Browse menus, reviews and photos of Italian Restaurants near Colts Neck.
Italian · $$
323 NJ-34, Colts Neck
Customers’ favorites
“Amazing food, great portions and quality for price, friendly and personal able staff, quick service, clean and warm atmosphere. Highly recommend. Definitely make reservations”
Pizza · $
943 NJ-34, Colts Neck
Customers’ favorites
“We had a catered affair from Prima Pizza at our VFW Post. Food was delicious. The fettuccine carbonara was so tasty. Eggplant rollatini was cooked to perfection. Definitely 5 Stars.”
Italian · $$
420 NJ-34, Colts Neck
Customers’ favorites
“My mother and law happen to come across this family owned establishment when we came into town for a doctors appointment. The food was AMAZING. We literally ate every piece of the delectable meal that was cooked for us. Our waitress was a family member who was the kindest person. If we are ever in town again we will definitely be stopping in!”
Pizza · $
340 NJ-34, Colts Neck
Customers’ favorites
“My wife and I had a wonderful meal she had a calzone that was cooked to perfection and huge. I had the best Pasta Bolognese I ever had and it's my go to dish . We both loved the Stewart sodas to compete the meal. Owner and staff were welcoming and pleasant a perfect find we loved it”
Italian · $$
3475 US-9, Freehold · 6.52 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Owner should learn how to treat customers We were a party of four and we arrived on time for a 7:45 reservation. When we arrived there were many people waiting to be seated. We were told that the wait would only be 10 - 15 minutes. Fifteen minutes later we were told that the wait would be an additional 10 - 15 minutes. A half hour later my wife was told that the wait would only be another 10 - 15 minutes. After 45 minutes I requested to speak with the owner and I was told that I was speaking with the owner (at that point there was only one other group waiting to be seated). They informed me that a group of six with an 8:00 reservation was just seated. I said that it was not fair to make us wait 45 minutes since we did have a reservation and the people with a later reservation were just seated. I said that I may have something to say about it after the meal. The reply was "if you have something to say, say it now"! I replied that I would reserve my thoughts until after the meal. How insulting, imagine waiting over 45 minutes and then being told if I had anything to say I shouldn't wait till after my dinner, that I should say it now. I replied that I would wait till after the meal before I had any additional comments. With that we were refused service and we were told to leave. I am a 75 year old retired veteran and in my life I was never treated in this manner. When we grew up we had more respect for others. This is not how customers should be treated.”
Italian · $$
53 NJ-34, Marlboro · 6.83 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Regularly a Brooklyn customer and tonight stopped in the NJ location. I really enjoyed the food as usual. Julia was a great server and would definitely go back when in the area. Rob”
Italian · $$$
1178 NJ-34, Aberdeen · 7.83 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The BEST! Always a wonderful experience. Great food, great service and an amazing atmosphere. A feeling of being in Italy.🇮🇹 Our favorite place to eat. And the owners Mike & Ro are always so pleasant and accommodating.”
Italian · $$$
2132 NJ-35, Holmdel · 8.65 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We recently hosted our rehearsal dinner at Patricia's in Holmdel, and we couldn't have asked for a more fabulous experience! Everything was absolutely perfect. The food was delicious and the service exceptional. Ivan and Daniel were outstanding - attentive, professional and so accommodating. A special thank you to John Tomassetti, the manager, who was truly hands-on throughout the entire evening. John went above and beyond and decorated the room to perfection. His attention to detail and dedication helped make our celebration so beautiful and memorable. We are so grateful to the entire team at Patricia's for helping make such a special night more wonderful. We had an amazing time and highly recommend Patricia's for any special occasion!!”
Italian · $$$
19 Broad Street, Red Bank · 7.17 miles
“The perfect evening ! Food, service and atmosphere were all spot on! Chef Dimas Montalvo III your a true talent !”
Recommended
Italian · $$$
16a West Main Street, Freehold · 5.73 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Our favorite date night spot!! From the moment you enter- elegant atmosphere, warm faces and nice music set the tone for a wonderful night. Anthony the owner makes you feel like you’re the only diners there- making sure you’re enjoying yourself, getting your food in a timely manner and making it special. He is such a kind generous man. The servers Faith, Carson, and JoJo are absolutely incredible- they are knowledgeable about the food, friendly, and their work ethic is incredible for such young people. They truly made our night special! The food is the star- best rice balls we’ve ever had!! We have been dreaming of them ever since! The homemade burrata, meatballs and eggplant were also just amazing. We had the homemade gnocchi and chicken scarpiello- again the best we’ve ever had We are locals and try to get here as often as we can for date night- and we are always so amazed how it continues to be just 5 star every time. It’s a special, special place and we are lucky to have such a gem in our small town. Thank you Anthony & Heather!”
