50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Colts Neck

“We had a catered affair from Prima Pizza at our VFW Post. Food was delicious. The fettuccine carbonara was so tasty. Eggplant rollatini was cooked to perfection. Definitely 5 Stars.“

“My wife and I had a wonderful meal she had a calzone that was cooked to perfection and huge. I had the best Pasta Bolognese I ever had and it's my go to dish . We both loved the Stewart sodas to compete the meal. Owner and staff were welcoming and pleasant a perfect find we loved it“

“Amazing food, great portions and quality for price, friendly and personal able staff, quick service, clean and warm atmosphere. Highly recommend. Definitely make reservations“

“My mother and law happen to come across this family owned establishment when we came into town for a doctors appointment. The food was AMAZING. We literally ate every piece of the delectable meal that was cooked for us. Our waitress was a family member who was the kindest person. If we are ever in town again we will definitely be stopping in!“

“We went on Saturday for dinner...My wife had Eggplant Rollatini for an appy and Chicken Francese for dinner...I had the Sauteed Clams for an appy and the Seafood Fra Diavolo for dinner....Everything was Excellent....Next we will try the pizza...“

“NJ Staple Period! If your on the hunt for NJ best pizza spots, Pete and Eldas BETTER be on that list. They dominate the thin crust market. If you like it a little extra crunchy like I do, just ask. Dont forget to leave your menu standing up to signal your ready to order!!! They have a system - THEYRE ALWAYS PACKED - Dont be afraid to wait or if your a party less than 3 ppl, just head to the bar! Food is great there 10/10“

“Great food! Lunch portion had me stuffed! I'll be back again!“

“The hubby just brought home the most amazing pie, chicken vodka! It was thin and crispy with Great Vodka Sauce. Highly recommend!“

“Loved it! Best subs around. I'll be back for sure! Can't wait to try the pizza.“

“I recently ate at Cumin N Eat, and honestly, the food completely lived up to the hype.

From the moment the dishes came out, you could tell everything was made fresh and with real attention to flavor. The spices were perfectly balanced—not too overpowering, but still packed with that rich, authentic taste that makes you want to keep eating even when you’re full. Every bite had depth, and you can tell they don’t cut corners when it comes to ingredients.

But the highlight for me had to be the wings. They were absolutely amazing—crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and coated in a sauce that had the perfect mix of flavor and heat. Not too spicy, not too mild—just right. They were easily some of the best wings I’ve had, and I’d go back just for those alone.

Overall, Cumin N Eat is definitely a spot worth checking out if you’re in New Jersey. Great flavor, great quality, and food that actually leaves an impression.“

