7 Best Bakeries near North Cape May

“I love this place. This is not a tourist place the locals come here. When I'm down this is where I go. Prices are great and the coffee is better than Dunkin' Donuts down the road. The donuts are great. My go to is bagel with cream cheese and a coffee. I don't know why people waste their money and go to a chain like Dunkin or Starbucks instead of support a local spot. The one problem is that its hard to find. It looks closed but it is open. There's a drive thru window but you also can walk in. It's hard to find because Google has the wrong address - says 3718 bayshore, but it's further down. Try 3850 bayshore drive and you'll see it on the corner.“

“Wonderful, wonderful soup and sandwiches! No indoor seating, although picnic tables outside, and only open on weekends. But really great food! Try one of the grilled cheeses (french onion grilled cheese was very good) and the lobster bisque.“

“We had some amazing pastries from Barry’s today, while staying at Wildwood Crest. I recommend them if you are looking for something extremely delicious and unique. They have something for everyone. Chocolate chip, bars, chocolate covered waffles, buns, etc.“

“A hidden gem!!!! Everything is made fresh and ingredients are basically farm to table from Beach Plum Farms. The bakery has some of the best pastries you’ll ever have. No joke. You have to try the pumpkin chocolate chip bread when it’s in season or literally ANY baked good. I have never been disappointed. The coffee is delicious, rich and they even have a La Colombe draft latte!! On top of that, the employees and bakers are heartwarmingly generous. Can’t say enough good things about this place. This is my absolute favorite café.Dietary restrictions: They often have gluten free muffins or brownies!Wheelchair accessibility: There are tables outside in the summer to easily pull a wheelchair up to.“

“Went in to try one of the advertised breakfast bowel and was glad I did. Very helpful and friendly staff . My legs aren't the best and she told me that she would walk it out t9 me if I wanted to rest feet.. THANK YOU. And kudos to Bayshore bagel for hiring such ge lonely ice employees Best of luck“

“I bought this one to hold me over until my favorite cappuccino peanut butter was back in stocks! As always the Cape May Peanut Butter Company never disappoints! I even place online orders throughout the year because it would cost more than tolls and gas to get down so in between vacations, I place orders online! I have never tasted a bad batch in the store and my dog absolutely LOVES their peanut butter dog treats!“

“I had ordered a 50th anniversary cake for my parents anniversary party and Chef Michel exceeded my expectations. Not only was the cake absolutely delicious, but it was beautiful! I had ordered the dark chocolate cake with peanut butter ribbon filing and buttercream icing. It wasn’t too sweet and the cake was extremely moist. I sent him a photo (3rd photo) as my inspiration and he nailed it. Florals were provided by Karin with Blooms. Thank you!“