50 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Caldwell

“My go-to call for a great-tasting, large, plain cheese pizza. Friendly staff. Quick local delivery. Great job, Franco’s! 😊👍🏼❤️“

“Title: One of the best Italian Restaurants in North Jersey

I am so surprised that I haven’t been to Mandara’s before considering that I have been frequenting the Essex County area for the past four years. Decided to go for dinner tonight and we can’t wait to come back!

Highlights:
You HAVE to try the pizza, one of the best margherita pizza’s in this area and the chicken marsala was phenomenal! The portions are generous!!

The service was amazing, our waiter came by to check in on us at appropriate times, they brought over extra napkins without us even having to ask, and were attentive to our requests.

Overall, ambiance was amazing, great food with huge portions, and amazing staff!“

“The other day I ordered, Frank’s Trattoria (West Caldwell), for lunch. I got their Pepperoni, Chicken Parmesan, & Plain Slice’s. From the toppings and the cheese(s), to the sauce. This place was phenomenal! Their pep & plain slices were a solid 9/10. Excellent flavor, and great texture!! the Chicken Parm slice was extremely sub par though. Was really disappointed. But the pep and plain slices GREATLY impacts my total score. The person who took my order was very rude. I asked if I could leave a tip, they vehemently expressed that they ‘do not need tips, they’ll be ok.’ Their pepperoni and plain pizza was really, really good. Like borderline top 5. Excellent pep slice, excellent pizza. I’d highly recommend this place to anyone looking for really good pizza, and happen to be in the, West Caldwell area. Just don’t expect the best service.“

“We have been coming here for years! Love the service, the food and the ambiance ♥️“

“Best Gluten Free pizza you will find. Reminds Me of the days before I was diagnosed with Celiac, I will be back for more“

“I had lunch with my little ones on the 1st of Sept. around 3 and the experience was far beyond; especially being that it was out 1st. These 3 were Amazing. The young lady as my introduction; very KNOWLEDGEABLE and PATIENT, to the 2 person (guy) with providing endless options making sure you’re going to enjoy your food, with ending the last person (another guy) who made sure he ended your experience with HUMOR. Job Well Done TEAM 💜“

“I ordered half tray of mini arancini balls for Christmas appetizer and my guests and family loved them. it was so good, and even made them as requested without beef inside. we love their pizzas in the past. thank you PBP for great service and Quality.“

“Des took my order on the phone.
Wow. An actual human being that's bubbly, connective & intelligent. You just don't find it that much these days. Was an absolute pleasure ordering. Knows her menu. Asks all the right questions (sauce on side, what variety would you like, etc).
The people that work there are always nice & authentic there. Plus their food is good.
5 stars, 🤩 Just order! And if you get Des, say hello and good day :-)“

“Awesome pizza and service!“

“Going to the Hot Tuna concert last night at the Wellmont with my son and stopped in for pizza before the show. The pizza was out of this world! Great crust, toppings were all quality and the staff was great. The owner Joe was friendly and place was going.“

“Great food and customer service“

“Best pizza in whippany especially the square grandfather thin crust pizza they also have delicious Italian dishes you’ll surely enjoy“

“OMG!!!!!! THE BEST PIZZA I'VE EVER HAD!!!!!!
This is not an exaggeration. They have cracked the code to the perfect crust/sauce/ topping ratio. The crust is crispy and fluffy and buttery without being greasy. The toppings are FRESH! It's light and hearty at the same time. I got the zucchini and buffalo slices and my sister got the Upside Down and the massive garlic knot. INCREDIBLE!!!!! I'm not usually a buffalo sauce person because it can be acidic and too spicy...........THIS IS PERFECT. The zucchini slice tasted like they picked everything from the garden. If you love a more saucy pizza the upside down is LEGIT.!!

Adam was so incredibly kind and welcoming. He explained everything to us and has the best energy!!

The bathroom is so ICONIC!!!! Just go in and if you know....you know.

