozzarella shreds before serving equals pizza nirvana. If you don't want the best slice of your life at 3am, don't go. But if you want to experience one of the most delicious and quintessentially-authentic New York experiences, let Maps show you the way.“

“If you go to NY you must grab a slice of pizza from Champion pizza! It was my favorite slice during my visit last year. Crispy bottom but melt in your mouth topping! So so good!“

“Family owned italian pizza, next to Port Authority Bus Terminal. The best pizza I had in a long time! Friendly service, nice decor with family pictures. I highly recommend!!!“

“Authentic lovely food Napoli style! Top class!“

“I grew up in a Pizzeria (literally), and I know a genuine Pizzaiolo when I see one.

The owner, and who I believe to be his wife, are the real deal. Genuinely good people making simple, fresh, and delicious food. The pizza is fantastic and authentic. The sandwiches are phenomenal. The bread is made to-order. This place is the very definition of Italian cooking personified in a little pizza place which finds itself in Union Square.

Thank you for your amazing food and genuine hospitality. Tanti auguri!“

“highly recommended“

“We dropped by Ace's Pizza around 3pm., Brooklyn, 30 Rockefeller Plaza, 5th Ave NYC and it was such a great experience! The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating—amazing service all around. We ordered the Grilled Chicken Sandwich, Caesar Salad, and a 14-inch Pepperoni Pizza. Every single item was delicious! The quality of the food was outstanding. The pepperoni pizza especially stood out—crispy crust, flavorful toppings, and just the right amount of cheese. We really enjoyed everything we ordered, and the overall vibe of the place made the experience even better. Highly recommended if you’re in the area and craving great pizza!“

“Delicious!! Loved the place“

“The ranch dressing with the bbq Pollo is absolutely incredible“

“How has Dave Portnoy not reviewed this yet?! It was amazing. Like this is what I expect from all NYC pizza.

I noticed the sign in the front of the store was a screenshot of a Gemini summarization. 1. Interesting marketing, but free and straight to the point so kudos to them. 2. Lots of AI ads in the city but they thought outside of the box by using AI still without a Seed A AI enterprise solution start up company, kudos again!“

“I love the delicious salads and pizzas at their store!“

“One word DIABLO !!!🙏❤️ Frost Beer was ice cold !!!“

“Delicious wood fired pizza with amazing toppings including vegan options. Wonderful, cozy environment and eclectic playlist. You won’t be disappointed!!“

“I spent the last few days going a concert at the Bowery Ballroom and went to Nolita pizza every night and it is the best pizza I’ve ever had. The Sicilian double pepperoni with hot honey was insanely delicious. I’m waiting for them to add my new appetizer I suggested pepperoni basket . Because they are so delicious. Everyone working there especially the owner is super grateful and kind. Highly recommend and can’t wait to get back to NY to get it again! #bestpizzanycnolita #nolitapizzanyc #nolita #TheAirborneToxicEventFansloveNolita pizza #Medici❤️Nolitapizza😃🍕“

“I do not like pizza but after having the truffle oil and mushrooms I can honestly say it was best and if I come back - would definitely come back . The girl who was behind the counter was absolutely wonderful—lovely customer service!!“

“El personal es muy amable, atentos y deliciosa comida.“

“Always such a pleasure coming into this pizzeria!! Very flavorful and the sauce is tasty . I love how creative they get with their pies. My favorite is the margarita. The customer service is awesome. Always greeted with a smile if you’re looking for a good slice in the lower east side area stop in they’re amazing.“

“Want to try one of New Yorks best places for a slice of pizza? Pop's Pizza is delicious! We had 3 different specialty slices. Meat lover, Spinach w/mushroom and a square pepperoni. OMG. Each had their very own taste, texture. The sause was perfect.“

“The wait staff and food were absolutely amazing.“

“Margarita Pizza was delicious. Will definitely be back to try some more adventurous styles.“

“Finally got around to trying it after having it on my list for a couple of years. I hadn’t had the chance to make it out to Brooklyn before, but I’m so glad I finally did. The pizza was everything I imagined and more. We were the first ones to order, and it ended up being one of my favorite pizzas I’ve had to date. The crust was light and crispy, the sauce was packed with flavor, and every bite lived up to the hype. An absolute must-try in New York, and I can’t wait to come back.“

“Un lugar lleno de historia y con bastante sabor!!! Un gran punto dentro de la gótica cuidad de NY“

“I love coming here! Whether eat in, order take-out directly or Doordash it, they are always on point. I've tried a variety of things on their menu including dessert. It's always perfect! Great job with the flavors & consistency of all your dishes!“

“What a wonderful restaurant great mix of foods and service was so friendly. Highly recommend butternut fries to start!“

“Cadre très sympa et pizza au top !“

“We dropped by Ace's Pizza around 3pm., Brooklyn, 30 Rockefeller Plaza, 5th Ave NYC and it was such a great experience! The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating—amazing service all around. We ordered the Grilled Chicken Sandwich, Caesar Salad, and a 14-inch Pepperoni Pizza. Every single item was delicious! The quality of the food was outstanding. The pepperoni pizza especially stood out—crispy crust, flavorful toppings, and just the right amount of cheese. We really enjoyed everything we ordered, and the overall vibe of the place made the experience even better. Highly recommended if you’re in the area and craving great pizza!“

“Food was amazing! I recommend😍“

“Great tasting food and nice atmosphere. Also a very attractive waitress, beautiful“

“Super legit lentil and chicken noodle soups. Wow superbly plated. Excellent ambiance and vibe. Amazing service bringing food to our table too! Very grateful to share space with the squad here while my mom and i recap our softball comeback down 5-2. Highly recommended“

“What an amazing dinner! We came for a family celebration and we we not disappointed!!“

“i was recommended to try the pepperoni and the spinach slices and they did not disappoint! the spinach slice was really good and my bf said that it was very similar to what he had in italy but just in a new york style slice. the pepperoni was a bit underwhelming as we thought it would be better but still good regardless. the price point is also pretty high too for these slices but the plain is a reasonable price as it’s $4 and the same price as most nowadays. the space is also pretty small and cramped so def go on a day where it isn’t extremely cold out so you can take your slice outside!“

“Loved this place! So good, very authentic“