18 Best American Restaurants in New Brunswick

Destination Dogs Hot Dogs • $
101 Paterson St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Wings with Fries
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Patatas Ridiculas
All Beef Hot Dog
Truffle Fries
Cheese Fries
Deviled Eggs
Paul Bunyan
Conquistadog
Bratwurst

“I absolutely love this place. Everything is fresh and delicious. These dogs are creative, are made in house, and the options are endless. I am consistently going back to try them all.Vegetarian options: Can switch out any hot dog with a soy dog“

4.7 Superb113 Reviews
SMASHVILLE Hot Chicken & Burgers American • $
377a George St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Milkshake Fruity Pebbles Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Double Patty Smash Burger
Smash Burger with Cheese
Hot Chicken Waffle Fries
Waffle Fries with Beef
Hot Chicken Tender
Chicken Sandwich
Comeback Sauce
Chicken Sammy
Fried Chicken

“SMASHVILLE's smash fries are an absolute game-changer! The combination of perfectly cooked spicy beef patties, crispy fries, melted cheese, and savory onions is simply irresistible. Each bite is bursting with flavor and texture, creating a mouthwatering experience unlike any other. If you haven't tried their smash fries yet, you're definitely missing out on a culinary delight that's worth every bite!Parking: No parking available there usually“

4.5 Superb126 Reviews
The Frog & The Peach American • $$$
29 Dennis St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Ahi Tuna Tatare Appetizer
Long Island Duck Breast
Lobster Eggs Benedict
Truffle Gnocchi
Creme Brulee
Cacio E Pepe
Italian Wine
Pan

“First, let me get the negatives out of the way because this was a very enjoyable brunch. $15 for valet parking seems a bit unreasonable with the prices here and compared with other restaurants that have valet service, the waiter service was adequate but somewhat stiff and cool. Having said that everything else was absolutely wonderful, very nice, eclectic and well put together brunch menu, bacon beighnets appetizer hit the mark, eggs Benedict with lobster and truffles was decadent and delicious, duck Bahn Mi with handcut chips was perfectly put together and the French Toast was nicely plated. Beautifull atmosphere, nice location, very relaxing brunch.“

4.2 Good280 Reviews

4
Clydz

Clydz American • $$
55 Paterson St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Roasted Organic Chicken
Alligator in a Blanket
Bourbon Cigarettes
Hangar Steak
Pierogies

“First time at Clyz since new ownership. Was a St. Patty's Day work celebration so no ordering from regular menu but rather a buffet setup with about 7 different dishes. Food was good. Service was great from waitress coming around for drink orders. They had orange whiskey for my fav orange whiskey mule! I and the coworkers I spoke to would have preferred not having the lights dimmed as it was way too dark and there was no need for such "mood" lighting.“

4.2 Good173 Reviews
Stage Left Steak Steak House
5 Livingston Ave, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Hand-Sliced Prosciutto Di Parma with Parmigiano Reggiano
28 Day Dry Aged Prime Tomahawk Chop
Wagyu Beef on Himalayan Salt Block
Molten Valrhona Chocolate Cake
Sautéed Spinach with Garlic
The Stage Left Cheeseburger
The Stage Left Burger
Stuffed Baked Potato
Petite Filet Mignon
Charred Asparagus

“Attractive restaurant, close proximity to the state theater, the reason for my choosing it, with nice ambiance, and an Attentive staff. Drinks were pricey but spot on, as was the food, cooked perfectly. Desserts were large and delicious. Even comped us a birthday crème brûlée as it was my girlfriend's birthday. Overall great dining experience, but, as previously stated, a little pricey for New Brunswick.“

4.1 Good143 Reviews
Fritz's Sandwich Shop • $
115 Easton Ave, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Risotto Fritters
Grilled Cheese
Truffle Fries
Salads
Vegan

“This is the absolute best gluten free bread my family and I have ever had and we have tried ALOT of gf breads. We have had to order gluten free bread on many occasions from California because that was the only good one we could find, so to have an even BETTER one available right here in NJ is such an unexpectedly amazing find. It is so hard to find fresh, soft gf sour dough bread and if you’re gluten free you know how amazing it is to finally find something that is actually delicious and tastes like bread! I visited the cafe today and the staff was so helpful, kind, and generous and gave me a lot of helpful information on the bread. I will definitely be ordering more online!“

