Restaurants near Baiting Hollow

“My husband and I have dined at the Cooperage Inn for many, many years. It literally is our favorite, and most definitely our go -to restaurant when friends from Queens and Nassau visit, as it never disappoints!! The food is absolutely delicious and always fresh; I had the lamb, which is the best and most tender I’ve ever had - the short rib pot pie awesome ? The staff makes you feel like family every visit. A shout out to Scott, who is always accommodating; a real sweetheart, and attentive to all his guests. Bella, our most recent waitress, was delightful and made the evening so enjoyable with her superior service and comedic charm. A perfect evening!”

“Exceptional Bakery! Delicious cakes and cookies! Wonderful Service! Great People! They went out of their way for my brother’s birthday and made his day! He loves his cake and cookies!!! Thank you.”

“Ice cream is out of this world, great staff and always nice people on line”

“The best vegan/gluten-free desserts I've ever had! Thank you for existing!”

“Very kind customer service ! Very clean on the inside”

“Went here for a birthday party for my 93 year old mother in law.. The staff could not have been any more accommodating or professional.. Extremely friendly and really did a fantastic job. A great experience .And the food was excellent.. Generous portions at a reasonable price..”

“BEST WINGS (simplest way to put it) Discovered them out East and now they're in Islip. Anthony's wings will ruin everybody else's. Crispy without being greasy and sauces are A+++. Go there.”

“Staff was great and the atmosphere was awesome. The buger I had was one of the best I've had in a while. their house burger sauce is could have drank out of a glass it was so good but even without it the burger would have stood out on its own. Juicy and perfectly cooked. With a nice cold Jetty 4, it was definitely a Cheeseburger in paradise.”

“Excellent casual seafood spot! Fresh, delicious and great selection! Service was excellent! Staff were outstanding! Loved this place! Well done, Jerry, Nicole et Al!!”

“The manger Sydney cares so much about her clients and the food is always great and well stocked! Tons of options and you walk in to not an employee but a friend!”

“Just had their food truck for an office meeting with lunch. Can't recommend them enough for the quality of the food and drinks. Everyone loved having them as part of our event.”

“The food is amazing. Had the pulled pork for lunch. It was cooked perfectly, not smothered in BBQ sauce. You just enjoy the taste of the pork....sweet potatoes, cole slaw and cornbread were great. Everyone was very friendly and owner walked around and said hello.”

“The best and most authentic polish food on Long Island. We celebrated my daughters first birthday this weekend. The food from Polka Deli was phenomenal. My guest were amazed by how good, fresh and tasty everything was! And it made my heart smile. I ordered staffed cabbage, bigos, kielbasa, pork lion in horseradish sauce, chicken Marsala, turkey meatballs, pierogies, pork shoulder with veggies, blitzes, potato wedges. Everything was amazing. I wont order from anywhere else for my holidays, parties and even dinner with friends! Why cook at home if you can easily say that you made it lol - it taste so good. I recommend Polka Deli for 100%, Anna puts her heart into it and you can taste it in her food. Very accommodating and friendly staff and lots of polish delicatessen on top of the best homemade cooked food.”

“We love Brekkys. The best Acai Bowls! The Super Goat Toast is so yummy. Love getting a delicious Ronnie too! Owner Marty is super nice with a great staff. Place is also super cute.”

“Best iced caramel macchiato !!”

“First visit. Brian and Beth were very welcoming drinks food and atmosphere great will return soon”

“Wonderful service and great food! I highly recommend it.”

“I highly recommend Long Island farm brewery great place for beers and good time with friends. Make sure you ask for Nick.”

“Had dinner last night with a friend, food was excellent and the Fall sangria even better!”

“Fish Guy Thursday Talks and great Food Trucks”

“The Doxie Derby was by far the most fun I had with my dog and all the participants, dog and human alike!!
The weather was perfect and so was the winery for this being the first time they had this event.It was so nice to see all different types of Dachshunds and their people!It was worth the registration fee to let my dog and I enjoy the fun filled event!
We'll be back next year!”

“No frills, just great food, FAST service with warm small town feel. The bacon and blueberry pancakes were delicious.
NASCAR memorabilia reminded me of my dad and uncle Bobby Filler's stock car/dragster days ❤️”

“Great day in Riverhead we stopped in for lunch. Very cool place the bartender was so nice”

“Food is always excellent.”

“Great food and atmosphere”

“GREAT food...friendly and inviting... ALL FIVE STARS from me!”

“My staff & I just enjoyed another delicious lunch from Wine Country deli. Everyone loved their choice. I ordered todays special panini turkey & Brie and it was fantastic. The orders are always accurate and the staff very friendly. Thank you 🙏”

“Tommy helped me and my partner out, we came in for lunch and got the Drunken Barrata. We were torn between that and the Fig n Pig and went with his suggestion. We enjoyed the meal and had a great time. He was personable and we will be back!”

“Came on the recommendation of Adam at Coffee Pot Cellars. Fabulous lunch! We will definitely be back!”

“What a delicious meal. Drinks were strong, service was superb. We can’t wait to come back.”