50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lawrenceville

“Three families went here for dinner celebrate my son’s birthday. The food was so good, but honestly it was the staff that overshined everything! They were so friendly, so accommodating, and so kind to all of our kids. The owner was so accommodating and so warm to all of us. I can’t speak highly enough about how great the staff was. We don’t live nearby but when we are here we will for sure go there for dinner.“

“We were a party of 11 for the Easter brunch at 10 a.m. (in 2024). We had a wonderful time. From the first greeting by the host/hostess, to the servers, and the buffet workers, to the good bye ~ everyone we dealt with was pleasant and professional.The food selection was varied, delicious, plentiful, and temperature appropriate. Matt, our server, kept on top of monitoring our drinks; mimosas, coffee, soda etc., empty plates were taken away and not thank you for making our Easter brunch a wonderful family gathering left on our table for very long.We could not have been more pleased to come to Amalfi's, our first visit, but definitely not our last.The ONLY negative was it was a bit chilly in the room.I'm sure for the next seating it was a little warmer.Highly recommend Amalfi's. We thank them all fees for making our family gathering a wonderful memory.“

“Let’s talk about great sandwiches and subs. Quality meat, cheese, solid bread, and my guy behind the counter is a multitasking wizard. He’s got the earpiece in making 5 sandwiches at least at the same time. Boars head meats and cheeses, and a lot of it.I always say you can tell how good the place is by their Italian hoagie, and it’s solid. They’ll toast the bread, or whole sandwich if you like.It can get a little backed up at lunchtime when all the construction folks and nurses come in but no more than 20-25 mins calling ahead.Solid coffee too!“

“Jerry’s pizza has the best pizza I’ve ever tried and has one of the best customer service. The atmosphere in there is so nice, if I want to I can see how my pizza is made. It is just very amazing and I think that you should try it yourself.“

“I was visiting the area and decided to stop here based on the reviews that I read. It did not disappoint. The food was delicious, and the service was excellent. We ordered the calamari and a meatlover's pizza. There was also complimentary bread and dipping oil. The atmosphere was really nice; however, the tables are really close together. I“

“Thank you and your team for the incredible experience our birthday girl and guests experienced. From start to finish Devon and Alyssa were amazing. The appetizers and entrees were spectacular. We were so pleased with the exemplary service of all your staff. The event planner Christina listened to every detail I requested and the experience was flawless. I feel so fortunate to have had the opportunity to work with the entire staff.“

“Wonderful experience tonight at Jojo's! The white cosmo and extensive beer list were the perfect start to an evening after a very rough day. My wife had one of the best BLTs of her life and my vodka rigatoni was top notch, a bellwether for any good Italian restaurant. All recommended and served with a smile by our waitress Devon. She was super helpful, very friendly, and made sure our evening was enjoyable. A long, difficult day was made great and relaxing with good food and exceptional service. Can't wait to go back!“

“It’s always the little nook in the walls that have the best stuff. I seen this guy on TikTok an year ago and I live like an hour away and I said to myself if I’m ever in the area I’d stop by. Needless to say I got this job with public service so now I have the privilege to drive around to a lot of new areas and I got lucky to be near by. I was craving pizza I looked around, the highest rated place pulled up not expecting it to be Sally Slices places bc I had honestly after all this time forgot about him being in this part of Jersey. I pull up posters and pictures of this guy everywhere and I was so excited. I got the pepperoni one with and without hot honey ( his sister was in this day I didn’t get to meet Sally but she recommended the hot honey I said I’ll try one of them with it) and the first bite was awesome. the crunch on this thing was insane. I had to make a video and share it to my fiancé. I then went 3 more times that week while working in the area and it was consistently the same perfect crunch each time and I only got hot honey after that first time. The hot honey was this added sweetness that I didn’t know I needed on my pizza. I recommend it to a couple of co workers and showed them the video of the crunch and they thought I was lying when I said it’s the crispiest thing you’ll ever bite into. they live in the area and they stopped on their lunches and after work they said it was the best pizza they ever had, probably won’t be ordering from anywhere else they said.“

“THIS LORENZOS IN YARDY IS EXCELLENT!!!!! Service is great. Waiters are personable. Pizza is delicious. Nice family oriented vibe!!!( I realized I rated the wrong Lorenzos. The Lorenzos in JERSEY IS THE ONE THAT'S HORRIBLY RACIST.That's why we switched to Yardly.)“

“Staying on town for work and decided to check this place out for dinner . Place is kept spotless very clean and fresh. Had a Veal parmeson with angel hair pasta and a salad. Walked back to the hotel in the cold rain and food was still piping hot when I got there . I will definitely eat there more when I'm in town food was excellent. Prise was fair definitely get your money's worth.“

