19 Best Ice Cream Shops near Stewartsville

“My husband and I have always had a great experience at Rita’s! The staff is incredibly friendly and does such a fantastic job. The service is quick, and they always make sure everything is perfect. The treats are always fresh and delicious—whether it’s Italian ice, frozen custard, or a blend of both! I highly recommend stopping by for a sweet treat and great service!“

“My husband and I stopped for ice cream and what a cute place! The ice cream was very good with a wide array of flavors. The service was very good, very courteous. Then we went to find a place to sit. Behind the building they have an area surrounded with trees and plenty of picnic tables. A perfect place to bring our grandchildren. We will be back.“

“Got a peanut butter milkshake & a small pup cup for my rottie - we both approve! Not only was the milkshake excellent, but the owners are extremely friendly and personable.“

“Their ice cream is outstanding. I had the honor of being the first person to try their new flavor this evening, Strawberry Rhubarb! Wow! I have a new favorite 💗“

“The pup cup was so delicious I enjoyed every lick.. a picture of me enjoying it is on my Facebook page. 👍“

“My husband absolutely loves their soft ice cream. He says it's like it was when he was a kid. He gets enough for a week every Saturday. I personally Love the hard ice cream flavors. They have alot and they change them up so there's always something new to try. We can walk to them right from our house. Go .... you won't regret it.“

“Best curry chicken in Easton very impressed . Plus people are so nice I see why dad loves it here 💯“

“We hired Anthony to cater the dessert at my kid’s college graduation party. It was perfect. All 50 guest made sure to get a treat! At one point my family waited in a line! It was great. Anthony is a very kind and friendly man. We had our little issues with schedules prior but I’m not uptight about that stuff. Life’s too short! At the event…perfection!!“

“This is quite possibly the best ice cream I have ever had anywhere in the world. I appreciate the limited selection of interesting flavors and of course the new flavors that come out every month. Most importantly, the ice cream is creamy and flavorful, not just packed full of sugar like most other ice creams. The store is also in a great location and staff are very friendly. Price is very reasonable for exceptional quality. Highly recommend!“

“great ice cream and friendly service, an awesome way to cool down.“

“Thank you for your support and generous donation of ice cream and toppings to the Warren Hills Boys Lacrosse Team!!!“

“Creamy, delicious ice cream on a real working farm with plenty for family to see and do during their visit. The best flavor is lemon, but we tried a bit of the Oreo, as well as mint, raspberry, and peanut butter. They are all high quality and fresh tasting.“

“Great food and ice cream! Wonderful 50’s vibe!“

“My friends and I had a fantastic time at Castlegate Ice Cream! Jolene provided excellent customer service—she was friendly, honest about the course’s older age, and made sure we still had a great experience. The mini-golf was fun, and the ice cream was absolutely delicious. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Epic ice cream, jams and Jersey fresh corn! I’ll be back!“

“I recommend Frozenlandia. I personally prefer the Burgers, Burrito ? and the ice cream ?. Delicious ?. Friendly and ready to help you staff!

Vegetarian options: Available

Dietary restrictions: Available

Parking: Free parking spots around the shop

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“I stopped by on my way to the funeral of Fethullah Gülen Hocaefendi. The boss and the employees are very friendly people. A lot of my Turkish customers stopped by today and asked why. I explained and shared our pain. I thanked him very much.“

“Drove up from Tennessee to enjoy a cheese pizza to go. Definitely in the top 3 best pizzas of my life. Wish I lived closer. That drive for the pizza was brutal.“

“ice cream! banana split.“