31 Best Sandwich Shops near Holmdel

1 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.0 Good 141 Reviews

2145 NJ-35, Holmdel

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“How can one not love this place. The smell of the bacon, the toppings being displayed infront of my eyes. If my eyes could drool, they would from how delictable everything looks. I thank the staff for the amazing job they do, even though its one slice of meat and im paying $20, I am still satisfied to be a regular customer and come back everyday during my lunch.”

2 Big City Sandwiches

4.9 Superb 120 Reviews

115 NJ-35, Eatontown · 7.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Popped in on a whim and met staff for the first time. Welcoming, friendly, and immaculate store. The assortment of sandwiches on the menu will please all. Ordered Sloppy Russian, Antico, & Italian… delicious. Big City Sandwiches for sure. Fresh breads. So happy to have such a great deli in town. Will certainly be back soon to try another.”

3 Quik Food Deli

5.0 Superb 79 Reviews

745 Poole Avenue, Hazlet · 6.2 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Simply the best subs, sandwiches and more. Everybody here is awesome. Wish I could give more than 5 Stars!”

4 Big Wally's Subs

4.8 Superb 107 Reviews

3322 Washington Rd, Parlin · 10.67 miles

• Take-Out

“Absolutely amazing and delicious better than any Jersey mikes or subway”

5 Mike's Giant Size Submarine Sandwiches

4.8 Superb 82 Reviews

103 W Front St, Keyport · 6.41 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“When you are 1000 of miles away and you still can taste the sandwich, it is good. When you return to visit, you make sure you have cash, and this is the first stop always. And maybe another before you leave.”

6 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.5 Superb 98 Reviews

311 NJ-35, Cliffwood · 6.8 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I stopped into the Cliffwood location yesterday, and it had been years since I’d been to Jersey Mike’s. The three guys working were all incredibly friendly, helpful, and had such great personalities. My friend and I actually left talking about how positive the whole experience was. The sandwiches were delicious, and the customer service really stood out. It’s refreshing to receive service like that these days. We’ll definitely be back!”

7 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.5 Superb 96 Reviews

728 Newman Springs Road, Lincroft · 3.34 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This Jersey Mike’s is legendary, and I say this with clear eyes and a full heart (can’t lose). Every other Monmouth County location is simply a warm-up act. My delivery arrived in optimal condition with iconic pickle and mustard levels - so precisely calibrated it should be studied in a lab. The delivery vibes were immaculate, snack packing execution unmatched, and overall the subs totally slayed. Will patronize again. In fact, I have already mentally patronized this location twice since finishing this review. Lincroft J.Mikes for the win!”

8 Johnny's Pork Roll and Coffee Too

4.5 Superb 92 Reviews

8A Monmouth St, Red Bank · 6.24 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“A passionate owner is the first step to a successful business and you have that here. Great pork roll and coffee is a plus. Highly recommend this place.”

9 Elsie's Sub Shop

4.6 Superb 65 Reviews

74 Monmouth St, Red Bank · 6.08 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I swing by for a couple subs when in the neighborhood. The past two cold subs didn't match my order. My hot sub reminded me that I should only eat eggplant in season. I miss the old Elsie's.”

10 D.A. Subs

4.6 Superb 56 Reviews

1070 NJ-34 A, Matawan · 4.44 miles

• Take-Out

“Great local sub shop where you get a nice hearty sandwich for the money (CASH ONLY). Their portions put's the likes of Jersey Mike's to shame. Staff doesn't seem happy and not the friendliest, but hey, you can't have it all.”

11 Stubby's Deli

4.5 Superb 61 Reviews

1135 Florence Avenue, Union Beach · 7.02 miles

• Delivery

“Getting a quick bite to eat for Breakfast.The usual sandwich of toasted hard roll, 2 fried eggs, jalapeno peppers with salt - pepper - ketchup.Spotted this bottle of hot sauce on Stubby's Condiment Shelf and since I like Hot Sauce gave it a try.It added a nice taste to the sandwich.”

12 Panini Bistro

4.5 Superb 60 Reviews

345 Union Hill Rd, Manalapan · 7.17 miles

• Delivery

“Got food from there for the first time yesterday, absolutely delicious!!”

13 Di Santillo's Artisan Sandwiches & Eatery

4.4 Superb 72 Reviews

455 CR-520, Marlboro · 3.43 miles

• Delivery

“Picked up a make your own salad today. I'm not even finished and I had to review. Absolutely the BEST salad!! All fresh ingredients, a lot of chicken and it's a BiG Salad. Work local and order lunch a lot. Be fat the best lunch I've had this year!!”

14 Panini Bistro

4.2 Good 157 Reviews

745 NJ-34, Matawan · 5.99 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Got food from there for the first time yesterday, absolutely delicious!!”

15 Brennan's Middletown

4.2 Good 115 Reviews

212 NJ-35, Red Bank · 5.51 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Sandwiches are delicious! Closest thing around here to a NYC deli. Staff is pleasant & courteous.”

16 Sorrento's Subs

4.2 Good 88 Reviews

690 Park Ave, Freehold · 7.87 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love this place! Excellent customer service and subs. Delicious. Ya can get subs, sandwiches on bread, quesadillas, or wraps. And made the way ya like them. 🍽🥪♥️ Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, it's wheel chair accessible.”

17 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.3 Superb 41 Reviews

1175 NJ-33, Farmingdale · 8.29 miles

• Delivery

“Justin and Mason work together very well. I mentioned that my wife has a tomato allergy. They quickly changed their gloves and cleaned the area taking great care of making sure not to get any tomato near our sandwiches. They were working hard and it felt like they have pride in their work. Keep up the great work and see you again soon.”