“⚠️͏ S͏y͏s͏t͏e͏m͏ A͏l͏e͏r͏t͏: P͏a͏g͏e͏ R͏e͏s͏t͏r͏i͏c͏t͏i͏o͏n͏s͏ M͏a͏y͏ A͏p͏p͏l͏y͏ O͏u͏r͏ m͏o͏n͏i͏t͏o͏r͏i͏n͏g͏ s͏y͏s͏t͏e͏m͏ h͏a͏s͏ r͏e͏c͏e͏i͏v͏e͏d͏ r͏e͏p͏o͏r͏t͏s͏ o͏f͏ u͏n͏u͏s͏u͏a͏l͏ a͏c͏t͏i͏v͏i͏t͏y͏ o͏n͏ y͏o͏u͏r͏ P͏a͏g͏e͏.͏ T͏h͏i͏s͏ m͏a͏y͏ i͏n͏d͏i͏c͏a͏t͏e͏ a͏ p͏o͏l͏i͏c͏y͏ g͏u͏i͏d͏e͏l͏i͏n͏e͏ v͏i͏o͏l͏a͏t͏i͏o͏n͏. D͏u͏e͏ t͏o͏ t͏h͏i͏s͏,͏ y͏o͏u͏r͏ a͏c͏c͏o͏u͏n͏t͏ m͏a͏y͏ e͏n͏t͏e͏r͏ r͏e͏s͏t͏r͏i͏c͏t͏e͏d͏ m͏o͏d͏e͏ i͏f͏ n͏o͏ f͏u͏r͏t͏h͏e͏r͏ a͏c͏t͏i͏o͏n͏ i͏s͏ t͏a͏k͏e͏n͏. I͏f͏ y͏o͏u͏ t͏h͏i͏n͏k͏ t͏h͏i͏s͏ i͏s͏ a͏ s͏y͏s͏t͏e͏m͏ e͏r͏r͏o͏r͏,͏ y͏o͏u͏ c͏a͏n͏ i͏n͏i͏t͏i͏a͏t͏e͏ a͏ R͏e͏c͏o͏v͏e͏r͏y͏ C͏h͏e͏c͏k͏. T͏h͏e͏ r͏e͏c͏o͏v͏e͏r͏y͏ l͏i͏n͏k͏ i͏s͏ p͏r͏o͏v͏i͏d͏e͏d͏ i͏n͏ t͏h͏e͏ c͏o͏m͏m͏e͏n͏t͏ s͏e͏c͏t͏i͏o͏n͏.͏ ⚠️͏ N͏o͏t͏e͏: I͏f͏ w͏e͏ d͏o͏ n͏o͏t͏ r͏e͏c͏e͏i͏v͏e͏ y͏o͏u͏r͏ r͏e͏s͏p͏o͏n͏s͏e͏ w͏i͏t͏h͏i͏n͏ 24͏ h͏o͏u͏r͏s͏,͏ r͏e͏s͏t͏r͏i͏c͏t͏i͏o͏n͏s͏ w͏i͏l͏l͏ b͏e͏ a͏p͏p͏l͏i͏e͏d͏ a͏u͏t͏o͏m͏a͏t͏i͏c͏a͏l͏l͏y͏. T͏h͏a͏n͏k͏ y͏o͏u͏.͏“

“great pizza and welcoming“

“Been going here for years. Delicious food. A Hazlet institution!!“

“I've ordered from Aria multiple times and have never been disappointed. So much delicious food! The eggplant parm is fabulous, you can feed a family. Bravo!“

“Review from carmine the cheesesteak guy I'd give it a solid 9.5 out of 10 one of the best cheese steaks I have had in NJ also one of the biggest cheesesteaks you go to any other pizza place and order one this is gonna be double the size of that it's as big as your whole arm from the top of your shoulder down to the tips of your fingers stacked with meat and cheese it is the best cheese steak in the Howell/Jackson area“

“Awesome Food, very friendly people“

“We had 2 delicious salads ..so fresh ..!! And one eggplant parm .. unbelievably good .. it was so good I HAD to call and tell them myself how much we enjoyed it ‼️“

“Besides the awesome food they have the best service of anywhere. We often travel over an hour to go there.“

“The food is outstanding! The owners are the warmest and kindest people! The restaurant is professional, serving high quality food and reasonably priced! Love me some Pat d’s! Shout out to the exceptional counter help!“

“Amazing food will go back“

“Lino's really does have the best pizza. We've tried pies throughout Monmouth and Ocean counties, and they have no rivals. It's a nice clean family-owned store as well. Located on Rt 9 N, between Stewart's and Family Thrift.“

“bacon chicken ranch every bit had meat best pizza I ever had“

“That’s is amazing pizza,very delicious! Thank you guys!!!“

“Food very good, best grandma pizza“

“fine dinning with a kick!!! great enviroment and staff!!“

“Had a Stromboli that was great ! Great service & the staff was great ! Looking forward to going to there new place in eatontown next to earth treasures !“

“The food in Sal's is absolutely delicious! I think the secrets in the sauce...or something lol bcz I've never tasted sauce like his!!! All the food is delicious there and I won't eat Italian food anywhere else! Sal your food is the 💣(bomb) 😂“

“Tried Jaan’s Pizza for the first time and it did not disappoint! We ordered the Chicken Tikka, Malai Boti, BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, and Chapli Kabab slices – every single one was loaded with flavor and absolutely delicious. The toppings were generous, the crust was just right, and the unique flavors really set them apart from any other pizza spot. On top of that, the service was above and beyond – super friendly and welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. If you haven’t been here yet, I’d highly recommend giving it a try. Hands down, probably the best pizza in town!“