Italian · $$
183 Riverside Ave, Red Bank · 6.86 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Fun atmosphere, delicious food. Our waitress Staci was great! We will be back.”
Italian · $$$
5119 Asbury Avenue, Tinton Falls · 4.75 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Last night we came in before a show we were seeing! Our waiter Collin was fantastic he was nice and attentive and made sure that we had everything we needed. The pasta with the spicy sauce was amazing. Collin suggested the meatballs and they were honestly the best meatballs I ever had at a restaurant. We will be back for sure!”
Italian · $
345 West Main Street, Freehold · 7.37 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Never had a meal I didn’t love”
Italian · $$$
500 NJ-35, Red Bank · 7.45 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This restaurant has amazing food and the waiters are very kind”
Italian · $$
3857 County Rd 516, Old Bridge · 10.32 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Food is excellent, amazing selection of specials and all that we had was so delicious! Pizza is by far the best pizza around! It’s cooked perfectly and flavors are just amazing! Staff were all terrific and make you feel like part of their family. Definitely returning and brining family and friends and letting everyone know about it!”
Italian · $$
Design Center Plaza, 345 US-9, Manalapan · 7.13 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My granddaughter had her graduation dinner here. It was absolutely fabulous. Lovely atmosphere, fantastic service & the food was amazing. Can’t say enough how great this restaurant is. I would highly recommend this restaurant to family & friends.”
Italian · $
177 Elton Adelphia Road, Freehold · 6.9 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My go to Italian restaurant near me. I go for pizza or hero sandwiches. I have had dinners there as well. Always reliably good and staff is great. Nino knows me by site, b when I go in he grabs my order. I will keep going there for a good meal.”
Italian · $$$
167 US-9 South, Morganville · 8.34 miles
Customers’ favorites
“La Cucina is absolutely delicious. Always fresh and VERY consistent. I have never ordered something that wasn’t superb! They have the best halibut over risotto I have ever had. If you have never dine here before then you are certainly missing out. Cucina is our go to! Best food in town by a long shot 🙌🏼”
Italian · $$$
837 West Park Avenue, Ocean · 6.89 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I’ve been coming to this restaurant for years. This is by far my favorite restaurant in Ocean Township! If you want a great fine dining experience with delicious food and a friendly owner and staff, Piccolo’s is the place to go! They are consistently delicious :). Highly recommend this establishment. 5 Stars!!! .”
Italian · $$
443 NJ-34, Matawan · 10.53 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The food was amazing,the staff is friendly attentive and very professional”
Italian · $$$
448 US-9, Englishtown · 7.6 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We have been to Nonna's many times and have always enjoyed the food and service. Today, my wife, daughter and I went to celebrate our 51st anniversary expecting to have a delicious dinner as usual. Although the food was excellent as always, the service was not! The waitress Melissa took our order and never saw her again until we were almost finished eating and had to wave to her to get more water. A man brought our bread and butter, another man brought our meals, and cheese etc. and that went well. It should be noted that Melissa never once came back to our table to see if the food was ok or if we needed anything. When she brought the water, she asked if we wanted desert, to which we declined. Another lady came and asked if we wanted our leftovers wrapped whereas she took our plates and returned immediately. Melissa dropped off the bill and walked away, and we never saw her again. We had some questions about the administration fee, because we were paying cash, but there was no one to ask so we just paid the bill, left the folder on the table and left, again, no one was around. When we were seated, there was a small party at a table near us, but they left long before we were ready to leave, so I cant understand why no one even came to our table, since by that time there were only about three tables of diners. Sorry I had to write this response but we were very unhappy with this dining visit. Like I said earlier, we have previously had great service and hope our next visit will be great. Thank You.”
Italian · $$
22 East Front Street, Red Bank · 7.24 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Highly recommended! This place is great!”
Italian · $$$
623 Newman Springs Road, Lincroft · 4.12 miles
“Absolutely stunning atmosphere, The service was impeccable, And the food was some of the best I have ever had! Yes it is expensive but so worth it. Perfect for date nite!!!”
