Had a great Sicilian slice with pesto, delicious! Service was down to earth. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric Schroeder
Ok. My wife and I are big foodies. We travel pretty far to try raved about food and have been on the hunt for the best pizza in northern NJ. Sometimes were disappointed when a place is over hyped. This place 100% caught us off guard. Wasnt sure what to expect when we walked in, but we have found it! THE BEST PIZZA in northern NJ. WOW! The fresh ingredients, the sourdough, the fluffy yet crunchy crust. Absolutely MIND BLOWING! Get the Drunken Nonna! Youll thank me later!!! My wife and I were wrestling on the floor fighting over the last piece. We will definitely have some of our events at our custom motorcycle shop catered by them in the future. Ordering 3 pies tomorrow for our employees to enjoy since weve been raving about it to everyone.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Diaz
Pizza was great sauce and cheese taste fresh I had the grandma slice with sausage. Service was good as well. I would eat here again when im in the neighborhood.
CJ Hura
Not only is the pizza fantastic, but the owner was super nice to my young daughter
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
drewzy
Expensive pizza? You get what you pay for. The homemade sourdough crust and peak quality toppings nourish while also being easy to digest. And it's so deliciously savory.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Penrose
Pizza is great if you pick it up but sucks if you want it delivered. They use the Slice App because they're to cheap to hire their own delivery driver. SLICE has to be the worst delivery app on the planet.
Mike Ailinger
Was upset to hear that they won’t do substitutions of pork products (which nearly all protein containing pizzas have some form of) for no charge. When asked if they could swap salami for chicken(a very inexpensive substitute) I was told it would be an extra $7 on an already $30 pie. Not very accommodating for those who don’t eat pork :/
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Nicole P
I heard about this spot from an IG influencer and made my way over the next day and was not disappointed. I did want a slice of Margarita pizza because I’m a plain Jane and I enjoying tasting the basic flavors so I will be back for that but the pizza was delish! A must visit and You won’t be disappointed.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gerardo Sacco
Some of the best pizza you'll get in the area. Seriously order the one with pistachio, no, really, it's one of my favorite pizza pies anywhere!
Food: 5
Kelly A
The pizza was DELICIOUS. I had the pleasure of meeting the owner Joe and we chatted about how he makes his pizza. It feels so great to know the ingredients are fresh, there are no seed oils used, and everything is made in-house. The dough is nice and crunchy on the outside and fluffy in the inside. I used to go to NY to get my fresh pizza al taglio but now I have a place wayyy closer to home 😍 will definitely be coming back! Oh also, I’ve never had artichoke pizza before… but it called my name when I was ordering. I LOVE.
Teglia Pizza Bar in Montclair, NJ is a true gem! They specialize in Roman pan sourdough pizza, crafted with heart right here in Montclair. “Teglia” means roasting pan in Italian, and they absolutely live up to the name with their scratch-made sourdough Roman pan pizzas crispy on the outside, airy on the inside, and packed with flavor. A bonus: you can even go half-and-half to try more of Chef Joseph’s amazing creations. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Assunta Difabio
Stopped in before a show. Pleasantly surprised how delicious it was. The crust was perfect! Ended up with the artichoke spinach square. Definitely recommend it. Small place no sit down tables but a side bar with seats. Nice, friendly owner.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katherine Shereshevsky
Some of the best pizza I've ever had. A diverse array of options (my personal favorite is the buffalo chicken) and very quick service. It's definitely more of a takeout place because of the small interior and limited seating, but it's 100% worth it.
rin
Some of the best pizza I've ever had. A diverse array of options (my personal favorite is the buffalo chicken) and very quick service. It's definitely more of a takeout place because of the small interior and limited seating, but it's 100% worth it.
Had a great Sicilian slice with pesto, delicious! Service was down to earth. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ok. My wife and I are big foodies. We travel pretty far to try raved about food and have been on the hunt for the best pizza in northern NJ. Sometimes were disappointed when a place is over hyped. This place 100% caught us off guard. Wasnt sure what to expect when we walked in, but we have found it! THE BEST PIZZA in northern NJ. WOW! The fresh ingredients, the sourdough, the fluffy yet crunchy crust. Absolutely MIND BLOWING! Get the Drunken Nonna! Youll thank me later!!! My wife and I were wrestling on the floor fighting over the last piece. We will definitely have some of our events at our custom motorcycle shop catered by them in the future. Ordering 3 pies tomorrow for our employees to enjoy since weve been raving about it to everyone.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was great sauce and cheese taste fresh I had the grandma slice with sausage. Service was good as well. I would eat here again when im in the neighborhood.
Not only is the pizza fantastic, but the owner was super nice to my young daughter
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Expensive pizza? You get what you pay for. The homemade sourdough crust and peak quality toppings nourish while also being easy to digest. And it's so deliciously savory.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is great if you pick it up but sucks if you want it delivered. They use the Slice App because they're to cheap to hire their own delivery driver. SLICE has to be the worst delivery app on the planet.
Was upset to hear that they won’t do substitutions of pork products (which nearly all protein containing pizzas have some form of) for no charge. When asked if they could swap salami for chicken(a very inexpensive substitute) I was told it would be an extra $7 on an already $30 pie. Not very accommodating for those who don’t eat pork :/
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
I heard about this spot from an IG influencer and made my way over the next day and was not disappointed. I did want a slice of Margarita pizza because I’m a plain Jane and I enjoying tasting the basic flavors so I will be back for that but the pizza was delish! A must visit and You won’t be disappointed.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Some of the best pizza you'll get in the area. Seriously order the one with pistachio, no, really, it's one of my favorite pizza pies anywhere!
Food: 5
The pizza was DELICIOUS. I had the pleasure of meeting the owner Joe and we chatted about how he makes his pizza. It feels so great to know the ingredients are fresh, there are no seed oils used, and everything is made in-house. The dough is nice and crunchy on the outside and fluffy in the inside. I used to go to NY to get my fresh pizza al taglio but now I have a place wayyy closer to home 😍 will definitely be coming back! Oh also, I’ve never had artichoke pizza before… but it called my name when I was ordering. I LOVE.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Teglia Pizza Bar in Montclair, NJ is a true gem! They specialize in Roman pan sourdough pizza, crafted with heart right here in Montclair. “Teglia” means roasting pan in Italian, and they absolutely live up to the name with their scratch-made sourdough Roman pan pizzas crispy on the outside, airy on the inside, and packed with flavor. A bonus: you can even go half-and-half to try more of Chef Joseph’s amazing creations. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in before a show. Pleasantly surprised how delicious it was.
The crust was perfect!
Ended up with the artichoke spinach square. Definitely recommend it. Small place no sit down tables but a side bar with seats.
Nice, friendly owner.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Some of the best pizza I've ever had. A diverse array of options (my personal favorite is the buffalo chicken) and very quick service. It's definitely more of a takeout place because of the small interior and limited seating, but it's 100% worth it.
Some of the best pizza I've ever had. A diverse array of options (my personal favorite is the buffalo chicken) and very quick service. It's definitely more of a takeout place because of the small interior and limited seating, but it's 100% worth it.
Amazing pizza, super nice owner! Highly recommend
Loading...