25 Best Diners near Pompton Plains

“We went off peak time ... 200 PM ... so it wasn't crowded. The service was excellent. I had a delicious veggie omelet and my home fries were well done and crispy the way I requested. And it was less expensive than other diners. And same price cash or credit.“

“they are very nice the food is delicious so much food I have to take it home“

“Absolutely the best food and service in town!“

“Great food, even better service! Highly recommend!“

“Great burgers, great prices! Our new “go to” diner!“

“This place makes a great breakfast. Coffee was good and fresh. Friendly staff. Looking forward to trying lunch.“

“This diner is worth going. We do not live in NJ but we stop in on the way back from NYC. The food is delicious, the service is spot on. The owners are very welcoming. Keep it going Caldwell Diner!“

“This place is small and cozy, its owners make you feel very comfortable, the breakfast is delicious.
I love this place, I would return without hesitation.
Recommended a thousand by a thousand

Parking: Few parking spaces“

“Excellent service, scrumptious dessert selection, and great menu. The dinner specials were excellent. Lots of delicious options for vegetarians!“

“The food is always good and the staff is great! Gus and his cooks do a great job!“

“Last night, my party and I had an extraordinary dining experience at Oakland Diner. The food was absolutely fantastic, and our waitress, Nicole, truly elevated our evening with her exceptional service. Not only was she incredibly sweet, but she also demonstrated unparalleled attentiveness throughout our meal. From promptly fulfilling our requests for extra napkins to ensuring our glasses were never empty, Nicole went above and beyond to ensure our satisfaction. Thanks to her warm demeanor and impeccable service, our dinner was nothing short of amazing. We are already looking forward to returning, knowing that Nicole will make our next visit just as memorable. She is undoubtedly an asset to the team and deserves all the praise!!“

“great service cozy little dinner vibe amazing food much love from Portland Oregon“

“I had a fantastic experience at this place. Diego provided excellent service and he made an excellent cappuccino. The food was delicious, and the smell in the restaurant was wonderful. It smelled of sweet pastries and cookies. My only complaint is that the AC wasn’t on, so I was pretty hot. Everything else was perfect though.“

“Great food, fast service. Been coming here for years. Don’t mind the 80’s music but they have it CRANKED. Came in for breakfast and couldn’t even have a conversation with my wife as Journey played in the background.“

“The best chicken pot pies in New Jersey and New York.The food is quality and large portions.The staff is friendly and accommodating. The other thing is the price for what you get is incredible.“

“I recently visited the newly revamped “3 Stone Family Diner.” The staff seemed to really have a “family” dynamic. My food was also great. Though a cheeseburger and fries is a simple meal, the chef truly amplified it. My dessert also proved that 3 Stone Family Diner implores a delicious motif. I had a wonderful slice of cheesecake, dulcified with a blueberry spread. I felt as if everything was fairly priced. One can see how the new owners are positively changing the place. I loved the updates, and have high hopes for the future. Kudos to the staff and owners! Keep it up!“

“We love coming here. We have tried many diners and by far this has been the best. We have already been here 3 times. I have tried something different every time and have not been disappointed. Angela is the sweetest waitress and I love how she remembered us. And her recommendations are always perfect. Always bring food home. We have a new favorite diner and will be here hopefully more. We live in Garfield, but it is worth the trip. Thank you for great food and especially the best service.“

“If it were up to my children, we would be eating at the Hillary Street restaurant and Grill every single day. We love it here, and the staff is the kindest and friendly as ever. The food is always absolutely delicious. Five stars from us.“

“food was great and service was awsome !!“

“Food was very good, portions and pricing are also great!
The atmosphere is also interesting and nice!
Unfortunately, they forgot the salad that was supposed to come with the chicken sandwich I had gotten. I just got 3 bags of balsamic vinaigrette dressing and no salad.“

“A++++ Staff was very friendly, helpful and accomodating. Place was clean and very nicely decorated. The best fruit bowl I’ve had. Oatmeal was a 10. First time and I can’t wait to go back.“

“I went to the Allwood Diner recently with my friend and ordered a Greek salad with grilled chicken. My friend ordered a crispy chicken sandwich with fries. My meal was delicious and it was a big portion. My friend, however, did not enjoy her meal because the crispy chicken was just lukewarm and felt as if it was placed in a microwave after being frozen. Also, she got a small portion of fries compared to what other patrons who ordered fries had on their plate.“

“We used to go to Park West quite often, but stopped when we were tired of having to check the bill carefully for overcharging. Happened again yesterday when we called in a pick up and 2 of the 3 items ordered were wrong and the wrong higher price was still charged. And, we didn't get two items we ordered, nor the coleslaw and pickle that was requested. Not happy at all“

“My mom and sisters and I had a great experience! Food was great and the staff was very kind and helpful! Especially Bulbul, Georgio, and Julie thank you!“

“Was a great morning at Montclair Diner. Enjoyed the last day of summer Jazz and a lively brunch and enjoyed the sultry, soothing voice of Ms. Jacque Johnson and the band that accompanied her. I met the owner Elliot, who was very warm and welcoming. A great experience all around.“