Nicholas Creamery

Name: Nicholas Creamery
Address: 1500 NJ-35 unit 19, Middletown, New Jersey, 07748, US
Telephone: (848) 225-3476
Price range: $
Rating: 4.6

$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
1500 NJ-35 unit 19, Middletown
(848) 225-3476

Menu Order Online

About Nicholas Creamery

Nicholas Creamery is a popular spot with multiple locations along the Jersey Shore. The Middletown location is bright and airy, but there is no indoor seating available. The friendly staff serves up delicious ice cream flavors like Vegan Speculoos Cookie and Peanut Butter Palooza. Customers appreciate the generous scoop portions and the variety of toppings offered, which makes it worth the extra cost for this high-end ice cream experience. Their unique flavor of the month creations, including a collaboration with Delicious Orchards, are a must-try.

Visitors consistently praise the quality of the ice cream, noting that it is always excellent. The toppings, especially the hot fudge, are wonderful, providing a perfect ratio when ordered as a sundae. Some reviews mention the need for a more efficient system for sampling flavors and a dedicated line for milkshakes, which could help speed things along during busy times.

One customer shared their experience of craving a hot fudge sundae late at night and being delighted by the array of flavors. They enjoyed Coffee Bourbon Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Palooza, and Mint Chocolate Chunk, describing them as amazing and creamy, with plenty of chocolate chunks. However, they mentioned that for $3, the portion of hot fudge was too small for their sundae, expressing a desire for larger sizes. Overall, Nicholas Creamery continues to impress with its delicious offerings and friendly service.