11 Best Italian Restaurants in Manalapan

“My granddaughter had her graduation dinner here. It was absolutely fabulous. Lovely atmosphere, fantastic service & the food was amazing. Can’t say enough how great this restaurant is. I would highly recommend this restaurant to family & friends.“

“They are truly a tribute to a neighborhood business. Outstanding food, and customer comes first atitude. Congratulations !!!“

“Place is very welcoming. Always has great music. Very friendly girls behind the counter and the boss is always extremely kind to every single person. Pizza is out of this world and the food never disappoints. La dona just gained a loyal customer !!“

“Amazing food and staff. Always a great experience!“

“Emilio’s new Bar Pie is hands down the best Bar Pie that I’ve ever eaten. It’s handcrafted and the crust is perfection. I wouldn’t go anywhere else!!“

“Since moving to New Jersey, Mezza Luna is the only Pizza that my youngest son will eat. Not only is their pizza amazing but their dinner dishes and everything else on the menu is just as tasty. I look forward to when I order from Mezza Luna because I know we will be having a delicious dinner. They are generous size portions, and the quality and taste are excellent. The customer service is amazing. And the delivery is always faster than what they tell you which is so nice. the owners are wonderful and generous people. They are active in the community. I recommend that everyone eat here or order from here with their really fast delivery, the food always comes hot. I love Mezza Luna and I will continue to be a loyal customer.“

“Me & the boys still talk about how good this pizza is. It's hands down the best pizza I've ever had. I'd happily walk from here in Scotland to New Jersey for a slice!“

“Ordered sandwiches (in a “6” shape) and salads for my kids 6th bday. I was pleasantly surprised at the presentation and quality! Will definitely be ordering again. Thank you!“

“The food here was absolutely incredible! The spaghetti was perfectly cooked and full of flavor, and the pizza was hot, cheesy, and delicious. The service was excellent — everyone was so friendly, polite, and made sure we had everything we needed. The restaurant was also clean and cozy, which made the whole experience even better. I would definitely come back again and recommend it to anyone who loves great food and great service!“

“Cucina Alessi Restaurant and Pizzeria consistently delivers some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I’ve visited half a dozen times, and each experience has been worth the trip. As someone particular about pizza, I can say this place stands out for both quality and flavor. Located in an upscale shopping center, Cucina Messi offers not only exceptional food but also a warm, welcoming atmosphere and attentive service.“

“Grabbed 2 slices to go this afternoon (9/5/25) after kayaking at the Manasquan Reservoir. Came to a little over $7, which is kinda steep for just two slices, but honestly the pizza was really good. Sometimes you just gotta roll with it — I’d definitely recommend.“