Custom Cakes near Hillsdale, NJ

Sprinklez Ice Cream Shop • $
130 Broadway, Hillsdale

“I absolutely loved my birthday cake from Sprinklez! They decorated the cake exactly as I described, and it tasted amazing! So many of my friends talked about how it was the best ice cream cake they ever had. I highly recommend Sprinklez for any of your ice cream needs!“

4.5 Superb99 Reviews
Chic Sugars Bakery • $$
28 S Dean St, Englewood

“We LOVE Chic Sugars! It's fully kosher with a great hashgacha and the sweets are the best you'll find in the tristate! Our family's birthday and holiday cakes ALL come from here. They are next-level beautiful and delicious -- a whole different kettle of buttercream that's superior to any other bakery around. Note for Uber Eats users: Chic Sugars is available there but is not listed under kosher eateries. Just search the name and it will pop up.“

4.8 Superb149 Reviews
Zadies Kosher Bake Shop Bakery • $
19-09 Fair Lawn Ave, Fair Lawn

Customers` Favorites

Black and White Cookie
Lemon Merengue Pie
Everything Challah
Rainbow Cookie
Torah Cake
Rugalach
Doughnut
Bakery

“Staff is always very friendly and helpful, you never feel overwhelmed or rushed. There is SOO much to try here and at the very reasonable prices, you can.The challah bread is a family favorite, as well as the rugelach. Everything is high quality and consistently good.“

4.8 Superb91 Reviews
Walter's Cake Art Custom Cakes • $
3 Veterans Pkwy, Pearl River

“Walter made a truly awesome cake for a 60th birthday party that I organized. It was not only artistic and colorful, but it tasted great! When I ordered the cake, he was very attentive to my preferences and gave good suggestions. Also, I let me decide how the cake should be decorated, and, as you can see by the picture, his choices were awesome! I would highly recommend him.“

5 Superb30 Reviews
Petal Dust Cakery Bakery • $
11 Rodney St, Glen Rock

“I can't be more impressed with the owner herself ie Christina and her beautiful creation of a yacht cake that she made for me at the very last moment. The cake was perfect and it was melting in the mouth and really yum. I will surely return for any future orders.“

4.8 Superb52 Reviews
McCrum's Bakery Bakery • $
378 Market St, Elmwood Park

“Happy Holidays and THANK YOU!! No time to bake this year. I stopped buy and bought a pound cake and cookies..WOW!! taste and quality is no different then home baked.. No need to bake ever again! I can't stop eating them.. rugelach and pecan balls are addictive!“

4.8 Superb44 Reviews
Bradley Bake Shop Gluten-free Bakery • $$
55B River Rd, Bogota

“Super cute place; the owner is so sweet. Bought some sugar-free/keto cupcakes for my dad's birthday (he's a diabetic) and omg they were so delicious! Definitely worth the visit!Dietary restrictions: Everything is gluten-free and they have a beautiful section of Keto baked goods & cakes.“

4.8 Superb38 Reviews
Dulce De Leche Bakery Bakery • $
55 W Palisade Ave, Englewood

Customers` Favorites

Ham and Cheese Croissant
Egg and Cheese on Brioche
Table Harvest Salad
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Breakfast Sandwich
Spanish Tortilla
Spinach Quiche
Chocolate Cake
Avocado Toast
Tres Leches

“Legendary Dulce de leche has a branch in englewood.. it’s a nice bakery with v v positive vibes and very popular for their sweet and savory treats .. the cakes are very different and very flavorful.. I love the coffee, tiramisu and the chocolate cake and love the spinach quiche.. it’s a must visit. They have the best breakfast menu and freshly squeezed orange juiceDietary restrictions: Very vegetarian ?? ? friendly“

4.6 Superb119 Reviews
The Modern Cakery Custom Cakes • $$
385 Kinderkamack Rd, Oradell

“We were just gifted the Holiday box set and oh man...SO SCRUMPTIOUS! I wanted to eat it all but you know, sharing is caring.lol. I'm a sucker for a good chocolate cookie and theirs is sooo good. You know everything else will be good if the "simple"chocolate chip cookie is something I can have 10 of with no regret. I also had the rice krispie treat and macaroon. Both devoured in a second. It's not overly sweet and love that it has the great home made taste and feel to it. My friend LOVED the s'mores blondie. Highly recommend your next gift to someone or for yourself The Modern Cakery!“

4.8 Superb33 Reviews
La Promenade Bakery • $$
137 Piermont Rd, Tenafly

Customers` Favorites

Traditional Chocolate Mousse Ganache Cake 7
Hamburger Cake Or
Rainbow Cookie 6
Large Cookies
Chocolate Pie
Wedding Cake
Various Pies
Custom Cake
Carrot Cake
Muffins

