7 Best Ice Cream Shops near High Bridge

“From the second we stepped foot inside this convenience store/ice cream shop/diner, we knew immediately we’d love it. As an avid pancake lover, I knew I had to get their massive pancake. Topped with warm, salty butter, every bite was delicious. The chocolate chips tasted like real chocolate, unlike many other diners around! I can’t wait to go back and try the pancake of the month next time!Parking: Fills up fast on the weekend“

“How have I never reviewed a place that I have been going to for YEARS?! Honestly the best ice cream around. I know many have their own opinions on other places within a good radius of Polar Cub, but nothing has ever topped them and I have been to them all! Good price, good portion sizes. I even used to get extras for the dogs (when I had dogs). Nice little seating area as well. My preference here is definitely a good strawberry sundae with Soft Vanilla Ice Cream. Not sure what they do with that, but it tastes amazing. The only downsides I can think of are the parking situation. If it's a busy day, expect to park on the side of Rt. 22. Also, it's cash only.. so be ready with cash on hand! Othe than that, it's a perfect little place!“

“I get exceptional service every time I visit this store. The staff is always friendly and smiling, even when I get off work late and show up just before closing. Marc the owner/mgr always makes you feel welcome and appreciated. Today he went above and beyond even more so than normal. I went in to get a large order of blizzards for the 911 center and he would not take any money and just offered his thanks for the work done by these often overlooked, true first of the first responders. Keep up the phenomenal work Marc and the whole DQ staff! You keep our community great!“

“Easy off the highway 31 southbound in Glen Gardner as we came down from Califon. All local fresh farm food. All locally-owned and grown dairy, organic meat, and produce. Meat is lean so there price is for weight of "show-me-the-meat", not filler-fat. Ice cream home made from cream of the local cows. Absolutely with delicious natural flavors and toppings. Like real strawberries in their strawberry topping. They have a nice rural sitting area to enjoy our spontaneous treat. Well worth the trip up 31North from I-78 @ Clinton, then it's on left.“

“Good ice cream and what a cute atmosphere. Happy they had some seasonal flavors. Some issues were I asked for soft serve and the machine was off. Since I couldn’t get my vanilla I figured u would get hard ice cream. I did not see it in the case. Same with chocolate.“

“I understand this is a local business here and I know I needed to try the Italian Ice! As soon as I spotted a location off the side of the road I exclaimed "STOP"! Rita's did not disappoint! I ordered a four-flavor sampler that they made for me in a cup. My flavor choices were black cherry, mango, strawberry, and peach and they surely didn't disappoint! I will be returning for a milkshake or sundae very soon!“

“My mom and I have been on a mission for a week to find spumoni ice cream. After striking out at what seemed like every ice cream joint in Central Jersey, we walked into Just Chill on a rainy Thursday evening. We asked the helpful employee, Julia, whether they sold spumoni, and she told us that they had a spumoni cake for $50 but could not sell it by the slice :( But quick-thinking Julia came up with a combination of pistachio gelato, a half scoop of chocolate and a half scoop of strawberry to appease my hungry mom! Thanks Julia, you're the best!“