“We ordered catering to pick up for a collegiate softball team and family members. Jessica and her catering staff were extremely helpful and very responsive. My questions were answered generally within an hour. All of our needs were accommodated as well. When we served the meal, all 48 guests were extremely satisfied with the quality of each item and all left very happy (and full). I would absolutely use Piccolo Trattoria again for my catering needs and would recommend it to others.“

“Had the chicken birra tacos, they were good. My daughter had the pretzel and beer cheese and that was really good. But omg the star of the show was the warm kale salad. It was amazing !!!! I find kale salads hard to get through but having it warm made it sooooooo much better.“

“excellent dinners. fine dining brought to your door. Bring out the dinnerware, bottle of wine and impress the guest. pick up a Pizza and don't forget about the homemade bread. everything is made to order. Special request isn't a problem. Very reasonable for quality & quantity, you won't be disappointed“

“Hands down Trenton, New Jersey classic. I'd argue to say one of the best cheesteak hoagies around. Old school pizza shop. Plain, pepperoni and mushrooms...nothing more nothing less......great owner, been there since I was born......if around, must try.“

“We were a party of three, with two having significant food allergies. The staff was highly tuned to our dietary needs. Portion sizes were amazing, much more than we anticipated. The food was excellent and the staff attentive, and very helpful in making GF recommendations. We had two staff members come over to ensure our dietary needs were accommodated.What a tremendous restaurant.Dietary restrictions: There is a GF menu with numerous options and the chef can ensure other menu options are GF.“

“We drive down to get their honey mustard chicken pizza all the way from Philly. Their pizzas are delicious and GIGANTIC. Especially their specialty pizzas. We made that mistake and got an entire pizza on Christmas Eve and could not finish it…had left over for days! They are insanely large and loaded with all kinds of delicious ingredients! Their prices are also pretty standard but definitely much cheaper than city prices. Customer for life!!!“

“The food was DELICIOUS, fresh, and reasonably priced. Service was so thoughtful, a tad slow, but for fresh, delicious food, it was no big deal. We were in no rush, and we had an amazing lunch. Very unassuming strip mall location, but lovely inside and we had a fantastic lunch. Highly recommend. You will not be disappointed. I think there is a small service fee for credit cards. I wish we would have gotten dessert. I only got a picture of the salad and after I inhaled my meal. My kids got the chicken souvlaki dinner and I got the shrimp skewers dinner. Also got the mozzarella sticks. I wish I lived closer and could go back and try the rest of the menu!!“

“I read about this place after booking a room at a nearby hotel. Wife and I went for early dinner and got a large pie. It was as amazing as the reviews. I ate 5 slices wife ate almost 3. The combo of crust, sauce, and cheese was just about perfect.“

“A 30 year, small family owned business, that's a mixture of pizzeria and Italian restaurant with indoor and outdoor seating. Tonight, I stopped in for the first time and was cheerfully welcomed and felt right at home. The menu had a wonderful assortment of great looking entries. But I decided to try one of the specials, the very flavorful and savory Chicken with portobello mushrooms sun-dried, tomatoes, spinach, and mozzarella in a white wine sauce over penne ($23.95). Service was great with friendly and attentive staff. If you're in the Hillsboro, Princeton area, this is a must try. Dine in or takeout, I think you'll be impressed too. Follow me on yelp or on Insta @noodlesoupr. As I travel the world and search up the perfect bowl of noodle soup.“

“We are so happy we came to Mamma Mia for my son’s birthday. The staff treated us like family and all sang happy birthday to him. It was a very special night because of them. The food was delicious, starting with the warm bread. We would recommend to anyone visiting the area!“

“I usually go to tomato pies every 2 months. The store is all the way from 1912! More than a century ago! Which makes me feel like i'm in a vintage store. Outside, there is a 2 doors in the front. There is a door for dine-in and another door for order to go or pick up. I personally haven't done dine-in but I always go for to go or pick up. Whenever I go, the staff is always so sweet and are always accurate for the time left. The only thing I dislikd is the time if takes to make the pizza. The pizza was delicious and stayed pretty warm when handed to me.“

“Located in a small strip mall you would never guess what a top notch restaurant this is from the outside. Owner is very involved and readily accessible, ambiance is outstanding, and service staff are attentive and professional. Food is out of this world and the menu offers everything you could want! I would highly recommend this hidden gem for some of the best Italian food in our area. I have been to some of the best Italian restaurants of this kind in Philadelphia and New York - Non Solo Pasta is definitely a contender!“

“This place has really stepped up their seating arrangements and the patio was warm, beautifully decorated and enclosed. My only issue was that it was hard to hear one another inside the enclosure with a lot of people talking. It might be helpful to have some sort of sound-reduction put in place in the future.“

“So happy they deliver to Marquand Park! It allows me to spend time at the park with my grandson and eat his favorite meal – pizza! He loves it! Love their sliders, cheese pizza, and their specialty sodas!Kid-friendliness: Pizza in the park“