4.3 Superb41 Reviews
Buns N Shakes American •
112 Church St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Hot Honey Chicken Fries
Cheeseburger and Fries
Cheetos Mac and Cheese
Homemade Cheese Sauce
Nashville Hot Honey
Macaroni and Cheese
Smashcheetos Combo
Hot Chicken Fries
Burger and Fries
Smashmelt Combo

“Awesome place for comfort food in New Brunswick. The Mac n cheese bites are awesome. They pair it with a homemade “Big Mac sauce”. The cheese fries were great too, I believe they have their own homemade cheese sauce. Everything is priced in line with what you would expect for a local restaurant. It came to $35 for two people. Parking is a challenge but that’s New Brunswick for you.“

4.1 Good111 Reviews
Houlihan's American • $$
55 US-1, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Pineapple Upside Down with Vanilla Ice Cream
Salted Caramel Gooey Butter Cake
Original Baked Potato Soup
Cheese Burger with Fries
Houlihan’S Cheeseburger
Ultimate Brownie Sundae
Chicken Tender Platter
Chicken Tortilla Soup
Fried Green Tomatoes
Sedona Shrimp Pasta

“Had to update my review and drop a star from 5 to 4.Houlihan's is unique among chain restaurants and bars.Very nice atmosphere, large bar, and better than average food.Why the 4 stars?Two reasons:1. Limited draft beer selection2. They removed the AMAZING Prime Rib when Covid hit, and they never brought it back.The Prime Rib was the best I've had in just about any restaurant, and it's a shame they removed it from the menu.I also wish they'd bring back the wings they had a number of years ago - green jalapeno wings or something - they were amazing.I miss the avocado toast here as well.Great appetizers - the Ahi Tuna app is excellent.Buffalo and Thai Chili wings are both awesome.NY Strip is solid.Down Home Pot Roast - incredible.Sedona Shrimp Pasta - great.Brentwood Chicken Sandwich is very good too.Overall - a great place to grab a drink and some food - and only a couple of changes would make it 5-stars again for me.“

4 Good147 Reviews
Olive Branch Gastropubs • $
37 Bartlett St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom and Onion Sliders
Branch Burger
Wing Sampler

“My cousin is attending Rutgers College and wanted to meet after class, and this was the place he picked. I was excited to check it out. When I walked in, I was carded it's been a while since that happened to me, so I was flattered, to say the least. Don't wait to be seated. Just find your spot, I found mine in front of the TV they had both basketball games on. While sitting I noticed no one came over to take my order I thought that was a bit odd, when my cousin came in we made our way over to the bar and we received all the service we needed. This is the first place I ever visited that didn't come to you. You had to come to them, lol. Different, but everyone was nice and had a smile. I had naked wings and house salad. I'm not sure what they use for the Buffalo sauce, but it was good. I left nothing but bone, lol. The salad was fresh, and I so enjoyed the Greek vinaigrette. It was delicious. They also had BINGO, and we played about 3 games before we headed out. Over all ot was a great experience, and I'll be back for those naked wings. Oh, and they gave me a drink, Cozy, as well, lol“

4.3 Superb15 Reviews
Stuff Yer Face Gastropubs • $
49 Easton Ave, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Stromboli
Original Stromboli
Pizza Boli
Pierogies
Meatball
Nachos

“One of the staples of Rutgers. Definitely grab a stromboli from here and pair it with one of many beers on tap. Friendly service, plenty of seating, and good prices for the food. The bolis are filling and have a large number of meats and vegetables for customization.“

4 Good59 Reviews
Glass Woods Tavern American • $$
2 Albany St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Quinoa Cake

“It seemed like the restaurant was closed but my friends and I was able to order some drinks at the bar, then we moved to a table for dinner. Our server Dominic was very attentive and helpful. Chicken tasted a little too dry, but all the other food we ordered was amazing; especially brisket! It was so tender and tasty. Two of the desserts we ordered with a cup of cappuccino were phenomenal. We were so full after finishing the bbq combo plate, but sure did finish both of the desserts ? I'm glad this place is open for the public. Will definitely comeback ??‍♀️“

4.2 Good15 Reviews
Harvest Moon Brewery & Cafe Brewpubs • $$
392 George St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries
French Onion Soup
Sandwiches
Chips

“Food was very good and the serving staff were courteous but service itself was slower than in the past. Value was pretty good but there were some price increases on the bill that were not reflected in the menu (add-ons). Make sure you give yourself time if going to a show!“

