“This place is unbelievable!!! My husband and i went for a quick lunch date and man, our only regret is that we hadn't tried it sooner. We got a salad, broccoli rabe, and the classic pizza to share. Everything was amazing. The pizza was like being back in Italy. We also got the nutella desert which should be illegal. Cannot wait to try our way through the menus. So happy to have this wonderful spot in the neighborhood.“
“BEST pizza in Montclair/ Essex/NJ!So surprised it did not make it as the best pizza in Montclair magazine. Truly the BEST! We have tried 3 different flavors so far and all were DELICIOUS! Our family drives from uptown Montclair to this location! Excellent service and food! Thank you.“
“If you are looking for a delicious and authentic pizza, look no further than Sofia's Pizzeria. The staff is friendly and the service is quick. The prices are fair and the portions are generous. Sofia's Pizzeria is a great place to enjoy a meal with your loved ones.“
“Some legit AF pizza. Awesome crust, really good sauce, just the right amount of cheese and toppings. I've ordered from here a half dozen times via Slice. Great stuff. This is my go-to when I'm not in the mood for another spot's square-cut Roman style, which is probably my favorite pizza joint in Montclair. That said, LPH is a solid 4.5/5.“
“Bivio was divine! The pear, prosciutto and Burrata was so fresh. Both the pear and prosciutto were sliced super thin just the way I like it. The Margherita pizza was delicious and so was the special Ciao e Pepe pizza. I highly recommend! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“
“Tino’s has fast become our favorite pizzeria. Our young children always shout “Tino’s!” if I ask whether they want pizza for dinner. The pizzas are always great. We usually do pick up and eat at home but some times we go in to dine. The service is always great. Oh and for Valentines I asked if they could make a heart shaped pizza - it wasn’t advertised but I knew of another pizzeria doing it but didn’t want to go to another pizzeria. So I called and asked and they said we could request for one when we placed the order. We ordered two pizzas and one turned out better than the other but it didn’t matter. Our kids got a kick out of seeing a heart shaped pizza when they opened the box on Valentine’s Day.Highly recommend this place.“
“This is the old Roberto's that was in the pathmark plaza. Their not ur standard chicken/ pizza joint. I tell everyone don't sleep on this place! Their food is very good! And they have a pretty large selection! The husband and wife that own this spot r some of the best people I've ever met in my life!“
“Our favorite pizza. The corn meal addition gives it a nice texture. Quality ingredients, loaded with toppings. Calzone was also great, ricotta mixture. I don't mind paying more for quality and don't understand why people complain about it. Get a cheap fill elsewhere then.“
“We decided to try this place since we pass it all the time and it's the exact same distance from us as Mario's in Clifton, which has been a long-time go-to for us. The pizza here is fresh and DELICIOUS (and the crust - A+++), the service is timely and friendly, and you can tell it's a favorite local spot from all the people coming and going for pickups and deliveries. Some things to consider:- I've never had a pizza where they sprinkle garlic (chopped or maybe minced) on it by default - not even in Italy. That should not be a thing; the first time I ordered from there, I kept wondering why the taste was "off" and thankfully I ended up realizing it was the garlic since at first I wasn't going to order from them again. When I ordered subsequent times and told them not to sprinkle garlic on it, the taste was perfect.- They put a little more cheese on their pizza than I'm used to, so each slice is a bit "heavier" on the stomach. At first I thought they gave me extra cheese by mistake, but it wasn't.- It's definitely "Montclair pricing;" slightly more expensive than Mario's. However you are certainly getting what you pay for.All in all, I'd say it's worth checking out!“
“*Belch* It was a stormy night. I couldn't see two feet in front of me. however, there was a light in the darkness...a sign...was it...from G-d? It must have been! for what my eyes saw, was the warm, welcoming sign of Mr. Dino. He welcomed me in as if I was one of his own. He put his hand on my shoulder and said, "Son, what can I get for you?"I said, "One margarita, one Grandma and one cup of root beer." He smiled and said, "coming right up."I waited for not even three minutes. *clears throat* My food and beverage were presented to me. I took a bite into the Grandma's slice first. What I felt, was a wave of emotion and flavor. I felt the warmth of my grandmother, who was passed away for many years. :(I washed down the memories with a nice refreshing sip of root beer. I bit into the margarita, and it made me feel like a boy getting a slice with my father again. After I finished my meal, I looked outside to see the sun was shining. I paid. I left. I'll never forget what you have done for me Mr. Dino.With love, JPSomewhat based on true events.Vegetarian options: It's pizza, Enter at your own risk.Kid-friendliness: 100%Parking: Get there...EARLY.Wheelchair accessibility: Yep.Dietary restrictions: Maybe? Pizza.“
