Highlander Deli
717 Otterhole Rd, West Milford
(973) 874-0909
Customers' Favorites
Peanut Butter Bagel
Muffin
Ham
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Does Taylor ham, egg, and cheese ring a bell? Super unique sandwich menu, too. The town high school team is the Highlanders, and the sandwiches are named after teachers, coaches, and things in school. Those sandwiches may have been those people's preferred invention, and/or discovery.
Awsome place for breakfast but only on the week days. Weekends I won't go due to the people working. There not the friendliness on weekends nore do thay listen very well on what you want.Week days: employees are friendly they listen and communicate with the cooks to assure what i asked for gets cooked properly.Prices are cheep also....(to me at least) but it is CASH ONLY wich kinda aucks but not a deal breaker. Keep an eye out for spiderman (bear) he hangs out by the trash
We ordered a sandwhich, in the shape of the #5, for our daughters 5th birthday party. Had several conversations with the owners who couldn't be more helpful! From taking the order, to double-checking with the bread bakery for our requests, putting fresh add-ons on the side for us, to even unboxing instructions! And upon unboxing it, WOW! Everything was layered so neatly and symetrically, it was actually a thing of beauty in both taste and appearance! We are customers for...
You May Also Like
Vesuvio Pizza - 1223 Westbrook Rd
![]()
Pizza, Seafood
The Vreeland Store - 1383 Macopin Rd
![]()
Bar, American, Gluten-Free, New American, Vegan
Country Cottage - 1745 Macopin Rd
![]()
American, Bar, Burgers