Mattarello Bakery & Café
254 Bellevue Ave, Montclair
(973) 337-6275
Customers' Favorites
Lobster Tail Napoleon Rainbow Cake Raspberry Mousse
Ricotta Cheesecake Red Velvet Rum Baba
St Joseph Cream Puffs
Croissant Basket
Pine Nut Cookie
Chocolate Mousse
Tiramisu Large
Cannoli Small
Sfogliatella
Apricot Tart
Pastries & Mousses
Lobster Tail
Sfoglia pastry filled with chantilly cream dipped in chocolate ganache.
Cannoli Small
Crunchy cannoli shells filled with ricotta and chocolate chips and topped with a slice of candied orange.
Sfogliatella Small
Sfoglia pastry filled with ricotta cheese and dried orange.
Croissant
Choose from the following: Butter Croissant, Nutella, Custard Cream or Apricot filled
Donuts (Bombolone)
Custard cream, nutella, raspberry, pistachio, strawberry shortcake italian doughnuts pillow-soft, airy, and amazingly light.
Tiramisu
Mascarpone filling layered with espresso soaked sponge cake and coffee cream, dusted with cocoa powder.
St. Joseph's Cream Puff
Creampuffs
Choose from our selection of cream puffs: custard cream, pistachio cream, hazelnut cream, zabaione cream, chocolate, or chantilly cream.
Mini Mousse Cake
Napoleon
Puff pastry layered with chantilly cream topped with vanilla icing and chocolate.
Baba with Chantilly and Fresh Fruit
Spongecake soaked in rum. regular - chantilly with fresh fruit- nutella.
Chocolate Mousse Cake Large
Ferrero Rocher Mousse Cake
Chocolate Caprese
Gluten free.
Torte Della Nonna
Eclair
Cream puff filled with custard, topped with chocolate ganache.
Fruit Tart
Shortbread cups filled with custard cream and topped with fresh fruit.
Apricot Tart
Nutella Bite
Italian Ricotta Cheesecake Slice
Nutella Tart
Candied Strawberry Cheesecake
Rum Baba with Chantilly Cream and Fresh Fruit Large
Ricotta Cheese & Pear
Gluten Free
Apple Crumble Pie
Macaroons
Set of 12 Gluten Free Macaroons: Chocolate, Raspberry, Vanilla, Salted Caramel, Lemon, Pistachio
Italian Rainbow Small
Carrot Cake Small
NY Cheesecake Small
Chocolate Strawberry Mousse Large
Ricotta Pistachio Cake Small (Gluten Free)
Carrot Cake Large
Pistachio Hazelnut Cheesecake Large
Biscotti & Cookies
Vanilla Biscotti 1 lb
Chocolate Biscotti 1 lb
Amaretti ( Almond Cookies ) 1 lb
Gluten free
Butter Cookies 1 lb
Nut Free
Pignoli Cookies 1 lb
Gluten Free
Mixed Cookies 1 lb
1 Biscotti
1/2 lb Holiday Cookie Sampler Box
1/2 lb holiday cookie sampler.
Mixed Cookie Box 1lb
Red Velvet Cookies
Double Chocolate Chip Cookie
Cakes
Cannoli Cake 8"
Vanilla sponge with a touch of rum layered with cannoli cream, topped with fresh panna and cannoli crunch.
Strawberry Mousse Cake 8"
Strawberry and chocolate mousse with fresh strawberries and a strawberry glaze.
Tiramisu Cake 8"
Mascarpone cream paired with a layer of coffee soaked sponge cake, topped with a light coffee cream and cocoa powder dusting.
Rum Cake 8"
Vanilla sponge cake soaked in rum layered with custard and chocolate Chantilly cream, topped with fresh panna and sliced almonds.
Chocolate Caprese Cake 8"
Gluten free, almond flour chocolate cake dusted in cocoa powder and powdered sugar.
Nocciola Cake 8"
Vanilla sponge with a touch of rum layered with hazelnut cream, Nutella, topped with hazelnut cream and roasted hazelnuts.
Lemon Mousse Cake 8"
Refreshing lemon mousse covered in a lemon glaze.
Fruit Tart Cake 8"
Shortbread crust filled with traditional Italian custard, topped with fresh seasonal fruit.
St. Honore Cake 8"
Millefoglie and chantilly cream, topped with fresh panna and custard filled cream puffs.
NY Cheesecake 8"
New York style cheesecake topped with a raspberry glaze and fresh fruit.
Chocolate Mousse Cake 8"
Chocolate mousse covered in a smooth chocolate glaze.
Profiterol Cake 8"
Chantilly filled cream puffs layered one by one, covered in chocolate and dollops of fresh panna.
Marble Cake 8"
Vanilla sponge cake, chantilly cream
Ricotta Cheesecake 8"
Sweet ricotta and chocolate chip filling inside a shortbread crust
Nutella Pie 8"
Nutella and chocolate chip filling inside a shortbread crust.
Apricot Pie 8"
Apricot filling inside a shortbread crust.
