50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pompton Plains

“My wife and I met friends for dinner at Pizza Man. Pizza Man is a casual BYOB store front Italian and pizza restaurant. The atmosphere is cozy and warm and the menu is quite extensive. There are many options that include soups, salads, appetizers, veal, chicken, seafood, pasta and pizza. We began by sharing a very good antipasto. It was large and packed with generous amounts of meats, cheeses, peppers, eggplant, tomatoes, olives and greens. For entrees we chose the pasta festival, chicken piccata, veal piccata and the chicken francese. All entrees were served over pasta. The pasta festival was in a brandy sauce with shrimp, chicken and bowtie pasta. Portions were large and we all brought home enough for another meal. We finished with delicious cannolis and tiramisu for dessert. Pizza Man offers very good Italian food in a comfortable setting.“

“We have been coming here for years! Love the service, the food and the ambiance ♥️“

“We got food from them the other day and everyone in my family loved it. We ordered margarita pizza and my kids said it was the best they ever had. The baked manicotti was really good. The broccoli and cheese calzone was amazing, especially when dipped into the sauce. The Mac and cheese balls were delicious. The fries for me were a little too salty, but everyone else said they tasted really good. Can’t wait to be in their area again so we can order more food from them.“

“Tried familia pizzeria for the first time. Did not disappoint! Food was absolutely fantastic and the service was excellent! Highly recommend this spot!“

“Food was amazing, 2 types of pizza, best garlic knots on Earth. Delivery was fast. No where as good around here.“

“Attended a baby shower. The food was the best I have ever had in a long time. Everything was delicious. I will be back really soon“

“Customer service was excellent, made sure to tell us what pizza was in the oven when we didn’t see the options we wanted out. Made sure to show us what coupons were available and also the food was delicious! I highly recommenced the bbq chicken“

“I just hope my review gets posted I'm not the one that normally post reviews but I have to do it here I'm the type of guy that not easy to be satisfied when searching for good pizza but oh my God this pizza is unbelievably tasty I was in this part of the state almost gave up on ordering pizza from places but I decided to take a chance people that are traveling through this area like me try this pizza I promise you will be telling others and by the way the person on the phone very polite and professional thank you!!!!“

“I ordered half tray of mini arancini balls for Christmas appetizer and my guests and family loved them. it was so good, and even made them as requested without beef inside. we love their pizzas in the past. thank you PBP for great service and Quality.“

“We’ve been coming to Celestino for dinner regularly, and it never disappoints. The food is always amazing, fresh, and perfectly prepared. The staff is incredibly friendly, welcoming, and attentive. We always have a great experience and look forward to coming back!“

“I love the spinach pockets they make.“

“Great food and customer service“

“Great food, friendly people“

“Greatest Pizza on Earth!!“

“Great staff. Excellent calzones. Generous with portions. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Delicious food“

“The best Pizza in town ! Family owned and very friendly and kind people!“

“I get delivery from them and they’re always fast and have the best pizza in Ringwood. The other places aren’t bad and no disrespect to them but this is my go to place. They have a great selection of gourmet pizzas too. The online system is also super convenient and the delivery is always fast and the driver friendly. I’ve had friend rave about how my parties have the best pizza and its thanks to Luigi’s.“

“Great happy hour selections! We enjoyed our bar pies (2 for the price of 1) and espresso martinis. The staff were very attentive and friendly. It's close to the Willowbrook Mall, and significantly less expensive than the food and drink options you'll find there. Good place to decompress after a hard day at work or a hard day of shopping at the mall!“

“We moved to Clifton a couple of months ago and have been trying different pizza places until we found the perfect one. We have not tried the pizza however the meatball parm and the chicken parm heros are the BEST i have ever gotten in any pizza place. Highly recommender this place“

“Stopped here (while traveling on 287 (exit 45)) for lunch. The food was absolutely delicious! The staff were friendly and welcoming. We ordered pizza and the godfather panini. Everything was fresh and super flavorful. Only complaint is that we live too far to visit more frequently. Will definitely be back again when we are in the area.“

“The man is an artist. The thin, thin pie .👍“

“When an owner like Donny is devoted to his business and truly concerned about quality, the result brings more than satisfied “repeat” customers! Congrats on bringing quality delights to the community! See you soon... Stan Jaffe“

“Love the chicken parm & drunken grandma pie! BUT now I just had the apple Turnovers..omg delicious!!! even yummy heated next day. Not doughy..light and airy.😋“

“Was in town for work last night. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza. Best pizza I had in a long time. Super fast delivery. Friendly delivery guy. Came with plates and napkins too! When back in the area, I’ll hit y’all up again.“

“Food is amazingly fresh and delicious and service is great 👍😋“

“Checked out Krios Prime last night and now I see why everyone’s talking about it. Beautiful space, great energy. The octopus was delicious, the salmon was fresh with an amazing sauce, and the homemade baklava was unreal. Highly recommend. 😋🔥“

“I went to Wayne Ale House and Pizza last night with a group of eight, and we had a great time. The service was attentive, the food was amazing, and everything came out smoothly despite our larger group. Our waitress, Natalie, was especially fun and a pleasure to be around—she really made the experience even better. I would definitely recommend this place!“