Italian
963 Holmdel Road, Holmdel · 4.19 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Sale & Pepe is absolutely OUT OF THIS WORLD! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is easily one of the best Italian restaurants we’ve been to. I honestly cannot believe this place has 4.8 stars — 5 out of 5, without question! The pizza is incredibly fresh, the salads are fantastic, and the dressing has this special blend of spices that makes it completely different from anything you normally get. Then they bring out this huge homemade bread with authentic olive oil and pesto — amazing! And the main dishes? Stunning. Everything tastes fresh and authentic, and the portions are incredibly generous. What a find! We came here before a concert at PNC and now I’d make the trip back just to eat here. Absolutely fantastic Italian food!”
Italian
8 South Main Street, Marlboro · 4.51 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Came here for dinner tonight with 10 of us! The restaurant is so pretty. The service was amazing. The owners Colleen & Joe were so warm and friendly. Hot bread came out immediately and complementary olives, delicious fava beans and cheese were placed on our table. Our dinners all came with salads. We all loved our dinners and the portions were large. Can't wait to come back again! Highly recommend!”
Italian · $$
31 East Main Street, Freehold · 5.67 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We had such a great dinner with friends. The food was outstanding and so was the service. We have never been disappointed when eating at this restaurant. I highly recommend for any occasion or no occasion.”
Italian · $$$
51 Oceanport Avenue, Little Silver · 7.49 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Locale doesn’t just serve Italian food — it seduces you with it. The meal opens with a Margherita pizza that nails the holy trinity: blistered, leopard-spotted crust with a satisfying chew, bright San Marzano tomato sauce, pools of molten mozzarella, and basil that perfumes every bite. It’s simple, soulful, and executed with confidence — the kind of pizza that reminds you why restraint is the ultimate flex. Then come the pastas, each one richer than the last. A creamy spaghetti glistens under cracked black pepper and fine breadcrumbs, indulgent without tipping into excess — silk on the tongue, deeply comforting. The baked rigatoni arrives bubbling and bronzed, blanketed in béchamel and cheese, fork-tender and unapologetically decadent, finished with a rosemary sprig that whispers old-world charm. The seafood salad brings balance: crisp celery, briny sweetness, delicate citrus notes, and freshness that cuts through the richness like a perfectly timed palate cleanse. And just when you think you’re done, a golden, cheese-crusted entrée lands center stage — crackling on top, impossibly tender beneath, finished with olive oil and snow-like Parmesan. Rustic. Elegant. Completely crave-worthy. Ambiance? Warm, intimate, and effortlessly stylish. Wood tables, low lighting, the hum of conversation — the kind of place where time slows, wine flows, and every table looks like it’s celebrating something. Final verdict: Locale is the kind of restaurant you plan your week around — not flashy, just flawless. Come hungry, linger long, and trust the kitchen. This is Italian food done with heart, heritage, and serious skill.”
Italian · $$
1801 NJ-35, Oakhurst · 7.2 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great food amazing service and wonderful warm hospitality”
Italian · $
1201 Sycamore Avenue, Tinton Falls · 4 miles
“Award-winning food with a side of award-winning service. Cheers to you Jimmy and thank you as always!!”
Italian · $$
1281-1283 NJ-35, Middletown · 8.29 miles
“Beautiful atmosphere, attentive and friendly staff, delicious salads, soups, family style appetizers, meal choices, desserts and drinks - everything was perfect.”
Italian · $$
2200 US-9, Howell · 8.27 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Held my daughter’s Bridal Shower here today and I can’t say enough wonderful things about it. The service and food was exceptional. Everyone was so helpful and accommodating. We were so pleased and I would highly recommend hosting your event here.”
Italian · $
3701 Highway 33, 3705 NJ-33, Neptune · 6.69 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Always accommodating! Very close to work and convenient.”
Italian
130 South Main Street, Marlboro · 4.47 miles
“A hidden gem in Marlboro has just opened. Beautifully decorated, top notch service and the food was to die for.”
Deli · $
415 US-9, Englishtown · 7.82 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Most amazing subs I’ve ever had, treated with complete respect. I had wings, fries, pickles, Philly steak, and Philly chicken. Taking the first bite it was mouth watering. Thank you!”
Italian · $$
203 West Sylvania Avenue, Neptune City · 9.21 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We stumbled on this spot to take out pizza, which is very good. Now it’s become our local spot. Amazing salads - no boring iceberg lettuce, it’s arugula, pears, gorgonzola….Fave entrees include super eggplant parm, tortellini, the classics. Also great lunch deals. Prices are very reasonable and the staff a delight. No ambiance but it’s a friendly, local spot with super food in generous portions.”
