24 Best American Restaurants near Peapack

“Ninety Acres at Natirar is a renowned restaurant that offers an exceptional dining experience. The beautiful setting, delectable cuisine, and outstanding service create a memorable occasion for guests. The restaurant's commitment to using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients is evident in the unique and flavorful dishes featured on the menu, including a popular 4-course tasting prix fixe option. Visitors consistently praise the warm welcome, attentive staff, and relaxed atmosphere, making Ninety Acres an ideal choice for special celebrations and gatherings.“

“Gabriel’s Fountain offers delicious ice cream with a variety of flavors that are worth the wait. The restaurant also serves juicy burgers, salads, and generous portions of sides. Customers praise the unique ice cream flavors and the quality of the food. Parking is available in the back with some difficulty in exiting during busy times. The restaurant has character and is a local favorite for its tasty meals and heaping scoops of ice cream. Overall, Gabriel’s Fountain is a wonderful spot to enjoy flavorful food and delightful ice cream.“

“Stoney Brook Grille is a local spot that offers a friendly and inviting atmosphere. The food is described as very good, though the portions may be a bit light. The service is noted as very friendly, but the noise level can make it challenging to have a conversation. The restaurant features a nice ambiance, with occasional live music that adds to the overall vibe. While the food is not considered amazing, it is still very good and makes for an enjoyable dining experience. The menu includes options like a delightful bruschetta and a tasty jambalaya dish. In addition to the food and atmosphere, Stoney Brook Grille is praised for its excellent happy hour and even free bingo on Tuesdays with prizes. The bartenders are also commended for their attentiveness and skill in crafting excellent cocktails, such as the delightful brown sugar old fashioned. Overall, Stoney Brook Grille is a great local spot that provides a memorable and affordable dining experience, with friendly service, a nice ambiance, and a menu that offers very good food options.“

“Pendry Natirar is a renowned restaurant known for its excellent service and delectable cuisine. The establishment boasts a stunning scenic view of the valley, particularly during the fall season. Visitors have praised the high-end atmosphere and the wide range of appetizers and full-course meals offered. The venue is also renowned for hosting magnificent weddings, with its historic mansion, beautiful views, and dedicated staff providing a truly unique experience for couples.“

“Chimney Rock Inn is a must-try restaurant with fast and accurate service. The staff is friendly, the portions are large, and the food is tasty and fresh. They offer a variety of options including burgers, ribs, thin crust pizza, and gluten-free choices. Dining at the bar provides a chance for interesting conversations. A great spot for a casual meal with reasonable prices.“

“DIG is a restaurant that offers fresh and natural food, providing healthy choices for those with dietary restrictions. The depth of flavor in their dishes encourages loyalty, and their presentation is described as beautiful. The house salad with crispy chicken and pesto dressing, as well as their vegan options, are particularly praised. The staff, including Arnie and Nikita, are noted for their friendliness and excellent recommendations. The restaurant's carrots, sweet potatoes, and cashew Caesar dressing have also received high praise. Overall, DIG is a clean, healthy, and delicious dining option with a welcoming atmosphere and enthusiastic staff.“

“The Pluckemin Inn offers an exceptional dining experience just off 287. The menu is meat-forward, but the chefs can accommodate vegetarian requests. The cocktail selection is sublime, and the wine list is extensive. Vegetable sides are cooked to perfection, and fresh bread is served while you wait. The elegant atmosphere is perfect for special occasions, and the restaurant also welcomes casual diners. With plenty of parking and outdoor spaces, The Pluckemin Inn is suitable for both dining and events.“

“Gladstone Tavern offers a great dining experience with attentive and friendly staff. Enjoy their excellent cheese board, burgers, and outdoor patio with plenty of space. While prices may be steep, the atmosphere and service make up for it, with a skilled bartender crafting killer drinks.“

“Butler's Pantry Trackside is a beloved local restaurant located in a charming old train station. It offers a delectable menu, including customer favorites like bacon cheeseburgers and the sought-after chocolate chip cookie pie. The restaurant is known for its generous portions, fresh and tasty food, and friendly staff, though service can be slow during busy periods. Whether you're craving breakfast, lunch, or dinner, Butler's Pantry Trackside provides a unique dining experience in a tranquil, if somewhat noisy, setting.“

“Gladstone Market is a hidden gem that offers a delightful dining experience. The food is consistently delicious, with fresh, farm-sourced ingredients and daily specials. The service is excellent, with attentive staff ensuring the best experience for every guest. The restaurant's charming patio overlooking the Raritan river headwaters creates an enchanting atmosphere. Gladstone Market caters to various dietary needs, including a highly praised vegan pad Thai, and is also kid-friendly, with staff catering to the needs of diners of all ages. This wonderful establishment is a must-try for anyone in the area.“

“The Tewksbury Inn is a welcoming spot that feels like a neighborhood gathering place. The bartenders are friendly, and the atmosphere is reminiscent of Cheers. The menu features delicious options like French onion soup, fish and chips, and amazing burgers. While the restaurant tends to prioritize its regular locals, visitors can still enjoy a great meal and drinks, including Sunken Silo IPA on tap. Despite some inconsistencies in service, the Inn's warm atmosphere and tasty food make it a great spot to visit.“