This was our first time going my sister showed me a video from instagram and it surpassed the hype!!! It was worth every penny and will be our main pizza place!!!“

“First time visiting this gem after roaming the area for a good slice. I had them heat up a cheese, famous Giuseppe, and pepperoni slices. All were extremely delicious, thin, and crispy. Just the way I like it. I’m not quite sure what the crust from their special pies are but I LOVE it. The undercarriage is like a thin focaccia style bread. I sat down on the patio as well which kept me nice and cool throughout the experience. Oh and I got a complimentary drink for dining in!

Most importantly, Mr Jack Calandra served me (and my dog with two slices of raw pepperoni) and he was nothing but amazing to say the least. We got to chat a bit and he gave me quick story of how this spot and its specials pies.

Please Go visit !“

“Fast, friendly, delicious, and fast! Can’t beat it.“

“Great food, friendly people“

“The owner of this restaurant was so pleasant and friendly as well as the staff!!! So welcoming and helpful. I had ordered a plain pie, buffalo chicken pie, and a chicken cesar pie. I wish I can pick a favorite, but they are all amazing!!!!! The plain tastes just as good as it looks. Don’t even get me started on the chicken ceasar and buffalo 🤤 This is my new go to pizzeria and the best around! I totally recommend!!!“

“Tried we’ll be back to try the pizza too“

“I love the spinach pockets they make.“

“The best Pizza in town ! Family owned and very friendly and kind people!“

“Bought three slices of pizza here tonight.
The boss' service was very good and he patiently heated up the pizza. The brother who was sitting next to me drinking beer was also very friendly and told me that the similar looking pizzas were not the same, they used different cheese.
The pizza is really, really delicious. It's the best pizza I've ever had in Bloomfield.
It's a pity that the six point bar does not have such good service. They didn't believe my student ID and refused to sell me alcohol, however the bar opposite welcomed me warmly.
I actually had a really bad day, but because of the pizza here I feel healed and have the courage and enthusiasm to live, thank you.“

“Love the chicken California Panini!!“

“I was at the Belleville senior club and had the cheesesteak sandwish. I was delious“

“I ordered from my job once in a while and don't have time to call. Their online ordering system is amazing and you can write any note and they will actually read it and do what you need. I had a problem months ago and the owner actually called me and spoke with me. She was a very nice lady and the reason I haven't nixed the place. Food is delicious 😊 5 stars always!“

“Love the chicken parm & drunken grandma pie! BUT now I just had the apple Turnovers..omg delicious!!! even yummy heated next day. Not doughy..light and airy.😋“

“If you’re in Little Falls and craving some delicious pizza, Jojo Pizza is the place to be! Their Jojo Square Pizza is a must-try – perfectly crispy on the outside and delightfully soft on the inside, with just the right amount of cheese and toppings. Another standout is the Chicken Torrente Sandwich it’s packed with flavor and incredibly satisfying.
What makes Jojo Pizza even more special is the friendly and welcoming atmosphere, thanks to the owner, Junior. He goes above and beyond to ensure every customer feels at home. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, you’re in for a treat at Jojo Pizza!“

“Terrific food and staff. The family specials are a huge hit in our house. Great pizza too.“

“They just catered for my son’s 1st birthday party, couldn’t be more happier it was an amazing party topped with amazing food, can’t thank Brian & staff enough for helping with this special party.“

“Great staff. Excellent calzones. Generous with portions. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Passed this place a bunch of times. So I was hungry. So I said let’s give it a try. Well was amazing. Staff from moment walked in very friendly. Warm welcome. Started off with the Fire Roasted Wings (10) flame-broiled all-natural chicken wings marinated in fresh herbs & spices + lemon & herb dipping sauce Dough-Roni Pie Olli Salumeria pepperoni + tomato sauce + ricotta + fresh mozzarella + red onions Lemon Ricotta Ravioli Hand-made Ravioli + summer squash + fresh mint + pistachios + lemon zest + parmesan cheese Got off track sorry. Has seating at bar and has outside patio. (Was just a little to hot out there today) Very clean and definitely swinging by again. It’s right across street from Fairfield airport. Can’t forget the wine cooler before seated. There had to be 25+ wines to choose from.“

