13 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Brunswick

“Ordered a very large order for delivery $200+ the gentleman on the phone was very nice and we received our food about a hour later which was impressive. Delivery driver was very friendly and added a free soda to our order. This was for a company lunch and due to their service and quality of food, we will be ordered from them again.“

“7 Tower Covid-19. evening shift were truly happy and bless with a hot meal. Thank you!“

“My favorite pizza place in New Brunswick. The vegan menu is incredibly extensive and delicious! The owner is so sweet, generous, and helpful. He's always willing to explain a menu item, chat with you ("where's the show tonight?") and make sure your experience is enjoyable. I can't say enough great things about Tata's.“

“Delicious and authentic food. My favorite is the pastor tostadas or penne vodka.“

“If you’re looking for a go-to spot for takeout in New Brunswick, this is it. Their Pizza City Wrap is a must-try as well the wings. And don’t skip the curly cheese fries; perfectly crispy and cheesy. Staff is always friendly. Recommend for sure!“

“Hands-down, the best thin crust pizza in New Brunswick is a must-try for any pizza lover. This spot stands out not only for its perfectly crispy and flavorful thin crust pizza slices but also for its exceptional customer service. The staff here are genuinely helpful and friendly, making every visit a pleasant experience. While the place primarily caters to takeout orders, there is the option to enjoy your meal inside the cozy indoor seating or outside in the fresh air with outdoor seating available.

The thin crust slices are consistently delicious, with a great balance of toppings and a satisfying crunch that true pizza aficionados will appreciate. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or sitting down for a relaxed meal, the atmosphere is welcoming and comfortable. The staff’s attentiveness and willingness to assist with any questions or special requests further enhance the overall experience.

For those in New Brunswick seeking quality thin crust pizza combined with great service and convenient seating options, this place is a top choice. It’s perfect for a casual bite or a small gathering, delivering both taste and hospitality that keep customers coming back. Definitely a standout in the local pizza scene.“

“Every year we take a trip or two to come to this restaurant from Rochester NY ! One year we brought friends of 12 people and went to make reservations and they were full ! Once I told them who we were and we come every year they went above and beyond and got us a private table in the back by the street and accommodated all of us no problem ! Everyone loved it there AND one of their waiters is from where we are in NY it was great to have conversations with him ! Can’t wait to go back again . The mixed drinks as in the mojitos are my favorite! The oil for dipping is perfect !“

“Best ever pizza one can find in whole NJ. Try once and you will be hooked forever. Highly recommend!!!“

“By far the best pizzeria I have ever been to! Great food, large portions and excellent prices. Staff was extremely kind and friendly. I worked in another pizzeria for 5 years and can honestly say Douglass’ food surpasses all pizzerias by far! My new go to spot. Thank you!!“

“Went to NYC in search of New York Style pizza. During our trip we visited Little Italy, found a nice place, food was good, but was told the pizza would not be NY Style. On our last day, after a long walk in Hudson River Park, we searched for "the best New York Style pizza near me". Artichoke was in the search, had awesome reviews, we went for the walk. We ordered two of the Sampler w Artichoke, Pepperoni, Margherita, and Sicilian. The first bite of the Artichoke was incredible 😋👏 I had to try a slice of each. So full, but so happy 😁😍🎉Thank you for giving me my first New York Style pizza experience. We will return!! 👍“

“This place is a Rutgers College Ave staple! The staff was super nice and worked really quickly to get everyone’s orders taken care of. I love the online order option, it really helped keep the line moving. There is no seating inside but the steps next door seem like a common option to eat your slice.

My pizza was piping hot and tasted pretty good. I got a large pepperoni pizza and my kids gave it a 7/10. I’ll definitely be back for a late night snack after a football game some time soon. I can’t wait to try the chicken and vodka sauce pizza.

Kid-friendliness: Pizza is always a perfect choice for kids. This place was quick with my order and was really friendly. I wouldn’t bring my kids here late at night or on weekends because of the college student lifestyle. But midday or grabbing food to go would probably be better for grabbing a quick bite that the kids will enjoy.“

“My favorite meal at Stuff Yer Face is the Turkey Club Boli with a side order of chicken tenders with their homemade honey mustard. Yum!“

“some of the best food around! a favorite lunch spot in New Brunswick.“