Mulberry Street Pizza

$$ • Pizza, Italian, Sandwich Shop

258 Mulberry St, Newark
(973) 596-0275


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Mulberry Street Pizza

We absolutely love the food here. We have never been disappointed with anything we have ordered. It’s all very tasty. The delivery drivers are always considerate and polite and usually on time. The phone and service and times of operation leave a bad taste in our mouth. It’s always a terribly long time from order to delivery (but the food is good and trusted). We also use the app Slice to order. I am guessing that the communication between the app and your full review
This rating has to due with their customer service/delivery. The delivery man refused to bring the food to our door, with no explanation and just kept saying "no" on the phone when asked to come to the 5th floor and then going silent, before repeating no. There was no thought given or question asked if there was an issue with me coming to the lobby- what if I wasn't physically able? It's OK to say No, but please be give me more than No. He eventually said he full review

I went back and forth between ordering the sausage and pepper slice or the Philly cheesesteak slice and ended up going with the sausage and pepper slice. It was as delicious as it looked. I also ordered some garlic knots, which were top notch. Prices were reasonable, service was good, and staff was friendly. I plan on coming back next time I'm in Newark to try that cheesesteak slice.

More Reviews(71)


Monday 10AM - 4PM
Tuesday 10AM - 4PM
Wednesday 10AM - 4PM
Thursday 10AM - 4PM
Friday 10AM - 7:30PM
Saturday 12 - 8PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.