32 Best Pizza Restaurants near Liberty

1 Louies Pizza

3.7 Good 24 Reviews

411 US-46, Liberty

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Basic pizzas. Plain, pepperoni, sausage. Best around. Good price.”

2 Pasta Grill Mansfield

4.7 Superb 77 Reviews

3470 1916, 1916 NJ-57, Hackettstown · 6.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food. Friendly service, nice atmosphere and reasonably priced.”

3 Bruno's Pizza and Pasta

4.7 Superb 58 Reviews

470 Schooleys Mountain Rd #2, Hackettstown · 7.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They have some good slices, and the staff is wonderful! I'll probably stop here again.But I was here between 8-9pm on a Friday night, and they need to keep those slice pies coming out! In the past 10 minutes I witnessed 6 people want plain slices but they were out, and offering people specialty slices, or to wait for a new pie. Remember, it's always better to have a couple to many plain slices, then potentially turn away business. In my experience at least.But yeah, good food, good people. I was just passing through, but if I find myself hungry in the area again, I'd definitely stop back.”

4 Davila's Pizza and Catering

4.7 Superb 52 Reviews

190 Main St, Hackettstown · 6.68 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Lived here over 5 years and never checked this place out. My daughter and I went for a quick bite tonight. The pizza was delicious! And everyone was so warm and friendly! I'm from NY and I'm picky about my pizza! Definitely go check them out!!”

5 Prontos Pizzeria & Restaurant

5.0 Superb 20 Reviews

1956 NJ-57, Hackettstown · 6.73 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Decent place with a bar and dining area. Authentic Italian food and ambiance. The deep dish pizza was good but our sea food was not fresh. The service was above and beyond. 12" deep dish is enough for 4 people. It is a budget friendly place and plenty of parking available.”

6 Domenicos Pizzeria and Liquor Store

4.6 Superb 36 Reviews

507 US-46, Belvidere · 4.81 miles

• Take-Out

“Can't beat the price and their hospitality!Inside the store, there's a mini bar with TV, deli/pizza and variety of liquors. Sit at the bar, have a beer while they cook the order. The owner's extremely nice. I'm taking my out of state family to this place when they come up!”

7 The Smashed Olive

4.3 Superb 139 Reviews

289 NJ-31, Washington · 8.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Place is absolutely amazing. The shrimp risotto is so flavorful and the shrimp are huge! The drinks are amazing and the entire staff is so warm and welcoming. Amazing job to Dave and his family for opening up the new place and a big thank you to managers, Jess and Felipe.”

8 Roman Pizza

4.6 Superb 34 Reviews

33 Wall St, Oxford · 4.35 miles

• Delivery

“I give Roman Pizza four stars, not for the pizza, but for the welcoming service and how I was greeted when I visited this location for the first time. The location has a sitting area with several tables and has an array of items on their menu at Avery reasonable cost. The daily special is two slices and a can of coke for $5.99! The pizza slice had a good dough and made thin and crispy which are its highlight. There is plenty of cheese, however the slice did not have much flavor. It was lacking a bit of salt and spices such as oregano. Overall Roman Pizza is a good pizza location to visit when in the area that offers good food at a very reasonable price.”

9 The Log Cabin Bar & Grill

4.4 Superb 62 Reviews

2314 47 US-46, Columbia · 7.5 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Always a friendly atmosphere. Very good food at very reasonable prices”

10 Roman Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.7 Superb 25 Reviews

124A NJ-94, Blairstown · 8.95 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food and great service!!! Love their pies!!”

11 Little John's Pizza

4.8 Superb 20 Reviews

401 Water St, Belvidere · 6.57 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best Italian spot in jersey tbh it’s was the most authentic pizza I had compared to all these other places like franks omg I will never go back to franks it was 100% worth the 30 minute drive from where I live and I will drive here any day over these other spots.”

12 Waters Edge

4.3 Superb 67 Reviews

487 US-46, Belvidere · 4.51 miles

“This is our regular #1 favorite place to eat, The owner & his staff are all super friendly , The food is superb every time,The prices are so reasonable ,And octoberfest is happening for this whole month and everyone is dressing the part ! & The live music to go with it is Amazing , They had all the dinners joining in .Best Atmosphere ! If you have not been to Waters edge yet , Go it is well worth the trip !”

13 BlackStone Bar & Grill

4.3 Superb 58 Reviews

86 US-46, Hackettstown · 5.08 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing! We had a private event today and Pete was awesome! the food was great! highly recommend!”