“I’ve tried most of the highest reviewed pizza spots in Jersey (besides Deluca’s) and Dilorenzos is still at the top of my list. Their regular pie is phenomenal but if you like sausage & peppers on your pie, you’re in for a treat. Every so often, we’ll drive over an hour just to go here, well worth the trip!“

“Tried this location for the first time . Great food to dine in as well as for delivery. Highly recommend their jalapeño pizza , Panner tikka pizza and singas special garlic bread. Food was fresh and great customer service . They were more than happy to accommodate my request to customize my pizza . Definitely my favorite pizza joint in the area !“

“Service was very good. Staff very friendly. All Food courses were delicious and came out hot, fresh and was delicious! I had the Bianca ? chicken with cavatappi special. Amazingly tender chicken and the sauce was exquisite! Atmosphere was OK but bathroom was neglected and needs a lot of work cosmetically.“

“I usually don’t post reviews but this was necessary. I just left and I had a great experience there, the restaurant is clean, the staff is nice and the food is great. Also, times are hard for most people and the fact that I noticed they were also going through something (emotionally/sad) for unknown reasons and still gave great customer service is top tier. I will be going back and I pray that they find comfort in whatever they’re going through. They also make sure to take care of each other which is also heartwarming. Please go support if you can.“

“I was craving Italian pasta, so I did some research for good Italian that isn’t ridiculously expensive. This is what I landed with. I was very happy. Reasonable prices and likely the BEST rigatoni vodka pasta my husband and I have ever had. The sauce was perfect (not too salty or sweet and a perfect balance of cheese and tomato flavor). I added chicken, and it came with a lot. The soup and bread that it came with were fresh, warm, and delicious too. Definitely would come back!! The workers were also nice. Great place“

“Ordered a Brooklyn pie and a chicago pie with sausage. These two pizza's were excellent! The Brookyln is very tasty with a crispy thin crust and the Chicago is a stuffed pizza that can be stuffed with anything you like, how can you go wrong here. Delicious, reasonably priced and made with love. Much respect for the hustle and quality put forth in their pizza's.“

“I got a small personal pizza light on cheese & extra sauce it was ok I'll give it a 5 from 10 a little different from pizzerias pizza taist more like a frozen pizza the sause taste good only thing is the cheese didn't taste as good. Ill be back for more pizza from here if by slices but not a full pie. The workers mostly talk spanish there a lot of ordering so it could take little time just like any pizza place this is more of a corner store that haven to make pizza though. I didn't have any problems waiting peeps there were cool peeps just a mix store & pizza spot in one small store. It's new to me I'll be back see what els they make there.“

“The pizza was amazing, along with the staff. They were all so friendly when I came in for a pickup. They all greeted me, and I felt bad for leaving them after that, with now wanting to stay, eat, and hang out some. The food was killer like I said, and I'll come back for that, but it's great when you meet people that make you want to stay.“

“Been going to this Great pizza shop since i could walk. It WAS the BEST. The Family who owned it for 52 years was the BEST. Sal's daughters ran the place so smoothly, they will be missed. Not a huge fan of the changes this place has made to my hometown shop. I was there so much i felt that it was my second kitchen. Michelle and Josephine thank you for being such pros for so long, and making the town that much better and cooler with your presence. Pizza fridays wont be the same as these new guys already started taking the main ingredient out of the food, the LOVE. Equal parts LOVE sauce and cheese. God knows the wings were the greatest ever as were the ladies running the show.“

“Good brick oven pizza with nice ambiance and friendly serviceVegetarian options: Margherita, Vegan Margherita, Sassy Vegan, Nutella Pizza.Sassy Vegan pizza comes without cheese and it is very spicy, we can ask cheese to be added to it if we dont need it to be veganParking: This place is located inside Princeton Shopping Center with plenty of free parkingKid-friendliness: Kids love the Margherita pizza and Nutella Pizza hereWheelchair accessibility: Accessible parking is available. And there are no steps to reach restaurant floor from parking. It is accessible by wheel chair“

“I've been going to Sal's Original's Italian Pizzeria since 1981, for awhile I pretty much ate there everyday, sometimes twice a day. Sal and his brother were the best. Haven't been there since 2014. I need to drive down there this month. Lol“

“I stopped in for lunch with my son today to Vincent's for the first time. We were just going to get one slice each, but we saw this amazing looking half plain, half pepperoni pizza that had just come out of the oven, so we asked the chef/owner(maybe) if we could buy that particular pie. He very kindly obliged. The pizza was perfect! The thickness, chewiness, crustiness of the crust was perfection. The sauce and cheese ratio were perfect, and the sauce was very tasty and tasted homemade. The pepperoni was perfectly cooked. On top of the pizza being absolutely delicious, the man who made it and served it to us was as nice and friendly as could be. This was the perfect place for my son and me to get authentic NJ pizza which we are extremely particular about. We will be back very soon, and next time, we'll try a cheesesteak along with another pizza!“

