9 Best Italian Restaurants near Batavia

“Stopped here on the way to a show in Niagara Falls. Reasonable prices, good food.“

“I liked everything about this place. The food was awesome and the atmosphere was super cool. On our way from Niagara we found this cool place and had a pit stop for lunch. Kids enjoyed the lunch. We had sphegatti, Alfredo, Lobster soup and Pizza which was customized to our liking as we don't like Beef. Thanks a ton to the person who serviced us. He really was too cool from the time he met us until our billing. He even gave us a chocolate tower cake billed on house. The cake was full of chocolate and delicious. If I have anyone visiting to NY on this way I would surely recommend this place for anyone who wish to have a nice Italian Food“

“Food was very good, portion sizes were generous, and the service was great. It was obviously a placed favored by locals. If you are in the area and looking for a good meal at a fair price, I recommend this diner.

A note on the atmosphere - the place hasn't been updated in a while but it's not run down. The atmosphere is friendly, not fancy. I was fine with that.“

“I ordered a chicken finger sub last night. No lie, it was the best sub I’ve ever had. Great job“

“Great food & great service!“

“I booked reservations for my father’s 70th birthday at the Clubhouse at Batavia Downs, but later received a call that they were double booked. That’s when Rosalie from Fortune's stepped in to save the day. She reassured me that my father’s celebration would be just as special, if not better—and she delivered! Rosalie thoughtfully selected a table with a beautiful view of the racetrack and even helped arrange a cake to complete the celebration. She even came by to take a picture of our group, which was such a thoughtful touch.

Our servers, Terri and Ryleigh, were also exceptional—attentive, friendly, and made sure everything ran smoothly. Rosalie checked in on our party multiple times to make sure all our needs were met, which we truly appreciated.

Thanks to Rosalie, Terri, and Ryleigh, my father’s 70th birthday turned out to be a wonderful experience we’ll always remember.“

“One of my favorite spots to eat with friends in Batavia! Great wings! Pizza is excellent! Love their slices! Try the chicken wing dip 😋

Kid-friendliness: Yes kid-friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp near parking lot.“

“Great experience, cannot wait to go again. I love the lanes and environment. Keep up the great work Rusty Rail Bar & Grill.“

“fast service, good food, very polite.“