14 Hope Pizzeria and Catering - Hope, NJ

4.5 Superb 23 Reviews

435 Hope Blairstown Rd, Hope · 4.12 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“So, I know this is a pizza place - shout out to the pizza. But, also THE BEST CHICKEN FINGERS EVERR!!! Not your run-of-the-mill bagged frozen tenders, these are HAND BREADED, FRESH chicken fingers. Grab them with some honey mustard... Amazingggg.”

15 Dominick's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.6 Superb 16 Reviews

128 NJ-94, Blairstown · 8.96 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“being from Pa, this is the best pizza we've had in 22 years!”

16 Bagelsmith Food Store Deli & Pizzeria

4.2 Good 60 Reviews

540 County Road 519, Belvidere · 3.97 miles

• Take-Out

“First time getting a pie there. Excellent!”

17 Terranova Pizzeria & Trattoria

4.2 Good 50 Reviews

1557 Panther Valley Mall, Allamuchy · 7.56 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“By far the best pizza I’ve ever had! The crust is not dry like most places. They have ruined pizza for me anywhere else!!”

18 Mamma Maria Pizza

4.2 Good 40 Reviews

433 NJ-31, Washington · 9.4 miles

• Delivery

“We ordered for the 1st time today. The food is delicious and the best Italian food in the area. We are so happy to find a place that prepares delicious meals.”

19 Dicola's Pizza

4.1 Good 41 Reviews

50 NJ-31, Washington · 6.82 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Union county in the house! The best pizza in the area here in warren county .Compares to none other. Tried them all in the 20 years since we moved here. We Always ask for thin crust and it never disappoints. Mangia mangia!”

20 Frank's Pizza and Italian restaurant

4.1 Good 29 Reviews

152 NJ-94, Blairstown · 8.86 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Wonderful establishment, wonderful food, wonderful staff! Besides all of that, this place has been supporting our community for years in any way they can! Thank you Frank's!”

21 Frank's Pizza (Mansfield)

4.0 Good 50 Reviews

1885 NJ-57, Hackettstown · 6.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Last night I had chicken francese at Franks. I like plenty of lemon tast and that is how it arrived Portion size allowed take home for today”

22 Little Italy Brick Oven Pizza & Cafe

4.0 Good 41 Reviews

459 NJ-31, Washington · 9.63 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We ordered catering yesterday for my sons first birthday party and it was fantastic! We got chicken francese, baked ziti, sausage and potatoes, and grilled veggies. Fantastic prices and amazing food! He even made the chicken francese dairy free since my son cannot eat dairy and everyone said they couldn’t tell and it was the best chicken francese, and so juice! My Italian family raved about all the food and all asked where the food came from! Thank you!!”

23 Frank's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

4.0 Good 34 Reviews

431 County Rd 513, Califon · 10.84 miles

• Delivery

“(For whatever reason, I can't seem to get this to the correct town of Califon NJ. There are a lot of Frank's Pizza places in NJ, but the one I ate at was in Califon, just to be clear.) A few years ago, I stopped by here to pick up a Calzone on my way home from wherever, and it was a decent Calzone, but invariably Calzones these days are made with Mozzarella and Ricotta Cheese, and that clashes with the memory of the Calzones I used to get in my younger years at the Buona's pizzeria in Bernardsville (and I haven't been there in years, so I could be remembering them as being better than they actually were). Those Calzones were immense, and made with Mozzarella, no Ricotta, and whatever meat you wanted inside-- in my particular case, that meant occasionally sausage but usually pepperoni. I'd pour on the marinara sauce and wolf these concoctions down with the grease running down my arm like warpaint. In retrospect, really, REALLY unhealthy, but in those days, I could gorge myself on food that would make any doctor cringe and never gain a pound. I could thoughtlessly comport myself like a gluttonous, self-indulgent wastrel, and still perambulate insouciantly about the earth with a runner's heart, an ascetic's liver, and veins/arteries unclogged by cholesterol. "Memories...light the corners of my mind..." Anyway... I haven't been back to Frank's since that Calzone (which...just to be clear...was very good, but couldn't match my rose-colored memories of those I had consumed in my teen years and young manhood; then again, what Calzone could?), but my old friend lives in the area, and last week we were looking for a place to sit down and eat (Califon is rural, and scenically impressive, but there aren't a lot of dining options), and we both finally agreed to give this place a try. There's a "pizzeria" style section in the front; a conventional sit-down restaurant in the back, which is where we chose to dine, as it was the least crowded portion of the restaurant. Our server was great-- cheerful, ebullient, hard-working. She started us off with a bowl of garlic bread, which was very nice, although I could have used more of it. I ordered a Coke, a bowl of Pasta Fagioli, and what was listed on the menu as "Baked Frank's Special Rigatoni." My friend ordered the same thing, minus the soup and the soda. There was a bit of a wait, but I was ok with it, telling my friend, "That means they're not using a microwave." (I can never entirely free my mind of those "Kitchen Nightmare" memories, the ones where Gordon Ramsay would sneer with his patented English contempt about microwaved food, "This is hid-eeee-ous!...Is the oven broken? It's disgusting! What a di-zasta!") My friend was getting antsy, but I thought the wait-time was reasonable. I'm content to wait for food that's actually prepared in a kitchen and cooked, as opposed to a rock-hard block of pre-frozen food microwaved to a state of reasonable edibility. The soup was hot and tasty, and filling. The "Special Rigatoni" was a large bowl of the pasta with sausage, eggplant, onions, mushrooms in a marinara sauce, topped off by a substantive amount of melted cheese. It was a different kind of dish than I'm used to (in Italian restaurants, I tend to gravitate towards lasagna or chicken parmigiana), but I found it flavorful in a delightfully unique kind of way, and it was more than enough to satisfy and soothe my often overly aggressive appetite. My friend concurred with my glowing assessment. When we were getting ready to pay the bill and leave, the server came over with 2 pieces of a delicious cannoli cake, on the house. I wanted to say, "Don't mind my impatient friend; we didn't wait long at all and it's not necessary," but the tastiness of that first forkful stifled any protestations that I might have been inclined to make. I scarfed it down with the same alacrity with which I had consumed my meal. And con”