18 Welsh Farm Deli

4.1 Good 63 Reviews

613 Hope Road, Eatontown · 6.99 miles

• Delivery

“Great food for good price!! Has lots of groceries too. Definitely recommend to go this place!!”

19 Colleen's Kitchen & Catering

4.5 Superb 14 Reviews

115 S Broadway, South Amboy · 10.76 miles

“Not only is the food good, but the free psychological counseling Carol provides is absolutely priceless! I love this place.”

20 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.0 Good 113 Reviews

7 Bayshore Plaza, Atlantic Highlands · 8.74 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love, love that you all make GLUTEN-FREE bread now for your subs!! We have a gluten sensitivity in our family so we now can enjoy your fantastic subs. They are delicious. We will be back and will tell all of our gluten sensitive friends. ;)”

21 Jersey Mike's Subs

3.9 Good 143 Reviews

3528 US-9, Freehold · 8.92 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“These subs cost more than going to wawa but they are delicious... and worth it to treat yourself once in a while. They are much much better than subway. The bread is fresh as are the premium Boars Head coldcuts. There are 3 diff types of bread i think to choose from too! Even the tuna is fresh. There are a variety of toppings to choose from directly with the workers who are very friendly and fast.”

22 Jersey Mike's Subs

3.8 Good 99 Reviews

100 Water Street, Red Bank · 6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The Italian sub is my favorite”

23 Jersey Mike's Subs

3.8 Good 124 Reviews

450 Union Hill Road, Morganville · 6.4 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We have been coming to this Jersey Mike's for quite a while now and just about every time we go, the food is good, and the staff are willing and able. My family and I were havin a rough day more recently with car trouble and we needed some quick dinner food. We knew where this place was and always enjoyed it, but it was only 30 minutes before closing. Instead of getting staff that were disgruntled that they were glad to serve us. I think it was justin, jack and ziggy, if I rememeber thier name tags. The cashier even asked my mom how her day was and was she admitted it wasn't the best. All together the food was great and the staff was eagerly getting us our needs. Thank you all so much for your service.”

24 Jersey Mike's Subs

3.8 Good 132 Reviews

2100 NJ-35, Ocean · 9.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“You can't argue with an empty box of subs! Jersey Mikes makes everyone happy!”

25 Subway

3.7 Good 46 Reviews

326 West Main Street, Freehold · 9.08 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“please if anyone knows a person named richy/richard give him a raise because he is a well experienced worker and i’ve never met a person like him!! GIVE RICHY A RAISE BC HES THE BEST PERSON EVER LIKE no person has ever gave me the best sub ever like literally give him a raise (or else im coming to rob yo momma and kids)”

26 Jersey Mike's Subs

3.7 Good 95 Reviews

10 Shrewsbury Plaza, Shrewsbury · 6.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great customer service, great food. This is our go-to Jersey Mike’s location!”

27 Jersey Mike's Subs

3.7 Good 104 Reviews

251 Main Street, Matawan · 5.14 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We order subs form here at least twice a month. Subs are always pretty good BUT today I ordered a meatball sub.. All I can say is it was the nastiest meatball sub I ever ate! I’m sure the meatball sub from WaWa is much better. The sub contained a crap load of sauce and mushed meat not even meatballs. The meat tasted like the cheap meat from a can. Every time I think of it I want to vomit 🤮!!!! I normally place online orders but today I went in. They don’t even put paper down while making your sandwich they place the bread on the counter and slide it from one side to the other. I didn’t complain since it looked clean BUT I will Not be ordering from there again. What a waste of $15. I tried giving the rest to my dog but he didn’t even eat it. He put it in his mouth then spit it back out. If a dog won’t eat what does that tell you???! I would really like a refund but reality I know I ain’t going to get one. So I will WARN all those who like meatball subs DO NOT go to Jersey Mikes in Matawan. They truly suck. I can’t get the nasty meat flavor out of my mouth. Smh I hope the cheese steak I picked up for my husband is good......”

28 Jersey Mike's Subs

3.3 Good 33 Reviews

2305 NJ-66, Neptune City · 10.84 miles

• Delivery

“I ran in tonight after not eating all day. It was busy being an hour before closing but the guys behind the counter were all doing an amazing job. My sandwich was delicious and I really appreciate their great customer service and patience despite being so busy!!! Quick, professional, and delicious. Thanks guys!!!”

29 South Amboy Deli & Subs

3.0 Average 25 Reviews

101 N Stevens Ave, South Amboy · 10.8 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Honestly, the lady behind the counter is not the nicest, but they have the best turkey sandwiches and i love their brownies! I have tried a lot of sandwiches but there sandwiches hit different ? One day i need to try more stuff off their menu!”

30 Subway

3.6 Good 214 Reviews

2825 NJ-18, Old Bridge · 7.36 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Tucked in a corner of Walmart, the space is adequate for a good 20 min meal. Friendly staff. Usually has veggie patties and vegetarian options. Every time I visit this store, I feel sure about the options I can get. Vegetarian options: Veggie patties and other vegetables in the mix”

31 Subway

3.8 Good 131 Reviews

3042 NJ-35, Hazlet · 5.05 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is my second time coming to this location I traveled all the way from Neptune Nj area and I must say this is the best Subway I’ve ever went to .. Jas was very sweet and gave me a discount for traveling so far, it really meant a lot and I truly appreciate his kindness.. Mandee and Jas are such beautiful souls, they greeted me with a warm embrace and they both had awesome communication.. the food is always fresh and made with love. They are very generous when making your subs.. Thank you soo much for caring about your customers you’re truly phenomenal..”