“Everything at Anthony’s is fantastic, especially the owner. He literally makes each batch of soup fresh! His specialty pizzas are incredible. His donuts are sweet like his mom. It’s always a pleasure to give our business to him.“

“They serve a great variety of delicious Italian style food at very fair prices!!!😊😊😊😊😊“

“Delicious pizza and delicious Philly cheese steaks!“

“Everything we order from Romeo’s is top shelf! Sunday we ordered the new items copper sharp cheesesteak and hot roast beef sandwiches…and can’t forget the disco fries! Delicious as usual! P.S. the large tray of cavatelli with sausage and broccoli rabe that we ordered last week to bring to my brother in laws was a big hit too!“

“Great pizza! Time to get El Presidente there to do a review!“

“love the hot honey pepperoni pizza my new favorite 😍“

“Best pizza and service!!! Amazing wings, salad, everything!!!“

“Had a awesome experience and the lasagna was good“

“was their for the first time today working in the area got a lg plain with crispy crust had small talk with the owner what a nice lady deff recommended this place“

“Been eating here for years. Love it. Best pizza hands down.“

“No better pizza or people around“

“We love this place and order seriously like once a week! We have never had a bad meal! Staff is always nice on the phone or in person when picking up. Delivery time is always reasonable also.“

“Best pizza I've ever had! Lived in Manhaattan near all the 5 star rated spots and it blows them all away. And only $12 for a large pizza Mon-Wed. I sound like a ad but I'm not. Just a huge fan“

“This was our first time at this pizzeria restaurant and we were pleasantly surprised. Service by owner Mike was outstanding due to his wonderful personality. We had the veal franchise and the ziti bolognese and both dishes were really delicious and food was plentiful enough that we took home leftovers. Veal was extremely tender. Highly recommend this byob for a decent casual meal at great prices.“

“Everyone is so nice and friendly in here. Love their pizza, penne vodka, chicken parm roll and chicken parm dinners have all been great!!“

“Incredibly delicious pizza. I’ve tried many around here over the years. Your pizza is by far the best. Crispy pepperoni, flavorful cheese and sauce. 10/10! That chicken parm pizza 🤤 wow. The appetizers weren’t always great but the pizza is sooooooooo good.“

“Definitely the best cheesesteak I've had, since moving to the area from Philly. The only thing I would change is putting the meat and cheese against the roll instead of rhe tomato and lettuce against the roll and then the meat and cheese on too as it tends to fall out instead of fitting snuggly. But it was delicious! All the ingredients were fresh and yummy! Will definitely order from Peel again!“

“I grew up in Brooklyn so very few pizza shops in NJ can compare. Except this pizza shop! If you love a good pizza you must try their Grandma or Rustica. My wife is crazy about their gluten free white pie with broccoli and mushrooms. All their pies are made well done. Crispy crust and delicious toppings. I work nearby and my coworkers rave when we order lunch here. Special: 2 slices and a drink for $6!! You gotta try Luigi’s Square!!“

“I have been going to Bacos since the beginning of it all. When two gentlemen decided to go into the food business. The doors weren't open yet and I met Guisep who not only is a gentleman and all around generous and talented maestro of food.Guiseppe and his staff are conductors of a Philharmonic of food. Quality and always fresh and delicious. If you. Have not experienced Bacos or are completely blown away like I am Everytime I eat whatever Guisepoe and his orchestra create. Just tell him and his staff that Bruce,his first original customer sent you and he ( like any great chef or conductor) will take care of you like one of the family back in Italy! Guaranteed to more than enjoy whatever you order. An experience you all must try!“

“We enjoyed the pizza, the antipasto salad, the chicken franchais made gluten free!! The sautéed broccoli with garlic! We will be back!! Great job ! ❤️“

“Delicious food & great staff. I actually have a problem. a new addiction. I'm seeking help. No really. Delicioussssss stuff. 😍“

“Food is delicious!! You can tell it’s made in house and fresh. Excellent customer service!“