16 Best Pizza Restaurants in Flemington

“Really good food and service. We really miss going but moved to Pennsylvania. However this spring we will be in more frequently.“

“Vito and his staff are amazing and the food is always above and beyond have never had a meal or pizza I haven’t liked. Food is always fresh and hot when I pick up. Thank you for all you do!“

“All .. salad pizza is my favorite“

“A great local spot with excellent food. The staff is friendly and makes you feel welcomed. Stop by if you can, you won't regret it.“

“Despite all of the pizza places in Flemington, I have always driven to Milford to get my favorite pizza because I’m super picky and nothing quite hit the spot. However, l just tried this place for the first time because my in-laws picked up a pie…. Didn’t even realize that it had changed from the previous pizza place. I am blown away!! I am so happy to finally be able to stay local to get my Friday night pizza after living here for 7 years! Yummmmm… 9.5 out of 10! If the cheese were a little more melted it would be 10/10 and that might just be because I picked it up a few minutes late….but the sauce is PHENOMENAL and so is the crust! Best pizza in Flemington by far! Great job 👏“

“Excellent food and better people. Food is very tasty, fresh, and great 'inventions'. Love Angelo, Lorenzo, and Emilio. They treat you like family. You will find homemade scones made by Angelo which are very good. No one makes a better white pizza than Angelo. All the pizza is very good, the bacon chicken ranch one of my favorites. And the dinners, Jim loves the seafood, are always very delicious. No better server than Lorenzo. He knows you and will recommend for what you might like. Love the hugs. Couldn't ask for a better gem in Flemington. It is my happy place, which is what is saved on my phone.“

“Absolutely wonderful! I ordered Mamma’s Tomato Sauce with pasta and it hit the spot! Tasty and amazing!! Couldn’t recommend more and I will definitely order again or stop in next time!“

“Love their food one problem they always deliver to my house on a Sunday I called up ordering for delivery the guy told me that they don’t deliver to my area Told him your boss told me you do he asked his boss he then said oh well we’re backed up so why don’t you order from the Hillsboro one the Hillsboro one is further away from me then Flemington location I will give them another shot because I like their food but I’m making it clear I’m unhappy with their staff and the way I was treated when all I wanted was a pizza Sunday night“

“The food is tremendous and the staff is awesome“

“Got 6 pizzas from gabbys for a bounce city birthday party. My son has a severe egg allergy and they promised to mark a pie and take extra care with it. He was able to eat it without any issue and we all enjoyed the pizza a lot. Thank you Gabby’s!“

“Love this place Friendly staff excellent food and service,great atmosphere and fair price“

“This spot has become one of our regular go-to places, especially after late drives back from NYC. The late-night hours have honestly been a lifesaver more than once. The pizza is always consistently good, fresh, and exactly what you want from a reliable local pizzeria. We also order the chicken wings all the time — easily some of our favorites in the area.

The staff is always friendly, polite, and welcoming, and the service is consistently quick even when they’re busy. You can tell they genuinely care about customers and keeping things running smoothly.

For a chain-style pizzeria, the quality is surprisingly consistent and dependable. It’s one of those places where you know exactly what you’re going to get every time, and that reliability matters. The only small thing is the signage can be a little hard to notice at night because the light is dim, so it’s easy to drive past the first time — but once you find it, you’ll probably keep coming back like we do.“

“Always great food and excellent service highly recommended! Never a bad meal love the sweet and sour calamari !!!“

“excellent and quick service, Delicious food and a great atmosphere !! The owner is very nice and attentive to every customer making sure they are having a good time while eating the delicious food.“

“Angelo’s never disappoints food fresh & yummy.“

“Went there with the family (10 people), the food was good, service was correct (the waitress was nice and got pretty much everything right), could have checked up on us more often (probably short-staffed). Nothing special about the atmosphere.
I would go back there.“