50 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Caldwell

“My go-to call for a great-tasting, large, plain cheese pizza. Friendly staff. Quick local delivery. Great job, Franco’s! 😊👍🏼❤️“

“Mandara's Ristorante & Pizzeria
Mandara’s Ristorante & Pizzeria is a cozy Italian eatery known for its classic pizza, pasta dishes, and traditional Italian flavors. The pizzas are typically thin-crust and generously topped with fresh ingredients. Pasta dishes are hearty and flavorful, with sauces made from scratch. The ambiance is casual and family-friendly, often giving a warm, neighborhood feel. Service is usually attentive, and portions are generous. It’s a solid choice for anyone craving authentic Italian comfort food in a relaxed setting.“

“Frank's Trattoria (West Caldwell)
Frank's Trattoria offers a cozy, welcoming Italian dining experience with a focus on traditional dishes made from fresh ingredients. The menu features classic pasta, pizza, seafood, and meat dishes, all served in generous portions. The flavors are hearty and well-seasoned, with a home-style feel that makes it perfect for family dinners or casual outings. The ambiance is warm and inviting, and the staff is attentive and friendly, enhancing the overall dining experience. Prices are reasonable for the quality and portions offered. Frank's Trattoria is a solid choice for anyone craving authentic Italian comfort food in West Caldwell.“

“Best Gluten Free pizza you will find. Reminds Me of the days before I was diagnosed with Celiac, I will be back for more“

“We have been coming here for years! Love the service, the food and the ambiance ♥️“

“If you love good pizza and live in North Jersey, you have to check them out! The garlic knots are so good. I was sad to see the confetti cake go, but they suggested the cinnamon one — guess I've got my next visit planned! I ordered the garlic knot. It's the hugest l've ever seen. The pepperoni slice was so yummy.“

“I ordered half tray of mini arancini balls for Christmas appetizer and my guests and family loved them. it was so good, and even made them as requested without beef inside. we love their pizzas in the past. thank you PBP for great service and Quality.“

“Service, Pizza and Tiramisu was excellent!!!!!🩷“

“This is one of the BEST pizzerias I have EVER been to. They make you feel like family at your first stop and thereafter. I wish that I lived closer because I would be every single day. My humble abode is in Belleville but make it in as many times as possible!!! You definitely need to come in for a great meal!!“

“Great food and customer service“

“Coming from a New Yorker this is the best Italian restaurant for the food, service, and atmosphere. The food was amazing and the owner was absolutely the best. If you don’t come here before you die you you are are making a big mistake.. So get here now!!!“

“I try to come here at least once a week for their hot honey pepperoni pizza. It is something i never tasted before until trying it here and honestly one of the best pizza I’ve had in a while. From the moment you walk in staff is super nice and friendly. Their lunch specials are great and reasonable as well if you work or are in the area. Recommend everyone to go and try it out you will not be disappointed!!“

“The owner of this restaurant was so pleasant and friendly as well as the staff!!! So welcoming and helpful. I had ordered a plain pie, buffalo chicken pie, and a chicken cesar pie. I wish I can pick a favorite, but they are all amazing!!!!! The plain tastes just as good as it looks. Don’t even get me started on the chicken ceasar and buffalo 🤤 This is my new go to pizzeria and the best around! I totally recommend!!!“

“I had lunch with my little ones on the 1st of Sept. around 3 and the experience was far beyond; especially being that it was out 1st. These 3 were Amazing. The young lady as my introduction; very KNOWLEDGEABLE and PATIENT, to the 2 person (guy) with providing endless options making sure you’re going to enjoy your food, with ending the last person (another guy) who made sure he ended your experience with HUMOR. Job Well Done TEAM 💜“

“Best pizza in whippany especially the square grandfather thin crust pizza they also have delicious Italian dishes you’ll surely enjoy“

“Going to the Hot Tuna concert last night at the Wellmont with my son and stopped in for pizza before the show. The pizza was out of this world! Great crust, toppings were all quality and the staff was great. The owner Joe was friendly and place was going.“

“Henry P. was extremely friendly and has a pleasant demeanour. As soon as I walked in, he knew about my order and he made sure it was ready. Also, him and another co-worker, were able to give me a great discount after I showed him my online coupon. Both of their attitudes were positive and were a great representation of what Celestino’s Pizza and Ristorante can be.“

“I love the spinach pockets they make.“

“Fast, friendly, delicious, and fast! Can’t beat it.“

“We tried the pizza 🍕 and the calamari 🦑 and the vodka penne dish and all exceeded our expectations, bravo 👏 we’ll be back soon,keep that quality up boys 🆙“

“Food was amazing, 2 types of pizza, best garlic knots on Earth. Delivery was fast. No where as good around here.“

“Great food, friendly people“

“I was at the Belleville senior club and had the cheesesteak sandwish. I was delious“

“We love Spinachio! We came here before Dave portnoy reviewed them and I thought I rated them but I forgot! Anyways I always eat the food before and today finally snapped a pic! We love their food and not just pizza! Their soups are amazing and super flavorful. I’ve had the chicken noodle and straticella. The pizzas are always amazing. Fresh ingredients and delicious full of flavor. I haven’t tried a slice that I didn’t like. Today we got the vodka rigitini and omh it was so different but amazing. Creamy and cheesy. The regular pie we got well done so a bit more crispy. The fries were cajón and super good a bit soggy but very good. The time of the fries wasn’t cut out like the rest of the tins. They do that so it doesn’t get soggy. I love how they do that. The mozzy sticks are so good too cheesy and crispy! Owners are super friendly and recognize me and my husbands family. We probably come here maybe every 2 weeks when we are in the area. Highly recommend!!! And will always come back!“