“Wonderful meal at popolari tonight - our first time there. Food was excellent, servers were outstanding - pleasant and professional. Sitting out front on a balmy night with music playing and a great meal was a great way to end the week.“

“I work across the street in Mattress Firm, I went in Famous Ray’s for the first time today. I have to say this is some of the best pizza I have had in New Jersey. I’m from the Bronx and its a challenge to find good pizza in NJ. I live in Rahway and I would travel the 30 minutes to Famous Rays when I want pizza from now on! Nice crew in there too! I recommend the Margarita Slice.“

“I ordered from my job once in a while and don't have time to call. Their online ordering system is amazing and you can write any note and they will actually read it and do what you need. I had a problem months ago and the owner actually called me and spoke with me. She was a very nice lady and the reason I haven't nixed the place. Food is delicious 😊 5 stars always!“

“There's a reason why this place is named Spinachio. GET THE SPINACHIO PIZZA!!! We got a mosaic pie so we could try a few different options, spinachio being one. The drunken grandma pie was also delicious. Saw another review that recommended the cheesesteak stromboli and I will be forever grateful for that suggestion, because it was incredible. I'll definitely be back!“

“Buonasera is our go to place to eat! It's great to bring friends to, great to have a date night, great for girls or guys night, just super great! The food is FANTASTIC! After going there for years and really enjoying everything my new crave is the Caprese Tower and the Calamari and Shrimp Fra Devraj. Although honestly, you can't go wrong with anything. Did I mention BYOB :)“

“I stopped into Danny's Pizza early in the day, shortly after they opened. I saw a sign outside that said they were voted #1 best pizza which I'm usually skeptical about. After having a slice though, I was pleasantly surprised. The pizza had a thin, crispy base with an incredibly flavorful sauce. The sauce to cheese ratio was spot on and the cheese was perfectly fresh and melted to perfection. Even the crust was bready and delicious. I'm definitely a fan.“

“My go-to call for a great-tasting, large, plain cheese pizza. Friendly staff. Quick local delivery. Great job, Franco’s! 😊👍🏼❤️“

“I love Ferati’s - The food is delicious, service is great, they are very accommodating shud I request a little change in Preparation.“

“Best pizza in NJ!!! I still dream about the taste 35+years after eating it. I have moved all over the US and have never found anything to compare to the superior taste or quality of their food. Absolutely love it! 😋“

“Food is absolutely amazing, staff very friendly, make you feel at home highly recommend“

“My absolute favorite. Pizza is the best in the area. Staff is super friendly. Everything you want from a small business! Definitely my go to.“

“I’ve been enjoying this great local restaurant literally since the day they opened. Great pizza, pasta and entrees. Definitely one of our favorite places to eat and to get take-out from. Great service and just a well run family restaurant.“

“Just started picking up from this place. Everything has been amazing. Great quality food and great value. Everyone is so nice and even called to confirm a complicated order. I think it is family owned and run and they are all lovely people. Absolutely recommend.“

“Friendly service, warm cozy atmosphere.. impeccable ingredients and outstanding pizza! SAPORITO 🇮🇹“

“Just picked up my pizzas. The staff is incredible and I inquired about a pie I saw so they let me try a slice. I can’t explain how good this slice was! Balsamic chicken. Trust me when I say get this pie!!!! Thank you so much for the friendly staff and amazing food. I will definitely be back over and over again!“

“la recomiendo 100% es un ambiente muy entrenado.“

“They just catered for my son’s 1st birthday party, couldn’t be more happier it was an amazing party topped with amazing food, can’t thank Brian & staff enough for helping with this special party.“

“Incredible pizza, soups, sandwiches and entrees - top shelf everything and customer service is the best -highly recommend“

“Terrific food and staff. The family specials are a huge hit in our house. Great pizza too.“

“I eat here every week with a big group and the food is always delicious. I like to order the chili nachos, and it's perfect for sharing. They are also very accommodating with allergies and have promptly answered questions about allergy content. The servers are very friendly and it's always very lively. Even outside of my group I like to take friends here. Parking is a bit tricky but it's worth it even if you have to park on the side of the road. Highly recommend!“

“We have ordered from Frank's numerous times with no issues. Tonight, driver arrived with 2 items missing and instead of leaving the items he had, took them with him....cold when he returned. Must have thought he was an Indy car driver on the way back because all the sauce for the mussels was gone, box was saturated. When questioned, he checked and said Ooops, sorry, and left. Called and spoke with the Manager who seemed less than Customer Service concerned although did offer another order of mussels. Unfortunately, with the fear of sabotage on the replacement due to complaining, we declined. Should have offered some kind of refund. As a Client Svc Mgr this is an unacceptable response to a dissatisfied client. We will not be ordering from Frank's again. I guess they have enough clients to not care about EVERY client. Shame!“

“My BFF and I enjoyed a wonderful dinner here, with tasty cocktails. Great atmosphere and kind staff! Festive DJ and music too. Go check it out!🥰“