Manhattan Bagel
Customers' Favorites
Egg on a Bagel
Menu
Fresh Bagels
-
Bagel $1.75
-
Butter Bagel $3.25
-
Cream Cheese Bagel $4.50
-
Flavored Cream Cheese Bagel $5.30
-
Doggie bagel $1.75
Breakfast
-
Egg on a bagel $5.35
-
Egg and Cheese $5.99
Plain bagel with American cheese.
-
Meat on a bagel $6.99
-
Meat and egg $7.60
-
Meat and cheese $7.49
-
Original bagel classic $8.25
-
Croissant classic $9.60
-
Classic breakfast wrap $9.99
-
Steak egg and cheese $9.99
-
Spinach bacon croissant $9.99
-
Avocado toast $6.25
-
Avocado egg white $9.60
-
Santa Fe egg white $9.60
-
Farm house $9.99
-
Smoked house brisket $10.60
-
Breakfast cheesesteak $9.99
-
Nova lox $16.75
Signature Lunch
-
Ellis Island Hot Pastrami $11.99
Rye bagel with Swiss cheese, grilled onion and spicy mustard.
-
Chicken salad $11.99
Rye bagel with Swiss cheese, grilled onion and spicy mustard.
-
Tuna salad $11.99
-
Empire State club $11.99
-
BLT $11.99
-
Ham and Swiss $11.99
-
Soho chicken Caesar wrap $11.99
-
Avocado veggie out $11.99
-
Manhattan cheesesteak $11.99
-
Chelsea chicken $11.99
-
Avocado BLT $11.99
-
Greenwich grilled cheese $11.99
Breakfast for the Group
-
Baker's Dozen $17.50
13 bagels.
-
Half Dozen $9.75
6 bagels
-
Baker's Dozen Value Pack $27.50
13 bagels and 2 tubs of cream cheese.
-
Half Dozen Value Pack $15.00
-
Coffee box $27.50
96 oz. of fresh-brewed coffee with cups, lids, half and half, sweeteners and stir sticks. Serves 10 people.
Pastry
-
Croissant $3.15
-
Muffins $4.35
-
Chocolate chip cookie $3.75
-
Cinnamon roll $3.99
-
Strawberry strudel $4.15
Sides
-
Yogurt parfait $6.25
-
Fruit cup $7.50
-
8oz tuna salad $7.99
-
8oz chicken salad $7.99
-
4oz potato salad $1.25
-
4oz macaroni salad $1.25
-
4oz coleslaw salad $1.25
-
4oz Lox package $14.99
-
Hash brown $1.99
-
Side of meat
6oz cream cheese tubs
-
Plain cream cheese $5.75
-
Veggie cream cheese $5.99
-
Scallion cream cheese $5.99
-
Lox cream cheese $5.99
-
Jalapeño salsa cream cheese $5.99
-
Honey almond cream cheese $5.99
-
Strawberry cream cheese $5.99
-
8oz butter tub $5.75
Coffee and tea
-
Hot Coffee $2.85
-
Hot Tea $2.85
-
Iced Tea $3.75
-
Iced Coffee $3.75
-
Cold brew $4.49
Chillerz
-
Caffe Caramel $5.99
FROZEN CHILLER WITH CARAMEL *chillerz* cold brrr
-
Caffe Mocha $5.99
FROZEN CHILLER WITH MOCHA
-
Caffe Latte $5.99
Is a FROZEN CHILLER
-
Strawberry banana $5.99
CHILLER
Beverages
-
Coca Cola 20oz $3.60
-
Diet Coke 20oz $3.60
-
Snapple $3.60
-
Tropicana $3.50
-
Gatorade $3.60
-
Nesquick $3.75
-
Chocolate milk $3.75
-
Yoohoo $3.75
-
Sports water $3.25
-
Fountain soda $3.75
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Amazing spot. GREAT PEOPLE. I had the French toast sandwich was absolutely amazing! They also have smoothies to go with your meals. Good spot nice people if you’re looking for an upper end quick deli vibe. Can sit down if you want.
July 2026
While many of the Manhattan bagel locations vary, the one in the ShopRite plaza in toms River excels. I have seen the same owner / manager for many years adventure to say have never had a bad experience. The staff is usually smiling, the food is warm when you get it, and the quality and quantity are very fair for the price. I don't know if all locations are as good but this one is worth the trip.
June 2024
Love this Manhattan bagel! I come here very often and this location is far superior. The food is always delicious, consistent and fresh and the store is very clean and well kept. They’re very accommodating, letting you customize your order to your liking and the staff is super friendly and helpful. Great experiences overall.
June 2024