“They had run out of the Cronuts we were looking for, so we opted for the chocolate alternative, which was pretty darn good. We also ended up going with a few other varieties of ? sweets. I must say I missed this place. It's been years, and I was passing through NJ, so it was a must to stop by here. These donuts/Cronuts are so addicting. The prices are a little high, but for the area and the quality, you can't go wrong. If I ever pass through NJ again, I'll make sure to go earlier for the original Cronuts.“

4.6 Superb92 Reviews
The Official Cake Lady Bakery •
191 S Main St, New City

“The official cake lady is officially our go to bakery!! Kim did our sons cake for his superhero party this weekend and WOW so cool and creative even included lights (iron man themed) !!! The cake was delicious too!!! She’s done a couple of cakes for us already and everyone raves about it!! She was so easy to work with and so kind!! She even texted me links from Amazon for a cake topper. It was a pleasure Kim to work with you and your staff!! Thank you!! People are still talking about your cake!! ;) Oriana from Liam’s superhero party!“

4.7 Superb45 Reviews
BoBo Z Bakery Bakery • $
9 Miller Rd, Mahwah

“The best croissant I ever had! All the crossants I had before were taste pretty much the same, but BoBo's has this very rich flavor inside, sooooooo good! And the owner she is so nice, she will tell you which are good to try, which are not, haha. I'm still waiting for the mango mousse for she said right now is not the mango season, has to wait for the fresh mangos come, lol.“

4.8 Superb29 Reviews
Rispoli’s Pastry Shop (Hawthorne) Bakery •
1103 Goffle Rd, Hawthorne

Customers` Favorites

American Cheesecake 7
Strawberry Shortcake
Italian Cheesecake
Anisette Biscotti
Assorted Cookies
Chocolate Mousse
Macaroons 1 4 lb
Chocolate Chip
Birthday Cake
Lobster Tails

“I stopped in shortly before closing and picked out the Chantilly cake from the case. It was one of the best cakes I've had in years! Their icing is not sickly sweet like some other bakeries in the area, and the filling was amazing! I also brought home some crumb cake, which was delicious. The cake part was very moist. So many places over-emphasize the crumb and have a dry bland cake, but Rispolli's has great crumb AND delicious cake. The next day it was still moist and tasted just as fresh as the day before. I'll definitely be back!“

4.6 Superb64 Reviews
Bella Vida Pastry Cafe Bakery
1197 Main Ave, Clifton

Customers` Favorites

Cookies and Dessert
Vanilla Flan Slice
Birthday Cake

“Ordered a gorgeous 2 tiered cake for my daughters 3rd birthday (Under the THREE themed) and Bella vida did not disappoint! Not only was the cake aesthetically appealing, but it was delicious! Very light and moist, the cannoli filling was to die for, and the dulce de leche filling was fantastic! Extremely flavorful and the details were intricate and you can tell there is a real passion for baking! EVERYONE was raving about the cake and asking where I got it from. Simply delicious!! We will absolutely be ordering our cakes from here from now on, I won't go anywhere else!!“

4.7 Superb34 Reviews
Karla Jiménez Cakes & More Custom Cakes •
78 W Main St, Bogota

“My friend at work referred me to Karla’s Bakery, I was looking for a place to order a customized cake for my daughters birthday, I ended up referring my sister to her and we are not disappointed, Karla made a wonderful, tasty customized cake in town, I will definitely will spread the word to everyone I know that this bakery is one of the best and the owner is super nice and detailed on all customers requests. Keep up a great work I will definitely order all my cakes to you.“

4.6 Superb45 Reviews
Pierre & Michel Authentic French Bakery Bakery • $$
38 E Ridgewood Ave, Ridgewood

Customers` Favorites

Lemon Tart Pain Suisse Mocha Latte
Ham and Cheese Croissant Sandwich
Apricot Croissant
Chocolate Eclair
Apple Croissant
Strawberry Tart
Creme Brulee
Croissants
Baguette
Pastries

“Lovely Bakery Cafe with a classic, relaxed ambience and old world charm. Came late afternoon on Presidents Day and there were lots of customers but also plentiful seats available. The croissant lived up to its reputation! It was large, crumbly and flaky on the outside and very affordably priced. Cashier was very friendly too! She offered to heat up our croissant and brought it out to us on a plate. This place is definitely worth a visit!“

4.5 Superb104 Reviews
Gigis Baked Goods Bakery • $
290 Lakeview Ave, Clifton

Customers` Favorites

Passion Fruit Tart
Alfajores Mini
Alfajor Cake

“Awesome place if you’re looking for cute bake goods for a thank you or a partner or business! Super fresh and look how cute the cover are for the bake goods! Worked perfectly for me since it was for a partner of mine. They have many other selections and fresh made mini and big empanadas. The place smells amazing too!“

4.6 Superb26 Reviews
Loading...
map Map