12 Best Italian Restaurants in Asbury Park

“Clearly, Belmonte's have switched owners. From some reviews there was a time when either the former owner or the new owners left the restaurant a bit shaky. This was not our experience last night 8/26/24. The front team was working like a well-oiled machine; bread and water served promptly after menus were delivered. The bread was warm and accompanied by butter soft enough to spread. The kitchen seemed to be running just as efficiently as the front. Our food came out quickly, leaving us enough time to savor the bread. The food was hot and delicious. Wait staff were attentive bringing more bread when requested. This is a family run business; dad prepares food and the front is represented by children of his. If you were a loyal Belmonte's customer who was worried about the change of owners, I suggest that you give them another try. They are clearly working hard to offer the best dining experience.“

“The best authentic Italian Food and deserts you ever have, taste and enjoy“

“We've been to Flavia's several times and have always enjoyed our experience. The service is fast and attentive and has it has a super cute modern Italian interior. We always try something new each time we go and haven't been disappointed yet. This time, we had the carbonara spaghetti and pesto fettuccine and it was perfectly al dente and delicious! I can't wait to come back to try the amaretto cheesecake!“

“We loved our dinner at Pasta Volo! You can’t beat the quality of food and speed in which they prepped it. Super friendly staff took time to explain everything on our first visit- big thumbs up from The Fantastic 4!“

“Delicious food and friendly service!“

“Excellent service by Don. We were fortunate to be seated in front corner window which gave us privacy. Every dish ordered was excellent, including dessert. The back room includes a brick oven. Worth the 5 stars I posted!“

“Jimmy's Italian Restaurant is one of those Italian restaurants that falls into the category of 'they just keep getting better', - until they approach the level of perfection, - and then they get even better than that. With all the new trendy restaurants opening in Asbury Park over the last several years, it's incredible that Jimmy's is still such a reliable & consistent choice for great food, great service, and a very civilized ambience. Jimmy's understands the needs of their guests, whether it be a birthday celebration, a marriage proposal, a retirement party, or an important business lunch or dinner, - they always come through flawlessly, assuring that everything goes right. There is not a mistake to be made on the whole menu, from the pizza, to the salads, to the fish, the pasta, the desserts and everything else they serve. Whatever you order is fresh, nicely prepared, and delicious. While fancy enough for any occasion, there is something about Jimmy's that also feels very comfortable & familiar every time you go there. It is a wonderful treat every time, whether it is lunch or dinner, winter or summer, crowded or quiet, - this is what a great restaurant is and is supposed to be.“

“TJ’s is the best is asbury“

“If you are looking to have a small wedding or event I highly recommend. I just got married on Saturday with a headcount of 58 people and I was absolutely blown away with how much "bang for your buck" you get at this venue with an absolutely breath-taking view of the ocean. In addition to all this, the food was insane and our guests were absolutely raving about how good it was. Liz Gloss and her team do an amazing job making you feel special, taken care of, and truly waited on my husband and I hand and foot. The entire staff that day was incredible and it really added to it being so special.“

“Fabulous atmosphere, our food was perfection. We had margarita, pizza, eggplant, Parm, spaghetti, meatball. San Marzano sauce was fabulous. Would definitely come back again thank you Carly you were a great waitress.“

“Naya at Ralph's in Asbury Boardwalk is wonderful. I have brought my special needs camp there for the last 2 years and she has been patient and kind to everyone in our group. It will be an annual trip for us after the Silverball Museum from now on. Congratulations on running a great business. Five stars“

“Food is fantastic! Lots of artisan creations on super delicious bread! We are not vegan or even vegetarian but grab a bite here everytime we are in Asbury Park. Never disappointed!“