“The very best in pizza, subs, the only place i trust to make me a good meatball without that nasty under taste you get from most restaurant meatballs.Family owned and operated, been coming here since I was a kid. I moved away some 10 years ago and somehow the brothers remember me when I stop by which is whenever i'm in town. I love th“

“I've been going to this restaurant for over 5 or 6 years. The atmosphere has definitely gotten better, but thier service in the restaurant isn't great. I visited last week 1/29/24. There were four of us with no one but another couple in the restaurant. We saw the waitress 2 times. Too busy talking and hanging with management . She looked like his daughter and she was not minding the table. Bar service is nuch better with John.“

“I’ve eaten at Amari’s twice and plan to go back at least monthly because the food is scrumptious and very reasonably priced. The service is excellent as well; welcoming, friendly, professional and efficient. I highly recommend the caprese salad (I ask for tomatoes to be removed and prosciutto to be added), chicken soup and the pasta dishes.“

“Planned my daughter’s baby shower from Florida with Sam and it turned out better than we could have imagined. Sam was so prompt with returning calls/emails and gave me suggestions to best accommodate the party from planning from afar. Being my family and a lot of friends are Italian, they are choosy with food and Villa Maria exceeded our expectations. The service staff couldn’t be any more attentive and courteous than they were. Being a lifetime Hamiltonian, Villa Maria was high on the list of venue choices when we began planning this event and having confidence that all would be as wanted , My daughter and son-in-law couldn’t have had a better venue than Villa Maria. Thank you again Sam for your professionalism and personal touch.Michele Rossi“

“If I could give 10/10 I would. I got fettuccine Alfredo with chicken , with a side of soup. Picked up this food and got a very clean vibe, delicious meal, really hit the spot. Me and my boyfriend want to come back, sit and eat and try more of what they have.“

“Very friendly and kind staff, i was a bit skeptical because the owner was guaranteeing that I'd like it and be back for more. It was pretty good, no real complaints, it was made fresh and it was the perfect crisp. Classic pizza joint, but they don't have ready to go slices on display.“

“My wife loves the gluten free pizzas. I'm not a fan of how they finish the regular ones. Too well done for my tastes, but they are pretty clear about that. Apparently many folks are big fans though, and other very good options to choose from.“

“The Best Pizza And All The Food Is A+ ?. The Place Is Always Busy. ICome From Hamilton 2 Ewing Just 2 Get Me A Cheese steak And A Couple Slices. Remind Me Of The Boadwalk Pizza @ Seaside.The Staff R ?. 1 Mo Thing, U Better Order B4 U GO There! OK I'm Out! ??“

“This pizza place is located in downtown Trenton. It's one of the few restaurants left there. They are pretty decent pizza and you can usually get a special of a soda and a slice. The service is really good and they will help you if you need assistance. The pizzeria is wheelchair-accessible they have a slight little bump in the front.Wheelchair accessibility: It is pretty flat and wheelchair accessible. The counters are a tad bit high“

“Absolutely superb Old Fashion (Trenton Style) Tomato Pie!! Crisp, full of flavor crust with zero "flop"! Chunks of tomatoes in a semi-sweet, yet bold sauce, went perfectly with the correct amount of cheese! Worth the 40-minute drive, Salerno's Pizza is definitely within my top five places to get a tomato pie!“

“We visited this BYO on a Saturday evening for dinner. There is a pizza shop connected to it, but we were in the dining room. I'll start with the entrees because they were the highlight. They were truly worth going back or getting it to take out. Large portions, super tasty and piping hot. The ceasar salads were fresh and tasty. I was told the "special" salad had a strong citus bite. The room itself is just a big box and lacks ambiance. It could use a decorator. Also, the service was ok, but a little clunky. I think was just inexperience. I didnt really appreciate them setting up for a huge party right next to us during our meal. The event was the next day and they could have waited. I will def be going back for the quality of the food...it was great. The rest, not so much“

“I ordered from here for the first time & the food was delicious… I ordered the chicken parmigiana.. it was enough food to feed my husband & myself… I had the food delivered & was told 45 mins.. the food was here before that.. the delivery guy was nice.. I will order from them again“

“We've ordered from here about four times. The food is plentiful, hot and delisioso!! Gave them a pass twice for timeliness of delivery, but well worth the wait. It's now our new 'go to' place after a neighborhood favorite retired and sold their spot and another fav spot moved. Smack your lips GREAT FOOD and standard with plenty of leftovers! Get you some...and some more!“

“This place is like a family kitchen they love you so much the food is so amazing you feel right at home I wish I could eat there everyday just to sit by their side and talk to them it's really a family pizza shop restaurant atmosphere love this “