“top pie and the best crust and great staff“

“Road the Amtrak transit into NJ to visit friends and stopped to get a bite to eat in the Bloomfield Center area. We chose the Six Points Pizza and it was delicious. We tried the momma's meatballs and the mushroom ricotta deep dish by the slice. It was covered in fresh dollops of ricotta and fresh basil pesto.
Yummy“

“I just went up to the order window but my two pizza slices came out in less than 3 minutes! I got the plain cheese slice and wow. For being just a plain cheese pizza slice it was DELICIOUS. Also it was only 7 bucks for two slices and a sprite. Will come again!“

“nice place, delicious 😋 food, quality was excellent also it was a friendly experience I really recommend it“

“The best Pizza in town ! Family owned and very friendly and kind people!“

“Tried we’ll be back to try the pizza too“

“Food is amazingly fresh and delicious and service is great 👍😋“

“Ordered delivery to our hotel. Service was fast, accurate, and the food was hot. Delivery options were door dash, Uber eats, or store delivery. We chose store delivery. Order arrived within 25 minutes. Excellent delivery driver. Professional, courteous, and an asset to the brand. Shout out to Luc. He earned a 25% tip !! A great start to our cruise week.. Bob & Crystal Connecticut USA
#BahamasBound #Cruiselife #TheHut“

“Love the chicken parm & drunken grandma pie! BUT now I just had the apple Turnovers..omg delicious!!! even yummy heated next day. Not doughy..light and airy.😋“

“Great staff. Excellent calzones. Generous with portions. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“I ordered from my job once in a while and don't have time to call. Their online ordering system is amazing and you can write any note and they will actually read it and do what you need. I had a problem months ago and the owner actually called me and spoke with me. She was a very nice lady and the reason I haven't nixed the place. Food is delicious 😊 5 stars always!“

“They just catered for my son’s 1st birthday party, couldn’t be more happier it was an amazing party topped with amazing food, can’t thank Brian & staff enough for helping with this special party.“

“I love a good double Italian hotdog and the best place to get one is here! They have the freshest bread and the food just tastes incredible! They are reasonably priced and give you good portions. The only bad thing is that it's a cash only kind of place, so make sure to bring cash. The next time I near this area, I will definitely be back. Highly recommend!“

“The pizza was delicious! They don’t use any artificial or super-processed ingredients, so even the Coke was Mexican Coke that uses agave sweetener versus corn syrup! Casual but feels upscale.“

“If you’re in Little Falls and craving some delicious pizza, Jojo Pizza is the place to be! Their Jojo Square Pizza is a must-try – perfectly crispy on the outside and delightfully soft on the inside, with just the right amount of cheese and toppings. Another standout is the Chicken Torrente Sandwich it’s packed with flavor and incredibly satisfying.
What makes Jojo Pizza even more special is the friendly and welcoming atmosphere, thanks to the owner, Junior. He goes above and beyond to ensure every customer feels at home. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, you’re in for a treat at Jojo Pizza!“

“Amazing! I just found my favorite pizza shop! If you’re looking for traditional jersey pie, you’re going to be disappointed.“

“Passed this place a bunch of times. So I was hungry. So I said let’s give it a try. Well was amazing. Staff from moment walked in very friendly. Warm welcome. Started off with the Fire Roasted Wings (10) flame-broiled all-natural chicken wings marinated in fresh herbs & spices + lemon & herb dipping sauce Dough-Roni Pie Olli Salumeria pepperoni + tomato sauce + ricotta + fresh mozzarella + red onions Lemon Ricotta Ravioli Hand-made Ravioli + summer squash + fresh mint + pistachios + lemon zest + parmesan cheese Got off track sorry. Has seating at bar and has outside patio. (Was just a little to hot out there today) Very clean and definitely swinging by again. It’s right across street from Fairfield airport. Can’t forget the wine cooler before seated. There had to be 25+ wines to choose from.“

“My husband and I stopped by late Saturday night for dinner and pick up a couple of slices.The pizza was delicious, especially the Margherita and Boom Boom slices, even the garlic knots was great. The women at the cashier was extra nice and helpful.“

“Just picked up my pizzas. The staff is incredible and I inquired about a pie I saw so they let me try a slice. I can’t explain how good this slice was! Balsamic chicken. Trust me when I say get this pie!!!! Thank you so much for the friendly staff and amazing food. I will definitely be back over and over again!“

“Love the chicken California Panini!!“

“Great place“

“The hospitality at avenue pizza was well appreciated, the Pizza is amazing. I recommend, a great place for your family.“

“The owner Mike is a great guy!“

“Friendly service, warm cozy atmosphere.. impeccable ingredients and outstanding pizza! SAPORITO 🇮🇹“

“Terrific food and staff. The family specials are a huge hit in our house. Great pizza too.“

“Good luck my son 😊❤️!!!! I love you, Love, Mom- God bless you!!!!!“