50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pitman

“Ordered Rustica and was not disappointed. Pizza crust was perfect, crispy, and amazing. The best Tiramisu I have ever had. I was also able to order a bottle from local winery. I enjoyed watching them prepare the food also. It was like dinner and a show.“

“Food arrived hot and was delicious.Sunday's delivery guy was friendly and very polite.Would order from there again.“

“It’s wild that I am just now reviewing Attilio’s Pizza! They are truly a staple piece in Pitman. Just a classic pizzeria! I love getting slices or candy to go as well dining in with my boyfriend. We can enjoy great food and people watch. It’s cozy as hell. I would choose Attilio’s any day over the “fancier” restaurants in town. Prices are totally affordable. Food is so good. I could go on & on about how amazing the sicillian pizza is, oh my god I’m actually obsessed. I also appreciate seeing kids have a place to go & grab a bite. What a dream, I would’ve killed to have a pizza place within walking distance that I could hit up with my friends as a kid/teen. Awesome place, awesome ownership, awesome workers, awesome food. Well done!“

“We stopped in for a bite. The Vegetarian Sandwich & The Chicken Vero Sandwich, both on Vero's bread were outstandingly delicious.“

“My Favorite place to eat. know the owner since he bought the place from Papi.“

“Best Panzerotti and Pizza in NJ... Food is ALWAYS Hot and Delicious! Service is ALWAYS on point! The Atmosphere is welcoming to one and all! Sal, the owner, is an outstanding guy! Thank you Topo Gigio... Will be back again Very Soon! 😎👍🇺🇸

Parking: Family run and owned.

Kid-friendliness: Family and Kid Friendly!

Wheelchair accessibility: Disabilities accessible 😎👍🇺🇸♿️“

“Dynamite thin crust pizza top notch Key lime pie 14 on a one to ten“

“Excellent panzerotti“

“Good food, friendly people“

“great pizza and great owners“

“We enjoyed our first dinner at Santini’s last night. It was very very good. 👍👍 Loved the salad bar and our entree choices. The staff were very friendly and accommodating. Menu was reasonably priced. Can’t wait to go back. You need to give it a try, you won’t be disappointed. ❤️❤️“

“Staff/owners kind. Evev gave me a $10 GC. My first time visiting this establishment and will definitely return. Everything my family ordered seemed freahly made, full of flavor, and exactly as described- shrimp quesadilla filled with shrimp. Giant Burger seasoned well. Champions salad with the works olives, onions, walnuts...added grilled chicken- perfection.“

“you guy did my sons law school graduation party's Saturday with the rain and all . the guy guys were excellent and the pizza was great THANK-YOU“

“We’ve had pizza a few times since they opened (which comes with delicious homemade soup) so we decided to go for the grand opening event to sample some other dishes. The food was great and the staff very friendly. Highly recommended.“

“Amazing pizza and the BEST service!! Every time we’re in the area, we are sure to stop by!!“

“Absolutely incredible customer service from the staff. The food was amazing. Definitely will be returning and telling my buddies about this spot!!!“

“Excellent pizza! Great staff.“

“Went for the first time last night, it’s been on the “todo” list for a while. This place is clean, not overpriced at all, and the staff is incredibly friendly. The food was quite delicious as well. The wait for food was a little bit, but who cares when your little people are playing on the pirate ship.“

“Everything was excellent the two guys had amazing energy“

“We recently moved to the williamstown area and had a hard time finding a pizza place until we came across Tuscan Pizza. They are fantastic and amazing customer service. We asked for paper plates the one time, the driver left without them but received a call from Tuscan apologized for this and said they sent another driver by to deliver the plates. They literally arrived minutes late almost the exact same time as the pizza. This is just a small sample of their service. Top notch and amazing pizza!“

“Love the bar. Great food and service, but the Techno music is is annoying!“

“The ONLY pizza place we order from. They are simply the best! Whether we’re eating in or grabbing take out, the staff here are so friendly and accommodating. Just today, I mistakenly ordered the wrong pizza online and when I realized the mistake, they immediately offered to make a new one for me, free of charge. Great customer service and great food!“