“Washington House Restaurant offers outstanding service and consistently delicious food. Whether you enjoy a Blackened Pork Chop or a Tuna Poke Bowl, the meals are perfect. The oysters are fresh, the gazpacho is chilled to perfection, and the desserts are exactly as they should be. The outdoor dining space is beautiful and welcoming, with a nice atmosphere under the tent. During special events like their anniversary, they offer great deals like $1 oysters. From the bar to the dining areas, the staff, including Armando, provides impeccable service, making sure everyone has the best possible experience. With a menu that has something for everyone, Washington House Restaurant is well-run, immaculate, and a favorite spot for many.“

“Millington Station Cafe is a charming old train station-turned-cafe, offering a nostalgic dining experience. The menu features classic dishes like French toast deluxe and Greek salad, with fresh ingredients and attentive service. The cozy ambiance is enhanced by the cafe's unique location, making it a delightful destination for both families and solo diners.“

“Tommy's Tavern + Tap is a clean and stylish restaurant with a wide range of food options and reasonably priced drinks. The establishment offers a pleasant atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for families or groups of friends. The menu features a variety of dishes, including burgers, flatbreads, and salads, while the bar offers a selection of drinks, including half-off deals on certain occasions.“

“Redwoods Grill & Bar offers a variety of delicious dishes, including a standout pork chop for Sunday lunch and a well-liked salmon entree. The Monday special has been praised, and the Chef's Tasting Menu provides a complete dining experience with salad, entrée, and dessert. The outdoor setting is pleasant, and the service is attentive. Some may prefer less carrots in the Thai noodles. The bar area is also a nice option for dining. Drinks, such as tap water and wine, are available. Overall, Redwoods Grill & Bar is a high-quality dining establishment.“

“Delicious Heights offers wonderful food and drinks with excellent service. While the noise level could be improved, the restaurant has a great ambience. Regular customers love the friendly staff and great drink options, but some miss the hot honey pizza that was removed from the menu. The restaurant has separate dining and bar areas, as well as a banquet room, with a variety of seating options. It can get busy in the evenings with golfers and corporate groups, but there is ample parking available. Delicious Heights is family-friendly, with private booths in the dining room and wheelchair accessibility through a ramp at the back entrance.“

“My stay at Delta Hotels by Marriott Basking Ridge was delightful, but the true gem was their restaurant! Forget overpriced hotel dining - this spot offered delicious, affordable dishes that surpassed any outside option. From the serene atmosphere (thanks to the smaller crowd) to the attentive service and delicious food, every aspect impressed. The hot buffet breakfast was a lifesaver - delicious, varied, and budget-friendly. Skip the tourist traps and treat yourself to this hidden gem. Your taste buds will thank you!“

“Sally Lunn's Restaurant & Tearoom is a charming destination that offers a delightful experience for tea lovers. The restaurant serves a wide selection of lovely teas and features a variety of delicious dishes, including the popular chicken pot pie. The pastry is freshly made in-house, and there are many vegetarian options to choose from. The staff is wonderfully friendly and helpful, with attentive service from hosts and servers. While the afternoon tea portions may be small, the food is fantastic, and the atmosphere is beautiful.“

“Time to Eat Diner is a long-standing breakfast and dinner spot with a variety of menu options. The restaurant has a good atmosphere and friendly employees, making it a great place for families to dine. They offer dishes from Greek, Mexican, Italian, Polish cuisines, and more. The portions, especially for children, are generous. The service is quick and efficient, with plenty of seating and parking available. Customers praise the delicious coffee and recommend trying the eggs over easy with pork sausage and potatoes, with options for different types of sausage and potato styles. Overall, Time to Eat Diner is considered one of the best diners in NJ for its top-notch food, service, and ambiance.“

“Grain House is a casual restaurant open 7 days a week with consistently good quality food and portions. The warm and inviting ambience in the "pub" room makes it a favorite spot for many. However, some customers have experienced a decline in service quality over the years, with long wait times and mix-ups with orders. The Cobb salad was tasty but lacking in components for the price. The noise level in the restaurant doesn't match the decor, but it's generally busy. Despite some service issues, the food and service provided by the bartender were excellent during one visit.“

“Redstone American Grill serves flavorful food with beautiful plating, and the staff is warm and accommodating, particularly with food allergies. The braised beef short rib is a highlight, served with a flavorful jus. Portion sizes are generous, and the patio seating is a great option. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, with vegetarian options available, although dairy-free options may be limited.“

“Seasons 52 is a renowned restaurant that consistently delivers an exceptional dining experience. From the moment guests arrive, the impeccable service and attentive staff ensure a memorable occasion. The menu offers a diverse selection of expertly prepared dishes, including the well-received filet mignon, which is cooked to perfection. The serene ambiance of the establishment creates a relaxing atmosphere, perfect for celebrations and gatherings. Whether it's a special event or a casual outing, Seasons 52 consistently exceeds expectations and provides a truly remarkable culinary journey.“

“The Claremont Tavern is a consistent high-quality spot for food, drinks, and service. The menu boasts must-try items like the chicken sausage soup, packed with meat, and the epic Claremont burger with amazing onion rings. The pub atmosphere is cozy and casual, with a great selection of beers and fresh salads. The backyard patio, open on nice summer nights, adds a unique touch. While parking can be limited, the excellent value and gourmet-style food make it a local gem worth supporting. With highchairs and a kids' menu available, it's also a great spot for families.“

“22 West Tap And Grill offers a lively atmosphere with weekly themed trivia nights, live music on weekends, and a diverse menu featuring daily specials. Customers praise the exceptional service, delectable build-your-own burgers, and flavorful dishes like the Cherry Pepper Wings and Short Red Bolognese. This well-run establishment has become a local favorite for a great dining experience.“