Elisa's Italian Pastry Shop & Bakery
$ • BakeryAbout Elisa's Italian Pastry Shop & Bakery
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Cupcake w Purple Icing
Espresso Assorted Cakes to Try
Assorted Italian Pastries
Zeppole Di San Giuseppe
Wedding Cake Topper
Raspberry Turnovers
Birthday Cake
Cannoli Cake
Lobster Tail
Cheese Cake
Recent Reviews
259 ratings
Share your opinion about Elisa's Italian Pastry Shop & Bakery
When I ordered a full sheet birthday cake (in person) the salesclerk was patient, professional and attentive to the details I requested. Great customer service!
At pickup in Jan 2025, the large heavy cake was carried out to the car for me. It was beautifully decorated and exactly as expected. Again, great customer service!
Best of all, at the party, many of our guests raved about the delicious cake. A fresh and moist chocolate cake filled with chocolate custard...read full review
At pickup in Jan 2025, the large heavy cake was carried out to the car for me. It was beautifully decorated and exactly as expected. Again, great customer service!
Best of all, at the party, many of our guests raved about the delicious cake. A fresh and moist chocolate cake filled with chocolate custard...read full review
Everything she sells is the VERY Best Quality. We are from the Jersey Shore currently living in Williamsburg, Virginia. We always bring plenty of goodies home with us. Very Friendly Staff.
The birthday cake I ordered for my daughter’s birthday was absolutely beautiful. All I did was send a picture of a mermaid, and they did the rest. The cake was decorated with such detail and was delicious as well. When we opened the box, I was not expecting multiple layers and such bright and beautiful colors. You can tell they take pride in each cake that is made!!! I have ordered multiple cakes and cupcakes throughout the years, and Elisas bakery does not disappoint!
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 7PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 6PM |
Elisa's Italian Pastry Shop & Bakery is one of the very few authentic bakeries in Monmouth County and Ocean County, well stocked with daily fresh baked Italian pastries, cookies and cakes. The bakery is well laid out with delicious smells. The birthday cake was delicious, beautifully decorated, moist, with a light and tasty chocolate mousse filling. It is the best bakery in S. Jersey with the biggest selection and best quality. The prosciutto bread is absolutely the best. Cookies for every holiday and family birthday cakes are exceptional. The owners are from Brooklyn. A bit pricey, but worth it.