“My boyfriend ordered us pizzas and wings from their specials list and everything came delicious and with amazing service
Our fries were accidentally left at the restaurant and they did not hesitate to deliver them to us. What a wonderful company. Thank you so much for your hospitality and service! We will be enjoying your food again! 10 out of 10 definitely recommend!“

“Just ordered first time since moving here… they are fantastic! Fresh food, delicious, like you’re in your mom’s kitchen! The roast pork and broccoli rabe, omg!!! I called to tell them how awesome it was! Very nice young man delivered and even nicer manager, Nicky. We will make them our go to place and please try them, you will be very satisfied ! Outstanding food and service!“

“Benny's not only has amazing pizza and dinners... the triple cheesesteak is the best Cheesesteak around! Also, the people who work there couldn't be nicer!! Highly recommend!!“

“The food was different. Highly recommend the Buffalo chicken cheese steak.“

“I am obsessed with Gallery Pizza! Ever since I moved to south jersey I was scouting for the best local pizza joint and I am so happy I found Gallery. Every single order is done perfectly, fresh, hot, and on time! All the staff are very kind and attentive. The pizza is amazing! We have tried so many different items here and enjoy every last bite! Keep up the amazing work, this is definitely the best pizza in the area! 5 stars all around and you are missing out if you dont come here.“

“Its Sals Pizza, the best pizza in south jersey. Id argue the best pizza in the tri-state area. But thats for a specific pizza, the comfort pizza. That old school floppy, glorious cheese pull, thin crust goodness. They've been belting out since I was a kid. High quality ingredients produces high quality results. Pricing is a couple bucks more than the half dozen competitors in the area and they dont deliver. But just makes them the perfect comfort food pizza. By the time you've had 2 or 3 other places pizzas, you remember why Sals is your go to for that slice of happiness. Incidentally they have my 2nd favorite cheese fry. So odd that theyre one of the only places to use shoe string, slighly under cooked, for those amazing floppy fries me and mine love so much! Apparently im really into floppy foods im just realizing.“

“I've had dinner here twice, excellent Italian food. It's not just a pizza place and the prices are reasonable too!“

“Our company recently moved to a new location, so we’ve been trying out different Italian and pizza spots nearby. After seeing a few great reviews, we decided to take a chance on Paradise for our Thanksgiving luncheon — and we’re so glad we did. We got lasagna, stuffed shells, chicken parm, and cannolis, and everything was gone within 20 minutes. The sauce was incredible, the chicken was tender, and the cannoli filling was perfectly balanced. Our team couldn’t stop talking about how good everything was. I’ve seen a few reviews saying it’s overpriced, but I couldn’t disagree more. The cost per tray was more than fair — and let’s be honest, everything costs more now. Mom-and-pop shops don’t have much wiggle room on pricing, and the quality here absolutely justified the cost. One of the owners, Linda, went above and beyond to make sure we had an amazing first experience with them. We’ll absolutely be ordering from them again. Great people and great food — and it’s rare to find a place that nails both. Linda & staff — thank you for the incredible food and outstanding customer service!“

“Just picked up 2 dinners and a Med pizza, the med pizza ticket didnt get printed, said will be 6-8 min. They said “you know what get him a lg and on his way” They were busy with the Deptford Spartan Marching Band fund raiser. Great customer service!! Ken S“

“Excellent food and always great service whether I eat there or take out.“

“YOUR BOARDWALK PIZZA👍👌😋IS THE ABSOLUTE BEST!! Delicious💥 I drive from Pa and there is NOTHING AROUND LIKE THIS!! So good!“

“The pizza is out of this world good. We usually order a Sicilian or a regular large Pie.“

“Everything we have ordered has been fabulous. My personal favorite are the homemade soups--they are my go to dinner on a busy night or a chilly day. I felt under the weather today and ordered the chicken orzo soup. It came piping hot with warm fresh rolls....just what I needed! And of course...finish off with a cannoli!“