24 Gabby's Pizza

3.9 Good 26 Reviews

190 Mountain Ave, Hackettstown · 6.99 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing owners! Best experience ever so far! What a kind humble people! Great food too! We couldn’t ask for a better night!”

25 Pizza Express

3.8 Good 19 Reviews

187 NJ-94 #6, Blairstown · 8.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best gluten free cauliflower pizza I have hard perfectly crispy and delicious. I have tried plenty from places all around and this one by far is the best. Couldn’t be more pleased and will be back.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options are shown on menu with plenty to pick from”

26 Sonny's Pizza II

3.8 Good 29 Reviews

915 County Rd 517, Hackettstown · 6.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We order from Sonny’s more than we would like to admit. Over the weekend, I last minute ordered a grilled chicken salad to go. It was a busy day, and they forgot the chicken. We called and were ready to just drive back and go grab it. They immediately said they were giving it to their delivery driver to add to his drop off. They didn’t have to do that, and we really appreciated it- they definitely did right by us. Also, have to recommend the pierogi pizza and chicken Marsala pizza!”

27 Enzo Pizzeria & Pasta Grill

3.8 Good 56 Reviews

328 W Washington Ave, Washington · 7.53 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love the atmosphere and the food is solid, I had a cheesesteak with fries and it was incredibly fresh.Came here on a whim and i was impressed by it. I’m new to the area looking for new restaurants to frequent, I’m definitely coming back”

28 Angry Dad Draught House

3.7 Good 76 Reviews

268 NJ-31, Washington · 5.8 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Nikki was great made the visit worth it”

29 Brother’s Restaurant - Bar and Pizza

3.7 Good 76 Reviews

301 W Washington Ave, Washington · 7.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I’ve had dinner there twice, and the food was excellent and the service was great!”

30 Ciao Pizzeria

3.6 Good 33 Reviews

2297 NJ-57, Washington · 10.48 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The cauliflower crust pizza was outstanding. The wings were not my favorite. They are small and soft. Strange texture. You can pop them into not your mouth and pull out the bones. Nothing like Buffalo Wild Wings, Rath's Deli, or Wing Stop where you need to bite into the wing with a little force. I'd prefer to pay more for larger, higher quality wings, so I won't be ordering them again unless they upgrade their chicken. Some people may prefer a smaller, softer wing so this could be a preference. But delivery was great, and I would order the pizza again.”

31 Taste of Italy Ristorante & Pizzeria

3.5 Good 46 Reviews

57 US-46 E, Hackettstown · 7.52 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best pizza in town”

32 Leo's Pizza Italian Restaurant

3.5 Good 49 Reviews

5 Clubhouse Drive, Washington · 8.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Very impressive, from the moment I entered this place, I was greeted by a very nice young woman, I never see this anywhere at all in years, so even if I wasn't impressed with the food they still deserve the stars but this wasn't the case, I will admit I'm very picky with my calzones and at $22 each expectation was low as far as quality and size, this was excellent and huge well worth the price, I will for sure use this as my go to spot from now on plus I ordered it went shopping at shoprite and picked it up when I came out excellent customer service really made me feel valued as a customer ?”