8 Best Coffee Shops near Amagansett

“Rosie’s is such a gem! The food is outstanding. Everything feels fresh and made with care. I especially loved the scone (a must-try!) and the cocktails, which are some of the most creative I’ve had anywhere.

The staff goes above and beyond to make you feel welcome, and it’s clear they genuinely care about your experience. Can’t wait to come back!“

“Incredible vegan pasta salad, and the best black bean burger, and the coffee was fabulous!“

“I really like this location from the others. Everyone is professional and gets the job done. It's a hit or miss with crowdedness. One of our mornings we were the only ones there, another the line was out the door. It all depends I suppose.
I like the make coffee your way feature. I didn't have the pleasure of having an egg sandwich yet, I will one of these days. And their bagels are just my type. Our staple for mornings in Montauk. We'll be back soon :)“

“Love the coffee and the staff—I’m there at least 5 days a week!“

“So good! The chocolate chip cookie was one of the best cookies I’ve ever had in my entire life, and I loved all of the baked goods and the different grocery assortments. The iced soy latte was really good as well and it’s a beautiful store.“

“Iced latte and coffee were delicious and I got to choose from two kinds of espresso for my latte which was unique. Usually I'm never asked. The barista was super friendly too! The market has lots of great stuff and their backyard is beautiful. It is a little pricy (paid $13ish without tip for the coffee and iced latte) but I think that may be par for the course with this area. Would definitely return!“

“It’s a very unique Starbucks Shop.“

“The East Hampton Starbucks is hands-down one of the best Starbucks locations I’ve ever visited. From the moment you walk in, the staff greets you with genuine smiles and fast, friendly service. Even during busy summer mornings, they keep the line moving quickly without compromising quality. The drinks are always made perfectly—my iced coffee with cold foam came out smooth and balanced every time. The interior is clean and comfortable, with a modern vibe that fits right in with the Hamptons aesthetic. It’s a great place to grab your favorite drink and relax for a bit or take it to go while exploring the town. The location is super convenient, and the team behind the counter really seems to care about creating a good experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this Starbucks is a reliable go-to for top-tier coffee and excellent customer service.“