F.M. Kirby Carriage House at Paper Mill Playhouse
22 Brookside Dr, Millburn
(973) 315-1707
Customers' Favorites
Flourless Chocolate Torte w Pastachios
Smoked Salmon
Duck Breast
Menu
Photos
+50 photos
+49 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The Prefix menu is always delicious. I love how it's themed to the current show. Everything eaten here has been flavorful, fresh, and amazing. The new update has added many seats and a large bar. There are always gluten free options.
We have eaten at the new Carriage House a few times since it recently opened, and have been impressed overall. The food has been consistently good, and the Carriage House is quite lovely. We have tried chicken, fish, and pasta entrees and have enjoyed them all. The overall service is good, but as with most restaurants, they have some very seasoned staff who are excellent, along with some relatively new staff who will benefit from more experience. It is an excellent choice before...
We attended the Golden Girls Murder Mystery and prix fixe dinner tonight for my mom’s birthday. The staff was welcoming and professional from start to finish. Any event as large as this is a feat to pull off, and the Carriage House pulled it off with panache. There was a very small, understandable issue, a late dish, with our order. The manager and staff went above and beyond to correct something so small. The food was excellent, the new facility is beautiful, the show...
You May Also Like
Springbone Kitchen - 321 Millburn Ave
![]()
Soup, Gluten-Free, Health Food
Mariachi Mexican Restaurant - 291 Essex St
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian, Salad, Seafood
Common Lot - 27 Main St
![]()
New American, American, Coffee & Tea, Seafood