12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sayreville

BRUNCHBOX DAYTIME EATERY Brunch •
20 Jernee Mill Rd suit 4, Sayreville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Avocado Sandwich
Egg & Potato Frittata
Frittata with Bacon
B Y O Pancakes
Mini Pancakes
Eggs Benedict
Very Berry
Home Fries
Brunchbox

“Celebrated my daughter's birthday with 15 of her friends. The staff were so nice, they helped us pick a few items that were served family style. They even made a Nutella pizza for her so we could sing happy birthday. What a wonderful place. The food was delicious. We will definitely return.“

4.8 Superb68 Reviews
Rustoni's Pizza Pizza • $
309 Main St # 3, Sayreville

Customers` Favorites

Breaded Chicken Sandwich
Spinach Artichoke Pizza
Classic Cheese Pizza
Eggplant Rollatini
Sicilian Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Garlic Bread
Southern Wrap
Vodka Pizza
Meatballs

“I just wanted to acknowledge Butch and his staff for their generosity in replacing my take out pizza that slid out of my cargo area onto the street, when the hatchback mysteriously opened as I left the parking lot. Butch replaced the pie (free of charge) and his wife gave me a free desert for me and my wife! I've been coming to Rustoni's Pizza since they opened, and their food is always exceptional, and the staff is always courteous and helpful. They are the best in town! Thanks again Butch.“

4.4 Superb48 Reviews
Camillo's Restaurant & Pizza Pizza • $$
31 MacArthur Ave, Sayreville

Customers` Favorites

Veal Chicken and Shrimp with Linguini
Chicken Oscar with Linguine
Limoncello Mascarpone Cake
Penne Vodka with Chicken
Cake by Lorenarealfood
Mozzarella and Tomato
Scallop and Salmon
Mozzarella Sticks
Crabmeat Ravioli
With Vodka Sauce

“My first visit! My husband's 2nd visit & our friends had been multiple times. We were SO LUCKY to get Alex for our server!! He set the tone so perfectly for our night. Food was good, service was great & Alex took beautiful care of us like family!! We will definitely visit again!! Everyone we met there was lovely. Nice atmosphere! Very warm and welcoming!“

4.3 Superb65 Reviews
Mia's Pizza Restaurant Pizza • $$
4500 Bordentown Ave #5, Sayreville

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks
Bruschetta
Pan Pizza
Wings

“I live in the general area and drive by here all the time and when it pops up in GrubHub, I always want to try it but are usually ordering another kind of cuisine. However, this evening we finally did try it...and the only thing we are upset about is that we didn't try this place much sooner! ? We ordered a plain pie with extra cheese...big hot! Hot, fresh, and delicious with a lovely sauce. The buffalo wings were very tasty! We also ordered the grilled steak salad, which was fresh and flavorful, and the shrimp alla vodka...awesome vodka sauce! We will definitely be ordering again!“

4.5 Superb28 Reviews
Angelo's Pizza & Restaurant Pizza • $
80 Main St, Sayreville

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari
Chicken Parm

“REAL Amazing Italian Food. The owner sal is great and a good guy. He cares about his customers. Any time i’ve had a delivery it arrives hot and fresh. Sometimes i stop in for a chicken parm sub. Couldn’t say enough good things about Angelos. A good family environment too. my kids loved looking at the fish tank. The young girl Alexis who works there is awesome. Always nice to everyone. i highly recommend Angelos Pizza food and service.“

4.3 Superb26 Reviews
Nunzios Kitchen Italian • $
521 Raritan St, Sayreville

Customers` Favorites

Penne Vodka with Breaded Chicken
Cheese Steak
Chicken Parm
Garlic Knots
Margherita
Cannoli
Sausage
Salad

“This was my first time ordering from Nunzios. I called up and talked to the owner who was so friendly. I asked for Gnocchi, but wanted to customize the sauce. That wasn't a problem at all. So I ended up getting the Gnocchi in a mushroom sauce. Well it tasted delicious ,fresh and homemade. It was soft to eat and not hard like other restaurants I've tried. It's by far the best Gnocchi I have had. And I will be ordering this again , thanks again to the owner who wa s so accommodating.“

4.1 Good61 Reviews
Pizza Heaven Pizza • $
777 Washington Rd, Parlin

Customers` Favorites

Large California Chicken Cheese Steak
Eggplant Ricotta & Mozzarella Pizza
Chicken Fingers and Fries
Baked Cheese Ravioli
Cheesesteak Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Veal Parmigiana
Pepperoni Slice
The Napoli Sub
Buffalo Wings

“this place is absolutely amazing. they said their upside down scillian was like L&B’s and it was exactly the same if not better. it was so good i took the rest of the upside down scillian slices to go! the man behind the counter was so welcoming and had the best customer service i’ve ever encountered. i will 110% be coming back here as much as possible! their other slices are also absolutely delicious and was all around the best experience i’ve ever had at a pizzaria. you NEES to try this place out asap!!!“

4 Good44 Reviews
TJ's Pizzeria & Catering Pizza • $
3109 Bordentown Ave, Parlin

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Crust Baked Ziti Pizza
Tavern Pie with Pepperoni
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Famous Tavern Pie
Tavern Pie Slice
Pizza w Sausage
Grilled Chicken
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Tavern Pizza

“Tavern pie is outstanding!Edit: I came back years later to update this review because I believe this information shouldn't be squandered by residents of the area. Seriously, the Tavern Pie is the best pizza I've ever had. Full stop. The garlic knot sliders are, also top-tier. However, the most important takeaway here is the Taven Pie is quite possibly the best pizza ever made on the planet. Thank you.“

4 Good39 Reviews
Pulcinella Italian • $$
3067 Bordentown Ave, Parlin

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti & Eggplant with Fresh Mozzarella
Chicken Parmigiana

“Eggplant parm is excellent. I’m very picky when it comes to eggplant. Many times it’s tough or stringy when I’ve ordered it elsewhere, but it has always been excellent here. The dining room is decorated very nicely. Service was great. Very satisfied.“

4 Good30 Reviews
Santino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
499 Ernston Rd, Parlin

Customers` Favorites

Fettucini Alfredo
Chicken Marsala
Eggplant Parm
Olive Spread
Cheesesteak
Cheesecake
Meatballs
Cannoli
Pizza
Wraps

“I'm going to be honest ... for many years I've seen this place but I never gone there until my mom told me about how amazing the food is ,so I tried the food and I agree it's simply amazing I just wish I tried them sooner !!! Anyway I highly recommend Santino 's pizza !!“

3.9 Good46 Reviews
Bella Napoli Pizzeria & Ristorante Pizza • $$
1816 NJ-35, Sayreville

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pizza

“It is my favorite pizza place in town. It is just perfect for me. Not too much salt in their sauce. The chicken pizza is wow!Vegetarian options: I am vegetarian and they have a wide variety of vegetarian food.Kid-friendliness: Yes. They have kids in the store too if you need a little cute boy.Wheelchair accessibility: Right at the doors.“

3.6 Good19 Reviews
La Rosetta Cafe Italian • $
881 Main St, Sayreville

“We have gone here twice in the last 2 weeks. We have yet to be disappointed. The food is very good. The prices are reasonable. Being a BYOB helps to keep total checks low. The staff is very attentive. The dining room is very comfortable. The owner is very accommodating. The service is neither slow nor rushed. You set the pace!!!“

3.5 Good19 Reviews
Loading...

Discover More Cuisines In Sayreville

map Map