“We’ve been ordering from Carosello’s since we moved to Runnemede 20 yrs ago. Tonight was the first time ordering a Margherita pizza. It was delicious, I had to write this review. It had a good amount of fresh tomato sauce & cheese, the crust was so crispy, cooked perfectly. Definitely my new favorite.“

“the best in the business 🍕“

“We stopped in for dinner and drinks.. They Did Not Disappoint! The customer service was amazing! We had Emily and she was super sweet, she keep checking to make sure we were okay and just made everything even more awesome. Our food .... I wanted to go back the next day! It was absolutely delicious. The appetizers just were the roll of red carpet greatness! Everything tasted great and left you wanting more. Everything has the fire grilled taste, and we had leftovers! I loved the drink menu! They had seasonal drinks and a bunch of cool cocktail drinks to order, i tried a few and they were all really good! But there is something about their espresso martini.... lol give me another! The bartender was on point!! Didn't get his name but I hope he's making my drinks when I get back there!“

“Another trucker review here. If you’re staying at the TA across the street for the day or resetting this is definitely a nice place to hit up. Food was good and so was the beer (and I’m not a huge beer person honestly). Prices are pretty average compared to larger establishments like BJ’s Brewhouse. Bartender was friendly and did a good job keeping up with checking on everyone at the bar regularly. If I ever wind up back at the TA across the street for a reset I’m definitely coming back.“

“Delicious Food Wonderful staff“

“Everything I’ve gotten there has been delicious. My favorite is chicken cutlet with long hots and sharpe provolone on a seeded roll, which isn’t on the menu but they will make for you. Also the breakfast sandwiches are the best around, nobody comes close.“

“Always a good meal at Select! From their wings to their cheesesteaks to their lettuce wraps to their other sandwiches, we have not had a bad meal here so far.

I would really like their ordering system to be a little more robust to accept things like notes on a particular sandwich or extra meat or some things like that“

“I typically order the Detroit style pizza, which is always fantastic from the sauce to the crust to the caramelized cheese edge- never disappoints! But, I have to throw the limelight of this review onto their cheesesteaks. All I can say is, “WOW!” I ordered the cheesesteak on their homemade, sesame seeded sub roll with cooper sharp, fried onions, and banana peppers. The meat, cheese, and veggies were spectacular (all in more than generous proportions), but that roll stole the show!!! I am a huge bread snob, and I cannot get over how great the bread is (flavorful dough, airy inside, crust baked perfectly, and enough seeds to happily feed a small village). I gotta give this family a ton of credit- they have carbs, among other things of course, figured out!!! Also, you should follow them on your favorite social media platform- the family is hilarious.“

“I love ordering their Italian hoagie. I’ve be in West Deptford for 17 years and Vinny’s hoagies are the best in West Deptford.“

“The food was bad and sentient. Took me weeks to get and finish the food. The 4th floor was dirty and 5th was spooky, Italian man running through, with giant rats. At the top there was a laser thing and a face made of pizza. It was very weird but I loved the experience. 10/10 would recommend best indie restaurant“

“We love little Sicily, we have ordered many pizzas, cheese steaks and I love love their steak fries (well done) and they have proper wiz. Gus also cares about the community and always sponsors the little League. Keep up the great work!“

“food here is so ....v2 the grill chicken with pesto arugula and fresh mozzarella is my favorite....people have said the workers are rude however I think they are just misunderstood....they are very nice people ...I think because they are Italian with accents people mistake them for being rude... they work very hard and provide great food“

“I had a menu in my mail from this place and decided to try them. I'm really glad I did. I ordered two cheese steaks and two orders of cheese fries. The cheesesteaks were very full of meat and the serving size of the french fries could have fed three people! Delivery was fast, food was hot and delicious.“

“Very delicious 😋 pizza and chicken sandwich“

“I want to begin by saying the food is consistently great here and every delivery driver I have had was prompt and courteous.

Today when I ordered I was brought the wrong pizza by mistake. I called and the man who answered the phone was polite and courteous. He apologized for the mistake and said a replacement pizza was on its way. It arrived promptly and much to my surprise included a complimentary order of garlic knots. I didn’t expect anything from them except a new pizza. They went above and beyond and will continue to get my business.“