“Found this local gem a few years back by accident while traveling for work and loved it. Well, back after a year and the place got a much deserved makeover inside and out - Food is still great - brought friends who enjoyed the onion soup and the chicken and fish française. Fish oreganata was also well prepared. Very large local bar crowd. Nick is still a wonderful host. Get there before 6 or the place fills up! Enjoy!“
“Nettie’s has an unassuming look as you drive by but when it’s open the parking lot is full. When I walked in I was pleasantly surprised at the warm atmosphere and decor. The server was very energetic, efficient and informative. The menu is somewhat limited but unique and elevated. Not your typical red sauce Italian. We shared Homemade ricotta served with seeded twist bread and Roasted Cabbage with a Caesar inspired dressing for appetizers. The ricotta was so creamy and fresh and the cabbage was so flavorful. We had the Hit Vinegar chicken that was perfectly cooked and tasted like grandma used to make and Fresh made Cavatelli with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage. The sausage and rave were cut up small so you had the taste in every bite. It was an outstanding experience across the board.“
“While they have so many fantastic foods to choose from, my favorite is their subs. It seems basic, I'm sure, but the quality of the cold cuts (and that they are actually cut PROPERLY) and the bread they use just makes it the best around like what used to be common place before chain places took over. This is a family business that's been serving our community in Tinton Falls for years and has some of the loveliest people working there.“
“Food was good, a little expensive. We had a gift certificate we purchased online and at first the Tinton falls restaurant said that was for the coney Island restaurant and did not want to take it. Showing him the gift certificate did not state Coney Island only, he did accept it. That was the only issue that the did resolve. “