Italian · $$
312 West Sylvania Avenue, Neptune City · 8.66 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great food and friendly service. Local family atmosphere. Highly recommended 👌”
Italian · $$
1 Corbett Way, Eatontown · 6.59 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great food and nice place to be”
Italian · $$
20 Broad Street, Red Bank · 7.15 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I hosted a family event at Via Sposito. Everyone was very pleased with our server, Jessica and the dining experience. The food was amazing and plentiful. We have dined there a few times prior to this and were always pleased with food. At our event everything was family style and there was a variety of food. The pizza and zeppoles were also great. They worked within our budget and offered a lot of choices.”
Italian
555 Shrewsbury Avenue, Shrewsbury · 6.09 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Delicious food and great service. Wonderful atmosphere. So nice to see the owners welcoming you too.”
Italian · $$$
125 Markham Place, Little Silver · 7.69 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Warm, welcoming feeling as soon as you walk in. Our waiter really knew the menu well and how each dish was prepared. Service was excellent. Too many items looked great. Portion sizes are geared for sharing, so larger group would have given us the ability to try more items. The Chicken Parm is as good as everyone has recommended. From the fresh Burrata to two half portions of different pastas and the light Hazelnut cheesecake, it was excellent. We will be back as well a look forward to going their other location, Raia's in Long Branch that recently opened.”
Italian · $
2005 NJ-35, Oakhurst · 7.1 miles
“Nino Jr's food is so delicious. I recently catered from them for my daughter's baby shower and our guests raved about the food. It was amazing. Everyone wanted to know where the food came from. The entire experience was wonderful! The staff was so wonderful also. Everything from the ordering experience to delivery was incredible. I highly recommend Nino Jr's. The best Italian food!”
Italian · $$
28 Broad Street, Red Bank · 7.13 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Food was good, service was great (Alex) . They charge you if you use your credit card and in my case my debit card. My biggest complaint is that the oysters were the size of my thumb nail, so skip the oysters.”
Italian · $$$$
447 NJ-35, Red Bank · 7.51 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Amazing food, amazing service. A bit pricy for the area and food but worth the go!”
Italian · $$
3679 US-9, Old Bridge · 9.32 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Had a Family Birthday Celebration Awesome definitely go back!!”
Pizza · $$
1175 NJ-33 Ste 6, Farmingdale · 4.29 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We went on Saturday for dinner...My wife had Eggplant Rollatini for an appy and Chicken Francese for dinner...I had the Sauteed Clams for an appy and the Seafood Fra Diavolo for dinner....Everything was Excellent....Next we will try the pizza...”
Italian · $$
7 South Street, Freehold · 5.69 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Delicious food, wonderful staff and great music.”
Italian · $$
3253 NJ-35, Hazlet · 9.36 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Went there with a party of 10. Was very good. Went back the following week with my wife. Food is delicious. Interior very well decorated. Highly recommended.”
Italian · $$$
765 NJ-34, Matawan · 9.66 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The food and service was second to none. The staff very attentive not over bering. A comfy cozy atmosphere. The restaurant is BYOB this is a plus. The portions are perfect size. I can't find enough good to post.”
Italian · $
3429 NJ-35, Hazlet · 9.53 miles
Customers’ favorites
“STUMBLED UPON A THIS GREAT FIND. BEEN THERE MANY TIMES SINCE. EVERYTHING IS FRESH, TASTY AND VERY REASONABLY PRICED. IF YOU'RE IN THE AREA DON'T MISS OUT AND STOP BY. ONCE YOU TRY THE FOOD YOU'LL ALWAYS GO BACK. NEVER WRITE A REVIEW BUT THIS PLACE IS SO WORTHY OF ACCOLADES, I JUST HAD TOO.”
Italian · $$$
476 CR-520, Marlboro · 4.93 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Best restaurant in nj hands down”
Una Pizza Napoletana, a popular spot in New York, has just been named the best pizza in the world by the 2024 Italian 50 Top Pizza ranking. This is a major victory for owner Anthony Mangieri, who has already earned the title of best pizza in the U.S. for three years in a row.
Naples-born Rosso Pomodoro has landed in Denver. The Italian pizza franchise just opened its first U.S. location in the city's Central Park neighborhood at 29th Ave Town Center. "It has long been a dream to introduce our brand of authentic Neapolitan-style pizza to every corner of America,” CEO Nicola Saraceno shared his excitement.
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana, a 100-year-old Coney Island eatery, is looking for a buyer or partner to keep its legacy alive, but it has one important condition. Totonno's has made it through fires, floods, and even COVID, but there's one thing they'll never tolerate: pineapple on their pizza.