The Nottingham Tavern
9 Mercer St, Hamilton Square
(609) 587-6000
Customers' Favorites
Buffalo Chicken Tenders
Cheesesteak Eggrolls
Chicken Cheesesteak
Bavarian Pretzel
Grilled Chicken
Italian Hot Dog
Seasoned Fries
Fish and Chips
Chicken Wings
Buffalo Wings
STARTERS (Deep Copy)
MAC & CHEESE
FRENCH FRIES
ZUCCHINI STICKS
BAVARIAN PRETZEL
NACHOS
BROCCOLI BITES
DISCO FRIES
FRIES W/GRAVY & CHEESE
BUFFALO CAULIFLOWER
CHEESESTEAK EGGROLLS
CHICKEN FINGERS & FRIES
LOADED TOTS
MOZZARELLA STICKS
ONION RINGS
PICKLE CHIPS
SEASONED FRIES
SWEET POTATO FRIES
SALADS (Deep Copy)
ARUGULA
ANTIPASTO
CAESAR
WINGS (Deep Copy)
6 WINGS
12 WINGS
36 WINGS
24 WINGS
FISH N CHIPS (Deep Copy)
FISH AND CHIPS
SOUP (Deep Copy)
SOUP OF THE DAY
PIZZA (Deep Copy)
MEAT LOVERS
BROOKLYN
RICOTTA PIE
CHICKEN BACON RANCH
BAR PIE
TOMATO PIE
GLUTEN FREE
PROSCIUTTO ARUGULA FIG
MARGHERITA
MUSTARD PIE
DRUNKEN BROOKLYN
BUFFALO CHICKEN
NUTELLA
SANDWICHES (Deep Copy)
CHICKEN CUTLET
CHEESESTEAK
THE NOTT BURGER
CLASSIC BURGER
PLAIN STEAK
MEATBALL/CHICKEN/EGGPLANT PARM
CAPRESE
CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK
HOAGIES
ITALIAN HOT DOG
ROAST PORK
SAUSAGE PEPPERS ONIONS
PANINI (Deep Copy)
BUFFALO CHICKEN
GRILLED CHICKEN
ITALIAN CUBAN
PORK BELLY
GRILLED CHEESE
STARTERS
CHEESESTEAK EGGROLLS
BAVARIAN PRETZEL
DO NOT MAKE
DISCO FRIES
FRIES W/GRAVY & CHEESE
NACHOS
CHICKEN FINGERS & FRIES
ZUCCHINI STICKS
FRENCH FRIES
LOADED TOTS
MOZZARELLA STICKS
ONION RINGS
PICKLE CHIPS
SEASONED FRIES
BUFFALO CAULIFLOWER
CHARCUTERIE BOARD
NOTT SAMPLER
SPECIALS
STRACHETELLI
PIEROGIES
FISH SAND
STUFFED PEPPERS
CHX CUTLET VODKA
SOUP SAMPLER
LASAGNA
FISH N CHIPS
FISH AND CHIPS
PANINI
GRILLED CHICKEN
GRILLED CHEESE
ITALIAN CUBAN
SOUTHWEST CHICKEN
BLT
PIZZA
MEAT LOVERS
DRUNKEN BROOKLYN
BROOKLYN
BAR PIE
BUFFALO CHICKEN
CHICKEN BACON RANCH
GLUTEN FREE
MARGHERITA
MUSTARD PIE
NUTELLA
PROSCIUTTO ARUGULA FIG
RICOTTA PIE
VEGGIE PIE
CLAM PIE
SALADS
ANTIPASTO
SIDE SALAD
ARUGULA
CAESAR
COBB
SANDWICHES
CHICKEN CUTLET
PLAIN STEAK
CAPRESE
CHEESESTEAK
CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK
CLASSIC BURGER
ITALIAN HOT DOG
MEATBALL/CHICKEN/EGGPLANT PARM
ROAST PORK
SAUSAGE PEPPERS ONIONS
THE NOTT BURGER
BUFF CHX CH STEAK
BUFFALO CHX SANDWICH
SOUPS
TOMATO SOUP
LOADED BAKED POTATO
FRENCH ONION
WINGS
6 WINGS
12 WINGS
36 WINGS
24 WINGS
BOTTLED RED WINE
BOTTLED FEDERALIST CAB
BOTTLED JACOBS
BOTTLED LAYER CAKE PINOT NOIR
BOTTLE SARTORI PN
BOTTLE ROSE
BOTTLED WHITE WINE
PROCESCO (3 PK)
BOTTLED FETZ CHARDONNAY
BOTTLED KJ SAUV BLANC
BTL STONELEIGH SAUV BLANC
CANNED BEER
4 PACK GUINESS
8 PACK GUINESS
4 PACK HIGH NOON
6 PACK IPA GOOSE ISLAND
8 PACK NUTRL
6 PACK PBR
4 PACK STELLA
6 PACK AMSTEL LITE
Strongbow Cider 4pack
Photos
+38 photos
+37 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
my friend and i were at the patio bar last night and had a wonderful time! the food (we had pizzas) was delicious! the bartender amy was especially great. we LOVED josh zuckerman playing and would definitely recommend having him back!!! he was awesome
April 2026
Was here Saturday night with friends for dinner before the band. I want to say our waiter Logan was awesome. Very friendly professional and took very good care of us at dinner and after when we moved to the main bar for the band. Band 80s Undercover sounded great as always!!! Food was delicious also!!!! Will definately be back!
April 2026
The Nottingham Tavern hosted the reception for my husband’s funeral at the beginning of March, and I truly cannot thank them enough. Sam and Lucy were incredible to work with—compassionate, attentive, and thoughtful during such a difficult time.
Everything was perfect, from the warm and welcoming atmosphere to the delicious food and outstanding service. They made sure every detail was handled with care, which meant so much to our family.
I would highly recommend...
Everything was perfect, from the warm and welcoming atmosphere to the delicious food and outstanding service. They made sure every detail was handled with care, which meant so much to our family.
I would highly recommend...
March 2026
You May Also Like
Donuts Time Cafe - 1280 NJ-33
![]()
Donuts, Coffee & Tea
Gaetano's Cheesesteaks - 1280 NJ-33
![]()
American, Cheesesteaks, Chicken Wings, Fast Food