3.9 Good93 Reviews
Tavern on George Gastropubs • $$
361 George St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Waffles and Chili and Lime Wings
Corned Beef Sandwich
Buffalo Cauliflower
Bacon Cheeseburgers
Sweet Potato Fries
Impossible Burger
Chicken Wings
Tavern Nachos
French Fries
Huge Pretzel

“Our server Mike, was great!!! We had a wonderful dinner and great server!!! His serving partner, Gabriel was just as great!! They make a great team, the food recommended by Mike was a huge hit!!! Ask for Mike and Gabriel when you get there!!!“

3.9 Good79 Reviews
25 Burgers American • $
4 Easton Ave, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Double Cheeseburger and Cajun Fries
Classic Cheeseburgers
Bulls Eye BBQ Burger
Diet Pepsi Bottle
Bacon Cheeseburger
Jr Turkey Burger
Maui Burger
Onion Rings
Milkshake

“The food is always delicious! Depending on the time you go, you might find allot of college kids, young professionals, or just riff raff from the city that might be asked to leave or just hang out in the restaurant. They have late night ? ? hours.“

3.9 Good67 Reviews
El Ranchito Restaurant & Bakery Latin American • $
23 Georges Rd, New Brunswick

“I ordered Mexican pastries and bread from this location. The servers were nice and the place is wheelchair accessible (do not know the bathroom situation). There are some high counters but you can basically see all the food available through the glass. The actual breads were pretty yummy and fresh.“

3.8 Good14 Reviews
Judy's Kitchen Spanish • $
153 Hamilton St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Plate

“Such a great place! The food and staff are 5 stars! I was in the ER for hours and got the house special, chicken and veggies with rice, tacos, and a milkshake. My doordash driver brought the wrong food and pretty much told me too bad and they had another delivery. I called up Judy's Kitchen and they apologized and made me a new meal and delivered it themselves. So thankful! I was there for almost 8 hours, they really helped!“

3.8 Good20 Reviews
Hansel 'n Griddle American • $
130 Easton Ave, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Popcorn Buffalo Chicken Crisp
Strawberry Covered Oreos
Buffalo Chicken Panini
Buttermilk Pancakes
Buffalo Tater Tots
Chicken Sandwich
Buffalo Wedges
Create Your Own
Cajun Chicken
Potato Wedges

“Went there with about four of my friends and we had a good time. I ordered the banana flip smoothie and the buffalo panini. The wait wasn't long and there was plenty of seating so the five of us found the perfect table to accommodate us. The seating was clean and very comfortable by the window with plenty of sunshine. We were the only customers there so we felt very comfortable. The smoothie was great as always, with the right consistency not too thick easy to drink, and sweet. The sandwich was okay I felt the chicken was hard to bite into at times and I wish I had more blue cheese but other than that it was plated and presented neatly. Would go again.“

3.8 Good58 Reviews
Old Man Rafferty's Bar & Grill • $$
106 Albany St, New Brunswick

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Chicken Sliders
Prime Rib French Dip
Chocolate Chip Cake
Filet Mignon Sliders
Chicken Pot Pie Bowl
Sweet Potato Fries
French Onion Soup
Chicken Parmesan
French Onion
BBQ Ribs

“We visited OMR for the first time tonight. Now today happened to be valentine's day so they were packed. I called ahead and made reservations however too my surprise they whisked us away to a table before we could mention it. Whenever you go to a big restraunt on a holiday you expect the service to be slow and it was. However I only have great things to say about this place. The manager Rachael was so attentive and turned it into a wonderful dining experience. They had a special menu for the holiday. We each started our with french onion soup. That was the BEST french onion soup I have ever had.For the main I choose the prime rib with vegetable and baked potatoes. The steak was amazing and melted in your mouth. The portion was huge! You definitely get your moneys worth. My wife choose the lobster risotto which did not disappoint. It was creamy and loaded with fresh lobster. We decided to take desert home not to mention half of our meals. They have a display in the front showing the desert so my wife choose 3....they are small portions ...again Valentine's day ?..Chocolate lava cake was dark chocolate with rich dark filling. Banana coconut kind of bland with icing too sweet. Butternut crunch I think was the 3rd but it too had no real flavor. Over all a good places to have diner and drinks!“

3.8 Good77 Reviews
Loading...
map Map