Ferrero Rocher 8" Cake
Sponge Cake layered cake, covered with chocolate ganache and cracked hazelnuts
Ricotta Cheese & Pear 8" Cake (Gluten Free)
Gluten Free
Shortbread layered with fresh pears and ricotta mousse.
Tre Chocolate Mousse 8" Cake
Strawberry & Chocolate Mousse 8" Cake
Pistachio Mousse 8"
Vanilla sponge cake with layers of pistachio mousse, pistachio glaze and fresh pistachio around
Tronchetto / Bouche de Noel
Specialty Coffees
Crokcaffe 16oz
Mokaccino 16oz
Sorrento 16oz
Palermo 16oz
Espresso, frothed milk, gianduia cream, chocolate flakes.
Siciliano 16oz
Cold frothed espresso, whipped cream, hazelnut, chocolate chips.
Coffee, Tea & Hot Chocolate
Draft Latte 16oz
Oat milk draft latte. A creamy coffee-milk drink that is served on tap. It's naturally sweet, with no sugar-added, and it pours out cold and frothy. It's the ultimate iced latte, complete with a head of delicious microfoam.
Draft Cold Brew 16oz
Cold-brewed coffee tastes sweeter and has a thicker and smoother texture than regular coffee. What's more, it's less acidic and higher in caffeine.
Chai Latte 16oz
Black tea infused with cinnamon, clove and other warming spices is combined with steamed milk and topped with foam for the perfect balance of sweet and spicy. An iconic chai cup.
Latte Decaffeinato 16oz
Latte 16oz
Loose Leaf Hot Tea 16oz
Italian Hot Chocolate 16oz
Dense and creamy, nothing says winter in Italy like a rich cup of cioccolata calda – hot chocolate.
Espresso
Mattarello's signature Italian espresso.
Americano 16oz
Cappuccino 16oz
Cappuccino Decaffeinato 16oz
American Coffee 16oz
Mattarello's signature coffee blend.
Macchiato
Cortado
Market
Torroncini
Pure almond, covered with chocolate.
Chocolate Covered Candied Orange Peel
Candied orange peel covered with extra dark chocolate.
Crocquadro
Prized crunchy peanuts covered with extra dark chocolate.
Mattarello Branded Apron
Mattarello Espresso Blend
Nesquik
Prosciutto Croissant
Freshly baked croissant, basil pesto, prosciutto, provolone cheese.
Pasta
Spaghetti, Linguine, Pappardelle, Tagliatelle
Numeral Sparklers
Birthday Sparkler's
Orange juice
S. Pellegrino
Flavored Pellegrino
Coke
Acqua Panna
Orangina
Chobani Yogurt
Olive Oil 500ml
Quiche Of The Day
Cream Of Pistachio
Acacia Honey with Cacao
Swedish Fish Candy
Olive and Pate
Pesto
Abracci Cookies
Amarettini Cookies
Chicche Cookies
Canestrini
Gemme
Baiochi
Pan Di Stelle
Buoni Cosi
Bar Italia Hot Chocolate
Pangri Classici
Marini Amaretti Cookies
Duca Chocolate
Ice Cream - Gelato
Nutella Gelato 1 Pint
Our house made Nutella Gelato
Straciatella Gelato 1 Pint
Our house made gelato
Vanilla Gelato 1 Pint
Our house made gelato
Chocolate Gelato 1 Pint
Our house made gelato
Cherry Gelato 1 Pint
Our house made gelato
Strawberry Gelato 1 Pint
Our house made gelato
Pistachio Gelato 1 Pint
Our house made gelato
Savory Food
Quiche of the Day & Choc Chip Cookie
Quiche of the Day & Macaroons
Quiche of the Day and a box of 12 Macaroons (gluten free, almond flour)
Savory Croissant & Choc Chip Cookie
Photos
+60 photos
+59 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The place is so beautiful, the staff is kind and helpful and the desserts are top tier! I brought some of the cookies and a gounache (however you spell it) to my friend’s house and we devoured them! My friends are still raving about how good they were.
April 2026
This is our go to spot in Montclair. Having been to Italy many times, and having an obsession with pastry, I vet my favorite spots thoroughly. To put it simply, the food is outstanding. After taking home a hazelnut flour cake for my wife’s birthday today, and being blown away, yet again, I had to write a review.
This is to die for, especially since it is gluten free. The owners are also incredibly sweet and kind, and local to Montclair. If you haven’t been...
This is to die for, especially since it is gluten free. The owners are also incredibly sweet and kind, and local to Montclair. If you haven’t been...
March 2026
You May Also Like
Tino's Artisan Pizza Co. - 252 Bellevue Ave
![]()
Italian, Pizza, Vegan
Java Love Coffee Roasting Co - 244 Bellevue Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee Roasteries, Bakery, Coffee
Sparo's Deli and Catering - 197 B Bellevue Ave
![]()
Deli, Italian
My coffee was cold (it was supposed to be) and I had a vegetarian breakfast burrito. The cashier was polite and welcoming. The wifi password was posted clear...