“Really really good pizza. It’s all done in the same shell. Plain and grandma were both stellar. The buffalo chicken slice was the standout in my opinion. Reasonable pricing too! Can’t wait to come back and try the deli side or their chicken parm. The thinly pounded cutlets looked incredible too.“
“We hosted a luncheon here for about 90 people - a total buyout of the restaurant - and it was perfection. The menu was family style and the food was delicious, beautifully presented and the sharing made for a really fun, friendly vibe among all the guests. And the cocktails look beautiful and taste even better.The service was wonderful - lovely, professional and very accommodating.They have a wireless mic and sound system, so you’re all set if you need to make toasts or anything.Would highly recommend and absolutely plan to be back for another event, or just dinner.Rich and Moe were particularly great to work with, and made our party a huge success.“
Pizza • $$
“One of my favorite spots in the area. The atmosphere is homey & laid back with eclectic cool vibes. Even though it was a busy Saturday afternoon The service is fast & friendly just how I love my customer service. Then on top of all that... the food is very good. I got a simple pizza slice and devoured it so mad I didn't get two slices. The menu has lots of options and everything looks great.“
“Love going to this place, service and food is always great. As a plus it’s also byob. Marlon is very attentive and makes you feel at home. I’m still to find something I don’t like, from the seafood risotto to the chicken parm to the mozzarella carozza everything is “
“Ah’Pizz was great. Delicious food I hade the steak medium rare and it was phenomenal. Service could have been a little better and dividing attention to all their table because we did have to ask 3 times for my son’s dessert a simple cup of ice cream. All in all we’d done here many times over.“
“Early dinner as we had to catch a show at the Wellmont. Amazing food especially the Appetizers! Great ambiance. Host Justin was super nice and accommodating. Our server was not very good. Took a very long time to take our drink orders and not attentive all evening. Restaurant wasn't busy at the time.“
“Not the style you’d expect from a brick oven place (crust is more puffy like a Papa John’s, except way tastier and with brick oven char) - but good pizza. I had a plain cheese, and it was a nice change of pace from the NY/NJ and Neapolitan style pies. Also had the churros which were great.“
“this is a must go to place the Staff is very friendly excellent food and the price was reasonable. The last time I went I had the Hotsytopsy shrimp and the Sorrentina pizza. Excellent with a nice red wine oh, by the way you have to bring your own..Parking: Parking on the street is free after 6pm. There are two lots in the area require walking a block or two“
“I was born and raised in Montclair 73 yrs. ago, lived on Forest St. I have been coming to this restaurant for years, even before Chris brought it from the original owner that had it (he and his brother worked there back then). To say the food is good is an understatement, it's fabulous. It's hard to find an Italian Pizzeria that knows sauce and how to make it, most places just dump tomatoe sauce in an pan without seasonings, not this place, all their products are fresh and are homemade. The raviolis, baked ziti and the other dishes are mountain sized and good, I should know as I worked in at least 5 pizza establishments in all my years. For the record I go there once a month and travel close to 75 miles to get there from there Pa. area. Best place around. Captain Jack“
“It was my first time at leone’s and I definitely will be returning! From the food to the service & vibe. But truly my server made my experience that much better. She listened to all my crazy accommodations and found the perfect dish for me. I will most definitely bring the rest of my family and request Angel! She made my experience a 10/10“
“I’ve been here twice, once with a late party and a party of 6 and both times we had incredible service and the food is delicious. Even the basics are incredible. No children’s menus so if your kids are picky then make sure to look at the selections. We had the chicken cutlet (served with a garlic parsley oil if you like), meatballs, margherita pizza, carbonara pizza. The carbonara pizza is to die for. Excellent marinara sauce and meatballs. Get the bread basket to soak up the sauce!“
“Great meal and overall time here! Our server was super nice and friendly/helpful he really guided us through the menu and gave some great suggestions. The restaurant itself is super nice and cozy while being spacious, but oh man the food is unreal. We had the meatballs (so big and flavorful and smothered in sauce), the mushroom pizza which was loaded with mushrooms, super flavorful and unique. Also got the vodka pizza which was really great, we got extra vodka sauce on the side so we could really drown it and loved it. My friend got the gluten free and she said it's the first gluten free bread she's had that actually tastes like real bread and loved it.“