“Amazing! I just found my favorite pizza shop! If you’re looking for traditional jersey pie, you’re going to be disappointed.“

“My husband and I stopped by late Saturday night for dinner and pick up a couple of slices.The pizza was delicious, especially the Margherita and Boom Boom slices, even the garlic knots was great. The women at the cashier was extra nice and helpful.“

“top pie and the best crust and great staff“

“I love a good double Italian hotdog and the best place to get one is here! They have the freshest bread and the food just tastes incredible! They are reasonably priced and give you good portions. The only bad thing is that it's a cash only kind of place, so make sure to bring cash. The next time I near this area, I will definitely be back. Highly recommend!“

“Friendly service, warm cozy atmosphere.. impeccable ingredients and outstanding pizza! SAPORITO 🇮🇹“

“The pizza here is a 10 !!! No question about it.... heard Dave Portnoy rated Joes a 7.9. Portnoy is brain damaged, plain & simple. AGAIN - 10.0 !!!!!“

“Hands down my favorite Italian restaurant in the world, I'm there at least once per week. The portions are enormous (for two people at least) and their vodka sauce is to die for. I love pork chops too and my favorite salad is the string beans one - I could eat it every day. Maybe not the fancy looks but you will love their food, I promise you.“

“Always great food and attentive service!“

“Best eggplant parm around!“

“Food is absolutely amazing, staff very friendly, make you feel at home highly recommend“

“Wow! Tony's Pizzeria absolutely knocked it out of the park! From the moment I called, the phone staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, making the ordering process a breeze. But the real stars were the pizzas themselves.
The Margherita pizza was classic perfection, with fresh ingredients and a beautiful crust. And the Nduja pizza? Perfection. The rich, spicy flavor was perfectly balanced. Plus, the mac n cheese wedges were a fantastic, cheesy side. This is definitely a go-to pizza spot. 5 stars, hands down!“

“Great location great service over phone and in person! The customer is always right ? so glad to be fully outside this year and I tell you people of hill side this is definitely a spot/ location to check out now later or in the very very very very near future! Tell them 5 five star Most sent ? you! Good vibes only ? take care see ya again soon !!“

“at tom’s pizza it felt like a home great man great day great food it was just a great experience in all i loved every moment of this it was the best place in jersey for me its simply wonderful

Kid-friendliness: he treats all the kid with respect

Wheelchair accessibility: no“

“Hands-down, the best pizza I’ve ever had. Perfect in every way. Simply amazing. I wish we had it in South Florida.“

“This is a great place for lunch or dinner. No reservations taken so you have to wait. This place knows how to make bread. Their pizza was amazing! The prosciutto sandwich was more like a panini however great also! Their pastries are so flaky and fresh. The meatball appie with a dab of ricotta was outstanding. Will definitely return to try more!“

“Another new place tonight. Got delivery from grub hub. Got a Spinach & Cheese Roll which was filled with spinach and cheese made fresh. Some pepperoni chips which was pretty interesting. Beef, Chicken & Bacon Empanada which to me was a plain chicken empanada but was still good. Got a Vegetable Stromboli as well. Was packed with vegetables. Stromboli was a bit soggy but still was pretty good. Would definitely go again.“

“pizzaHQ has one of the best pizza around and delivery is fast and price is very good“

“The pizza was delicious! They don’t use any artificial or super-processed ingredients, so even the Coke was Mexican Coke that uses agave sweetener versus corn syrup! Casual but feels upscale.“

“I've been eating their pizza for over 20 years and in my opinion it's the best I've ever had. Their antipasto salad is delicious and always fresh and their spaghetti with meatballs is delicious. The owners "Vito and Mario" are always courteous and kind and so are the employees. Best pizza in town!!!

Kid-friendliness: The owners and employees are always courteous and kind.

Wheelchair accessibility: There are no stairs so the place is wheelchair accessible. You can just go in.“

“First time ordering from Carelli’s Pizza tonight. Pizza was so delicious! Crust was thin, just the right amount of sauce and cheese! Fast delivery! Will definitely order again! Also the disco fries are amazing! Staff and driver were super nice! Thank you!“